the return Warriors game.WOW
Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion
- Thread starter MacDougall
- Start date
A
Agreed
Lodge and Brown would add some aggression that is badly needed..
We need to address the forwards urgently as getting flogged weekly done not help your brand.
The thought of facing Penrith is nightmare stuff.
supercoach
Well-known member
Kentwell cup was the rugby comp I played in, I played for the bank nsw
No idea.
Tb honest, I wouldn’t be opposed to Lauri being given some time at 5/8 and playing To’a back there.
Id consider a decent contract for Ruben Garrick to leave manly and play fullback.
He is robust and quick, and quickly developing the skills needed there through exposure. Manly have an abundance of outside backs.
Yep, played there too. It was like concrete too but the worst thing was the sideline which ran at a completely weird angle to the grandstand. Our wingers could never handle it, they used to run out all the time when they ran down the grandstand side.
Mighty_Tiger
Well-known member
It won’t be
Mighty_Tiger
Well-known member
Feel for Noddy
The problem is the chicken comes before the egg.
That is the law of attraction.
You have to be appearing attractive to attract someone or something. Or you just throw a lot of cash at something as an alternative.
Hanging out for the next huge marquee to be interested in helping a bunch of kids grow within this comp is not realistic.
We need some experienced players in and around the squad to complement.
It doesn’t have to cost us an arm and a leg but it will be a worthwhile consideration of our cap money.
The problem with our past signings
Cleary era.
Paid over the odds for average to good players at the top of their game.
If, Packer, Matolino and Reynolds were fit and firing 2 seasons in to their contract it’s possible they wouldn’t of been terrible signings but they declined and we’re surrounded by other players on a similar decline.
Madge era.
Tried to bye players that can deliver the culture without being able to deliver a performance.
Tamou peachy etc are value signings from a cost perspective. But from an output perspective they were also on the decline,
paid a bench salary but we’re signed with the hope that we can extract starter performances from them.
Both strategies had merit and could of paid off to a point.
But they failed because the personal they contracted were on a decline.
Similar to signing Nathan Brown.
We might pick him up for 500k, he will work his but off in defence but will wear out quicker then he would at a club where he isn’t the focus. So you need to ask yourself if your signing Nathan brown on his own, is he worth 500? What if he lasts 1-2 seasons max.
TurnStyle
Well-known member
Wow. These are some of my thoughts exactly!
I talk about the tigers with my dad and I said when Garrick was still very new to first grade the tigers should seriously go after him. Very solid, fast player who is an awesome kicker; Exactly what they have needed for so long.
Might get shouted down, but I just don't see Laurie ever becoming a great full back. Any position if I'm honest.
He was good last season and has been good (mostly) this year, but to me he just looks like he plays better than the player he really is, if that makes sense? Punching above his weight and I don't think he'll sustain it long term.
Apart from the game before last, he is never there for an offload and is caught out of position often. In fairness, he pulls off a few try saving tackles, but he'd be close to missing just as many letting them in.
I like To'a much better there and think he's worth investing in for that position.
Also, in reply to an earlier post, Garrick is a far better full back and he isn't even his club's first choice. Admittedly, he is behind Trbojevic, but still I wouldn't have Laurie anywhere near the (equal?) 5th best in the comp.
I think you could add Papenhuyzen, Sloan, Mitchell, Hynes, Brimson, Meaney, Wighton and Gutherson as better full backs to those already mentioned and a couple don't even play there any more.
PS: I played fullback. At my peak, I reckon I would have been ranked around 12,832nd in Australia. 😉
tony soprano
Well-known member
Twal is a weird one.
Watched the hit. Seem light contact to start with that knocked him out and may have had a secondary knock on impact with the ground.
Reminds me when ufc fighters loose their chin from too many head knocks and get knocked out easily.
Think he is a high probability to retirement
TurnStyle
Well-known member
I'm not so sure it's an accumulated affect - just a very heavy hit with no give (ground impact).
When they showed it, I think Burton was pissed at the hit (for some reason?) and as they landed his forearm/fend slammed his head into the turf like he was grounding a try.
Not implying he meant to intentionally hurt him, but his head had nowhere further to travel having hit the ground whilst the brain continued its momentum towards a stationary skull, meaning the meninges had far less impact absorption.
Dr TurnStyle
C
Cobarcats
Guest
Wow, it's like I've just jumped into a time machine.
kentwell cup was were Hornsby 4th grade played,before the club shifted 2 the Central coast comp 6-8 years ago
C
Cobarcats
Guest
Played both 74-79, god it's like steppin into a time machine.
C
Cobarcats
Guest
Are you saying you played there mate?
for Hornsby union ,yes,77/ 80,home ground was Wiatara oval,next door now 2 Asquith Leagues club,i lie 2 you not
C
Cobarcats
Guest
Prob played against you old fart, thats my era
Staff online
-
Suzie-QModerator