Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

[Buttface]

Sims is unwanted at Saints as he has a huge error rate and, most weeks, is poor.

He has about 2 great games a year...one happened to be in Origin.

And about ten bad games.

With us...no real motivation or pressure...you'd be lucky to get one great game. More likely to get tons of bad ones.

Def no thanks to Sims.

Packer x2?

 

[Buttface]

I don’t know if you’ve noticed mate but we are struggling to sign good players. Fans like you who turn your nose up at origin players, well, good luck.

I think like a lot of us he doesn’t want to get stuck with another has been, and I reckon his assessment of Simms is pretty fair, he is also on the decline.

 

[BAGNF05]

I think like a lot of us he doesn’t want to get stuck with another has been, and I reckon his assessment of Simms is pretty fair, he is also on the decline.

Maybe he is but 11 months ago he was good enough for origin and he’s tougher than our blokes. Might actually smash a halfback or two. Two year deal max. Can’t see us doing better tbh

 

[Lauren]

Just watched the interview with Talakai and wasn't aware he made his NRL debut under Madge. Why haven't we gone for him?
He's someone I'd love for the club to land.

 

[Furious1]

Maybe he is but 11 months ago he was good enough for origin and he’s tougher than our blokes. Might actually smash a halfback or two. Two year deal max. Can’t see us doing better tbh

I don't know mate. I like your train of thought, and believe we need some hard experienced players to lead us from the wilderness as other clubs have had successfully in the past, but just wonder whether Simms has it in him week in week out.

 

[BAGNF05]

I don't know mate. I like your train of thought, and believe we need some hard experienced players to lead us from the wilderness as other clubs have had successfully in the past, but just wonder whether Simms has it in him week in week out.

I agree it’s a gamble. I’m a gambler.

 

[Cobarcats]

Maybe he is but 11 months ago he was good enough for origin and he’s tougher than our blokes. Might actually smash a halfback or two. Two year deal max. Can’t see us doing better tbh

I certainly wouldn't put Sims in Packers mold.
Sims is still physically tough and fit. He'd be a good signing at the right price.
Understand people's fear of recruiting older players.
We've been burnt in that area before.

 

[BAGNF05]

I certainly wouldn't put Sims in Packers mold.
Sims is still physically tough and fit. He'd be a good signing at the right price.
Understand people's fear of recruiting older players.
We've been burnt in that area before.

Plenty have worked out e.g Luke Lewis

 

[Cobarcats]

Plenty have worked out e.g Luke Lewis

That's true, but then again if Luke Lewis came to present time in the same physical condition as when he went to the Sharks, I would pick him over Sims.
Another however!
If Sims was in our team from round 1, he would probably be our best forward 🤔

 

[Tweed_Tiger]

Hopefully we go after Taylan May if he isn't already signed up for next year.

 

[Demps]

Hopefully we go after Taylan May if he isn't already signed up for next year.

Penrith boy for life ud think

 

[Cobarcats]

Hopefully we go after Taylan May if he isn't already signed up for next year.

Pretty sure he's only with the Pamfers for this year.
Last I heard the club was waiting the outcome of the assault charges before contract talks.

 

[Viking Warrior]

Dolphins have made it hard for us to recruit quality

 

[weststigerman]

I think we have enough money tied up with wingers.

Bigger issues everywhere inside the wingers.

 

[Viking Warrior]

I think we have enough money tied up with wingers.

Bigger issues everywhere inside the wingers.

I disagree we need some pace out there

 

[weststigerman]

I disagree we need some pace out there

They would be like JAC at the dogs. Wasted.

 

[BAGNF05]

That's true, but then again if Luke Lewis came to present time in the same physical condition as when he went to the Sharks, I would pick him over Sims.
Another however!
If Sims was in our team from round 1, he would probably be our best forward 🤔

A fully fit Sims/papali’i backrow would get me excited

 

[GNR4LIFE]

Hopefully we go after Taylan May if he isn't already signed up for next year.

Very wishful thinking

 

[Cobarcats]

A fully fit Sims/papali’i backrow would get me excited

It will be hard but I'll see if I can find when I said last year that we should chase Sims 😀

 

[GNR4LIFE]

Dolphins have made it hard for us to recruit quality

We’ve done that all on our own.