Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

Ciraldo would be best. If not, Flannagan, which hurts me to say considering his previous actions, should be the next go to considering he has had premiership success and experience dragging a basket case up to a finals contender.

Morris would be far too soft on this lot and is more likely to be the players friend than hold them accountable. While he may be a good coach one day, I don't think he would be good for the club.
 
Batmans Parents said:
I've my own experiences in being assaulted by three men whilst walking home from school so I do have experience in similar thing like that which is why I can sympathise why you wouldn't want him here. There's no denying the guy is a piece of sh#t human but he's been convicted, given a punishment (yes I agree, it was inadequate and he deserved far worse) and has since been approved to return and has played for multiple clubs.

To call him average is wrong and not based in reality for anyone who has watched him play. He would bring aggression and go-forward to a forward pack that is severely lacking both of those thing.

You can make all the moral decisions you want but at the end of the day, this club will continue to have piss all success if it makes its decision based on morals. You try to get the best players available who can contribute to areas of the team that are lacking which is why Lodge should be signed. I don't want him here but I do think he would benefit the team in terms of results which is what the club is sorely lacking.
Click to expand...
You don’t want him here. That’s says it all for me. Thanks. But I disagree with your opinion on quality. I’m going to cook dinner. Enjoyed it though.
Due to the nature of the content of my post I will be deleting it.
 
Batmans Parents said:
I've my own experiences in being assaulted by three men whilst walking home from school so I do have experience in similar thing like that which is why I can sympathise why you wouldn't want him here. There's no denying the guy is a piece of sh#t human but he's been convicted, given a punishment (yes I agree, it was inadequate and he deserved far worse) and has since been approved to return and has played for multiple clubs.

To call him average is wrong and not based in reality for anyone who has watched him play. He would bring aggression and go-forward to a forward pack that is severely lacking both of those thing.

You can make all the moral decisions you want but at the end of the day, this club will continue to have piss all success if it makes its decision based on morals. You try to get the best players available who can contribute to areas of the team that are lacking which is why Lodge should be signed. I don't want him here but I do think he would benefit the team in terms of results which is what the club is sorely lacking.
Click to expand...
Personally I wouldn’t go there due to inconsistent form and discipline, and potential impact on an already poor culture.

But, if the club think he’s worth a shot, that’s where we need to give him a chance to explain himself and his motives. Based on that conversation/s you might sign him. This is an area I believe the club has a really poor record over the last 5 years or so. You listen to half our players interviewed and try and disagree with me.
 
tiger_scott said:
Matterson fills a position of need for us though: backrow. I think now that Madge is gone he would come back. Of the backrowers on the "off contract" list, there's not a lot of quality. Ignoring his "exit strategy", he's one of the better ones available.
Click to expand...
I wouldn't ignore his exit strategy at all; rather it is the entire reason I would never sign him again.

He can stay with his other little btch mate at Parramatta or anywhere else they don't care about players crying their way out of their contract.
 
Newtown said:
The Roar 1 hour ago.

Adam Doueihi has declared he wants to play in the halves long term at Wests Tigers setting up a looming squeeze of three playmakers into two positions. Doueihi will make his long-awaited return from his ruptured ACL on Sunday against Canterbury, after 10 long months of rehab.
The Lebanon star will come off the bench and expects to play limited minutes in the backline at CommBank Stadium, as he settles back into full fitness.



But he has made no secret of his desire to claim back the Tigers No.6 jersey. Doueihi was the easily the club’s best last year before his late-season injury, before Jackson Hastings arrived and partnered Luke Brooks this season. “Long-term I definitely see myself in the halves. No.6 or No.7,” Doueihi said. “I probably prefer No.6. Anywhere in the halves down the track is where I see I will be most comfortable.”

Doueihi, Hastings and Brooks are all off contract next year, with a crucial decision ahead on how the Tigers best manage the trio. Hastings had initially been brought to the club with the thought he could be used as a ball-playing lock, which potentially remains an option.
Doueihi meanwhile said there was no chance he himself would fill that kind of role, but was yet to speak interim coach Brett Kimmorley or head of football Tim Sheens over his long-term role.












​










​






























​




​






Continue reading
Click to expand...
Yeah he's got talent and leadership. Still needs to work on a few things though.

Better than Brooks however.
 
Could be a handy back up after Lucy leaving and may not be to expensive for the rest of the season and then look at him for next year if he goes ok
 
tiger_scott said:
From https://www.zerotackle.com/rugby-league/players/off-contract-2022/, the list of off-contract players available for next year (and beyond).

NRL PLAYERS OFF CONTRACT 2022 | NRL CONTRACTS
A complete list of NRL players who are off contract at the end of the 2022 rugby league season.

BRONCOS
Delouise Hoeter, Ryan James, Albert Kelly, Rhys Kennedy, David Mead, Corey Oates, Keenan Palasia, Jake Turpin, Billy Walters

RAIDERS
Matt Frawley, Ryan Sutton

BULLDOGS
Matt Doorey, Matt Dufty, Raymond Faitala-Mariner, Reece Hoffman, Tui Katoa, Joe Stimson, Jackson Topine, Paul Vaughan, Brandon Wakeham

SHARKS
Jayden Berrell, Andrew Fifita, Wade Graham, Mawene Hiroti, Royce Hunt, Matt Moylan, Briton Nikora, Franklin Pele, Aiden Tolman

DOLPHINS

TITANS
Herman Ese'ese, Esan Marsters, Kevin Proctor

SEA EAGLES
Morgan Boyle, Andrew Davey, Manase Fainu, Sione Fainu, Jorge Taufua, Martin Taupau

STORM
Tom Eisenhuth, Dean Ieremia, George Jennings, Cooper Johns, Chris Lewis, Jayden Nikorima, Young Tonumaipea

WARRIORS
Daejarn Asi, Temple Kalepo, Dunamis Lui, Freddy Lussick, Jack Murchie, Pride Petterson-Robati, Junior Ratuva

KNIGHTS
Phoenix Crossland, Anthony Milford, Jirah Momoisea, Brayden Musgrove, Pasami Saulo, Sauaso Sue

COWBOYS
Kane Bradley, Mitchell Dunn, Brendan Elliot, Brendan Frei, Ben Hampton, Jordan McLean, Emry Pere

EELS
Ryan Matterson, Solomone Naiduki, Tom Opacic, Hayze Perham

PANTHERS
Eddie Blacker, Christian Crichton, Matthew Eisenhuth, Kurt Falls, Sean O'Sullivan, Jaeman Salmon, Chris Smith

RABBITOHS
Michael Chee-Kam, Lachlan Gale, Josh Mansour, Steven Marsters, Taane Milne, Jaxson Paulo, Isaiah Tass, Izaac Thompson

DRAGONS
Billy Burns, Poasa Faamausili, Jackson Ford, Jack Gosiewski, Josh McGuire, Tautau Moga

ROOSTERS
Angus Crichton, Moala Graham-Taufa, Lachlan Lam, Kevin Naiqama

WESTS TIGERS
Luke Garner, William Kei, Jock Madden, Tommy Talau, James Tamou

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Obviously $$$ dictates who we target, but personally I would be looking at:

Ryan Sutton, Raymond Faitala-Mariner, Jackson Topine, Nikora, Franklin Pele, Kevin Proctor, Sione Fainu, Jorge Taufua, Ryan Matterson, Tom Opacic, Angus Crichton, Lachlan Lam

And retain:

Jock Madden, Tommy Talau

Obviously we all have a different take/value, but what I think it does show is that there is not a lot out there. Parra, Melbourne and the Dolphins will also be trying to do the same. Players (managers) have the upper hand atm.

One thing in our favour is our newly declared development club status, which means we should have the most money in our cap available for a few high value targets, seeing as how most of club should be "kids" on lower money.
Click to expand...
From that list I’d be looking to sign Billy Walters, Reece Hoffmann, Andrew Fafita, Esan Masters, Marty Taupau, Sauaso Sue, Kane Bradley, Ryan Matterson, Matt Eisenhuth, Michael Cher-Kam, Kevin Naiqama.

May as well get the band back together
 
TurnStyle said:
I wouldn't ignore his exit strategy at all; rather it is the entire reason I would never sign him again.

He can stay with his other little btch mate at Parramatta or anywhere else they don't care about players crying their way out of their contract.
Click to expand...
Yep, he isn’t coming back. He bagged out the club on his way out and I’m sure anyone that was at the club when he left would not want him back.

Career wise he is one head knock away from retiring anyway so best to avoid.
 
Last edited:
stevo133 said:
I’m not sure if Cameron Ciraldo is going to be wests tigers coach he must be interested if he spent 6 hours with sheens, Lee and Justin
Click to expand...
6 hours.. How do you know that ?
Not been rude or challenging you just 6 hours is a long time and you would not want to give too much away to a potential coach unless they are confident etc..
If this is true its a good sign IMO
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Members online

Total: 705 (members: 1, guests: 704)
Back
Top