Maguire didn't create the problem nor could he fix it. The problem lies in the club's ability to recruit and retain a roster capable of competing and playing finals footy. It was a problem before he came and it still is and until that changes all coaches will suffer from the same fate. The exact reason why our main target for coach said thanks but no thanks.Maguire signed up for the role, he wasn't forced. How long would you give him to "turn" matters around? Another 3.5 years?