Brooks Bashers Bore Me

Status
Not open for further replies.
Blake said:
Brooks received the ball 60 times and Tigers completed 33 sets. So what are you talking about?

The wildly differing opinions about Brooks is caused by confirmation bias. Also I think that there is a certain type of person that feels better when they rant and blame someone, it doesn't have to be true, but they feel better.

You hobbo1, only see what you want to see. If Brooks was as bad as you think he is, why has he played 174 first grade games? Why do other teams want to buy him (now and in the past)? Why does he get paid an unknown but very large amount of money?

The choices are:-
1. hobbo1 knows far more than all the people that run and coach NRL clubs
2. hobbo1 is wrong about Brooks, and does not see reality when he/she watches a game.

I'm pretty sure its number 2.
Click to expand...
Reynolds, Mbye, Packer etc got paid probably more, they deserved those checks huh. Newcastle were the only reported team that wanted him, they now have Clifford and Clune in the halves, so its safe to say they were scraping the bottom of the barrel, besides any other club (inc Newcastle) wouldn't touch brooks if not a large large proportion of his pay is handled by us. I get the point your coming from, but using brooks's salary and the amount of games hes played are very poor points to convey your opinion, those figures are the way they are because of the wests tigers.
 
Last edited:
The only reason he Brooks still here is we can’t find a cub stupid enough to pay the ridiculous amount of money we give him …And that’s the only reason he played so many games cause of the amount we pay this turd 💩
 
Blake said:
Because the qualified and experienced people that put their careers on the line and are professional coaches and administrators are not Brooks haters. I think it is more likely that they are right and the people that thinks Brooks is a bad player that should not be playing first grade are wrong.
Click to expand...
The term “Brooks Haters” is juvenile and simplistic at best.
People criticising him are not saying he is a bad player. They are saying that we just witnessed another game he failed to close out. It happens too regularly. He is not improving, not evolving. He has hit his ceiling and after 9 years of failure he has had his turn.
 
One of our own. Holy cross rhino, he's like Farah at henley park, enfield federal. Be quite I won't allow slander (at least for tonight I dunno)
 
Blake said:
Brooks received the ball 60 times and Tigers completed 33 sets. So what are you talking about?

The wildly differing opinions about Brooks is caused by confirmation bias. Also I think that there is a certain type of person that feels better when they rant and blame someone, it doesn't have to be true, but they feel better.

You hobbo1, only see what you want to see. If Brooks was as bad as you think he is, why has he played 174 first grade games? Why do other teams want to buy him (now and in the past)? Why does he get paid an unknown but very large amount of money?

The choices are:-
1. hobbo1 knows far more than all the people that run and coach NRL clubs
2. hobbo1 is wrong about Brooks, and does not see reality when he/she watches a game.

I'm pretty sure its number 2.
Click to expand...
Lol
Whatever you reckon .
When the games on the line Brooks is shithouse !
Please tell me again what we’re paying him for ?
Punt him !
 
Blake said:
Because the qualified and experienced people that put their careers on the line and are professional coaches and administrators are not Brooks haters. I think it is more likely that they are right and the people that thinks Brooks is a bad player that should not be playing first grade are wrong.
Click to expand...
Keep thinking bud
This is the most piss poor run NRL club there is !
This joints a job for the boys club
Wether it’s a CEO gig , coaches gig , if your an out of work player or a player that what’s to top up his super .
But hey .. hat sales are up lol 😂

The sooner this dump of a club is privately owned the better cause at the moment there’s zero accountability!!
P.s Brooks sucks
 
Cheffo said:
I challenge this Forum to give the Brooks bashing a rest. It’s boring and monotonous. We get it. Yep, it’s frustrating he hasn’t become the player we hoped he would be, but the constant bleating is such a bore. I challenge the Forum to go a week without whinging about Brooks!!!!
Click to expand...
I challenge Madge to go one week without picking him
 
Chicken_Faced_Killa said:
are people really suggesting we run out with a Madden Peachy halves combo? I think Brooks and the club should part ways for everyone’s sake but that combo is worse. Brooks is here for the year and will be the 7 for most of it
Click to expand...
I've seen nothing from Peachy to suggest he will do anything great. He's new at the club and probably needs some time but I haven't been impressed with anything he's done so far, certainly wouldn't be putting his name forward as a halves potential. Im still pissed at his stupid penalty/sin bin last week followed by his visual response after being sinbinned. He's a 14, rover type player at best.
 
hobbo1 said:
Keep thinking bud
This is the most piss poor run NRL club there is !
This joints a job for the boys club
Wether it’s a CEO gig , coaches gig , if your an out of work player or a player that what’s to top up his super .
But hey .. hat sales are up lol 😂

The sooner this dump of a club is privately owned the better cause at the moment there’s zero accountability!!
P.s Brooks sucks
Click to expand...
Ur up late old man.
Drowning your sorrows?
 
I've had a change of heart.
It's the team that's shit, not my mate brooksy.
He tries to carry the team but they are useless.
Just ignore them buddy, another dally m is on its way.
 
GNR4LIFE said:
People will justify anything to drop Brooks. Apparently he was as bad as Laurie, even though he was our most potent attacking weapon.
Click to expand...
Imagine if it happens.. (it probably wont)
And it actually works.
 
  • Like
Reactions: PJ_
Demps said:
Imagine if it happens.. (it probably wont)
And it actually works.
Click to expand...
He’s had a lot worse games and held his place. You even said yourself he just missed out on your 3,2,1, so he can’t be dropped on last nights effort if he was one of our better players.
 
GNR4LIFE said:
He’s had a lot worse games and held his place. You even yourself he just missed out on your 3,2,1, so he can’t be dropped on last nights effort if he was one of our better players.
Click to expand...
I was only joking about that.
I said maybe he's 4th...
He wasnt......

I said he wasn't the worst.
I just truly know a happy divorce for he and the club is drastically needed.
 
GNR4LIFE said:
He’s had a lot worse games and held his place. You even said yourself he just missed out on your 3,2,1, so he can’t be dropped on last nights effort if he was one of our better players.
Click to expand...
The only reason he's one of the best is that all of the others are shithouse retarded
 
Demps said:
I was only joking about that.
I said maybe he's 4th...
He wasnt......

I said he wasn't the worst.
I just truly know a happy divorce for he and the club is drastically needed.
Click to expand...
You’re talking what ifs. What if Laurie swallows that ball and falls over the line and the ref goes upstairs for Luc’s try and it’s awarded? We win, and the narrative would be very different. He had absolutely no luck no last night.
 
GNR4LIFE said:
You’re talking what ifs. What if Laurie swallows that ball and falls over the line and the ref goes upstairs for Luc’s try and it’s awarded? We win, and the narrative would be very different. He absolutely no luck no last night.
Click to expand...
No fate but what you make.

Luke isn't a winner.
NEXT.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Latest posts

Members online

Total: 346 (members: 4, guests: 342)
Back
Top