Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

tony soprano said:
My guess garner is getting low balled
Click to expand...
How do you define "lowballed"? Because I take it to mean "offered less than he is worth". Which presumably isn't happening to Garner - by this stage if he was worth more presumably someone would have offered it to him and he'd have taken it. I think it's more likely that he, or more likely his agent, thought he would have had more of a market than has eventuated. Which is not surprising given he is a completely bog average player.
 
2041 said:
How do you define "lowballed"? Because I take it to mean "offered less than he is worth". Which presumably isn't happening to Garner - by this stage if he was worth more presumably someone would have offered it to him and he'd have taken it. I think it's more likely that he, or more likely his agent, thought he would have had more of a market than has eventuated. Which is not surprising given he is a completely bog average player.
Click to expand...

Bloke in a bar, made a comment they rate him and undervalued, assuming they have contact with players or player circles could be a reflection of the truth.

I think he was ok last year. Still the best we have at present. Hopefully a big year him. Been unlucky with injury
 
GNR4LIFE said:
Anyone hear anything about us signing Franklin Pele from the Sharks? Dude is bigger than Stefano. 121kgs.
Click to expand...
there's always been whispers that we're interested in him, but it's gone cold the past few months. he'd be perfect off the bench for us, he is a deadset wrecking ball and has a ridiculous amount of pace for a bloke his size.
 
tony soprano said:
Bloke in a bar, made a comment they rate him and undervalued, assuming they have contact with players or player circles could be a reflection of the truth.

I think he was ok last year. Still the best we have at present. Hopefully a big year him. Been unlucky with injury
Click to expand...
We're definitely going to need him this year but I won't be totally devastated if we don't have him in 2023 to be honest. He's a B- player in attack and generously a C in defence. That's fine as far as it goes: every team needs serviceable first grade players. But I wouldn't want to be using any sort of significant chunk of the salary cap on him.
 
nuggetron said:
RE tuilagi - if a guy has signed elsewhere for 23 and is only a rookie surely we are better off throwing the game time at someone who will be here for 23 and possibly beyond if that is our premiership window
what's the go with garner, he was touted to manly for all of last year and remains un-signed next year is he done and dusted
Click to expand...
We don't have anyone that fits that bill. Only have 4 second rowers in our top 29 players, one is gone the other three are average or unknown. No other candidates from last years NSW Cup side that could get a promotion. And then we have a bunch of 19 year olds who have barely played at any grade in the last couple of years. So yeah we have to sign someone from outside the club, and some with experience or go even harder for the qld boys
 
Fade.To.Black said:
Matterson "ripped in"? That's not what I would call it when someone gets their blouse in a knot, kicks stones and moped about and basically holds a club to ransom until they kick his arse to the exit.
Sure he had a handful of games where he did some good things but I can't recall him doing anything much in defence and being a physical minder for the halves.
Plus once Packer and then Kaufusi bounced his head like a squash ball IMO since then he's been badly damaged goods. No thanks.
Click to expand...
I have never had reason to doubt Matterson's courage or on-field playing standard. His collision with Packer was normal for the NRL, two big forwards coming together. Matterson did not shirk the contact and took a knock. I wouldn't be the least concerned if we could sign him to boost second row depth.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Members online

Total: 435 (members: 38, guests: 397)
Back
Top