Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

Earl said:
It's good to hear something positive.

I hope you are right. How much is AD worth though. You could basically play another centre in that position and you'd get pretty close to the same output.

Brooks is clearly better than AD and walks into our top team but he isn't worth top dollar.

Would we be a better team with a quality 6 and Hastings at 7.
Click to expand...
Here we go again,
we should have enough money to be able to let 7 or 8 move to other clubs, and buy at least 5 or 6 top liners, why are we now saying, things like we will keep brooks, but only if we can retain him for $500.000, He has really done nothing in the 9 years he has been at the club, do you really think paying him half price will make him play any better.

LET'S TAKE NOTICE OF WHAT THE DOGS ARE DOING, THEY ARE GETTING RID OF ALL THE RUBBISH, AND BUYING PLAYERS THAT ARE GO GETTEM PLAYERS, AND WHEN THEY HAVE FINISHED WITH GETTING ALL THE NEW ONES, TO JOIN TOGETHER WITH THE ONES THEY GOT THIS YEAR FOR NEXT YEAR THEY WILL FINISH
WITH A TOP 8 TEAM.

IT LOOKS LIKE WE ARE SETTLING FOR THE SAME TYPES OF PLAYERS WE ALREADY HAVE.
AND UNLESS WE PURCHASE SOME MORE TOP NAMES.

THEN WE ARE HEADING FOR THE SAME PLACE WE HAVE JUST REACHED.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 851
Might be unpopular and i certainly feel conflicted typing this but is Woods an upgrade on the muppets we had ambling around in the front row yesterday?
 
Dennisspicer1 said:
Here we go again,
we should have enough money to be able to let 7 or 8 move to other clubs, and buy at least 5 or 6 top liners,
Click to expand...

It's not fantasy footy mate. You can't just let 7 or 8 go and get 5 or 6 top liners. No club does this. Not the Dogs and definitely not Melbourne or Penrith.

Dennisspicer1 said:
why are we now saying, things like we will keep brooks, but only if we can retain him for $500.000, He has really done nothing in the 9 years he has been at the club, do you really think paying him half price will make him play any better.
Click to expand...

He can fill a role for a short time period and we can get better players around him plus we can use that money to get top liners or hold onto juniors who are top liners.

I wish we could do what you suggest. I wish it was that easy. We've signed 2 top liners for next year but there are no more on the market and getting them is hard.
 
Last edited:
Dennisspicer1 said:
LET'S TAKE NOTICE OF WHAT THE DOGS ARE DOING, THEY ARE GETTING RID OF ALL THE RUBBISH, AND BUYING PLAYERS THAT ARE GO GETTEM PLAYERS, AND WHEN THEY HAVE FINISHED WITH GETTING ALL THE NEW ONES, TO JOIN TOGETHER WITH THE ONES THEY GOT THIS YEAR FOR NEXT YEAR THEY WILL FINISH
WITH A TOP 8 TEAM.
Click to expand...
Dogs got Gus, we got Sheens. Gus makes things happen....
 
88 said:
Why does our edge and centre/wing defence always slide backwards when defending? We just give up so much ground on sets. Is this coached? I see no other team that defends this way. Reckon assistant coaches are so important to structures. Hope we can come up with some better systems next year.
Click to expand...
We’ve had a million different assistant coaches. Doesn’t change no matter who is there.

Our club is like the Bermuda Triangle. Players just get worse here regardless who the coach is.
 
Dennisspicer1 said:
Here we go again,
we should have enough money to be able to let 7 or 8 move to other clubs, and buy at least 5 or 6 top liners, why are we now saying, things like we will keep brooks, but only if we can retain him for $500.000, He has really done nothing in the 9 years he has been at the club, do you really think paying him half price will make him play any better.

LET'S TAKE NOTICE OF WHAT THE DOGS ARE DOING, THEY ARE GETTING RID OF ALL THE RUBBISH, AND BUYING PLAYERS THAT ARE GO GETTEM PLAYERS, AND WHEN THEY HAVE FINISHED WITH GETTING ALL THE NEW ONES, TO JOIN TOGETHER WITH THE ONES THEY GOT THIS YEAR FOR NEXT YEAR THEY WILL FINISH
WITH A TOP 8 TEAM.

IT LOOKS LIKE WE ARE SETTLING FOR THE SAME TYPES OF PLAYERS WE ALREADY HAVE.
AND UNLESS WE PURCHASE SOME MORE TOP NAMES.

THEN WE ARE HEADING FOR THE SAME PLACE WE HAVE JUST REACHED.
Click to expand...
Question: How do we get rid of all our rubbish?
 
weststigerman said:
Yep. Losing off the field: Ciraldo, JAC, TPJ etc translates to losing on the field.

Admin needs to go. Since Sheens got here things have got significantly worse, surely that can’t be argued.
Click to expand...
The board should hang its head in shame.
The never-ending cycle of palming off responsibilities and kneejerk reactions has only always put us in a more vulnerable position.
 
weststigerman said:
Yep. Losing off the field: Ciraldo, JAC, TPJ etc translates to losing on the field.

Admin needs to go. Since Sheens got here things have got significantly worse, surely that can’t be argued.
Click to expand...
Sheens has been an unmitigated disaster by any account
Sacked the coach without a plan,humiliated the brand with a spurned approach to his sole coaching contender(after sharing all our secrets) ,lost 2 of our biggest forwards mid season then 2 of our most experienced backs "on loan"...got dictated to by Douhi on jersey number rather than make him earn it ..then worst of all appointed a totally unqualified and inexperienced coach with serious question marks about his abilities to look after the next 5 years..FIVE years !!
Hired nobody..& may lose one of Madges best hires
and almost certainly consolidated our first spoon
..all in 12 months!!
His job,just like Bellamy at Storm who faces smiiliar issues about motivating departing players,is to get all these players playing to their potential rather than run the white flag up on 2022I
Hes not working for Gus is he?
A disaster
Little wonder he got fired from his last 3 gigs
 
Last edited:
clontarfkid said:
Sheens has been an unmitigated disaster by any account
Sacked the coach without a plan,humiliated the brand with a spurned approach to his sole coaching contender(after sharing all our secrets) ,lost 2 of our biggest forwards mid season then 2 of our most experienced backs "on loan"...got dictated to by Douhi on jersey number rather than make him earn it ..then worst of all appointed a totally unqualified and inexperienced coach with serious question marks about his abilities to look after the next 5 years
Hired nobody..& may lose one of Madges best hires
and almost certainly consolidated our first spoon
..all in 12 months!!
His job,just like Bellamy at Storm who faces siliar issues about motivating departing players,is to get all these players playing to their potential rather than run the white flag up on 2022I
Hes not working for Gus is he?
A disaster
Click to expand...

The plan was after the season was over which it was around start of origin to plan for next year.

This year is not on sheens.

If you're upset find the correct people to finger point at.
 
Lauren said:
The board should hang its head in shame.
The never-ending cycle of palming off responsibilities and kneejerk reactions has only always put us in a more vulnerable position.
Click to expand...
A strong board would take a stand and make a real change. They would announce a press conference and roll out Sheens and Benji and 3 major signings. They would announce a permanent home ground and an identity at the same time. They would announce that this is the moment we are no longer the competition’s whipping boys. We will get more excuses, blame games, grandstanding and mediocrity.
 
tony soprano said:
The plan was after the season was over which it was around start of origin to plan for next year.

This year is not on sheens.

If you're upset find the correct people to finger point at.
Click to expand...
Sorry..but from a low base under Madge,Sheens is responsible for all the above & has plunged WTs into totally new depths of mediocrity..or worse
He needs to own his actions..and the ensuing results
Sheens can go back to wherever he wants to be in UK...tomorrow.
Difficult to say this..but Id rather have Flanno rite now
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Staff online

Members online

Total: 516 (members: 39, guests: 477)
Back
Top