Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

[Cobarcats]

Hey guys, there are some nasty comments by member's about other members atm in several threads lately.
Please take some happy pills.
The forum is about sharing opinions and not about abusing or making fun of someone's opinions. Please don't make this personal.

 

[Roar_Power]

Maybe Brooks is just after a contract extension. Forcing the Tigers hand to make a formal offer. Doesn't really make sense why he would want to move to another basket case team like the Knights knowing he will be harshly scrutinized.

 

[bathursttiger1]

Little slime bag.

I hate when people sign the following year with another club, but tanks it for a year before they go.

I don't think that Brooks could TANK anymore than he is at the present

 

[batboy]

Maybe Brooks is just after a contract extension. Forcing the Tigers hand to make a formal offer. Doesn't really make sense why he would want to move to another basket case team like the Knights knowing he will be harshly scrutinized.

Get out of Sydney maybe - might have family in Newy? Has been seen out and about there on occasion…

But yeah, not really a cracking career move - must have sold it well,…

 

[Batmans Parents]

Better to ignore those members you don't like.

View must be great from that glass house of yours.

Don't worry, Brooks is only going 90 minutes up the road. Plenty of time for visitation rights for you and the fan club.

 

[Aceshigh]

Dope name

I would only take Klemmer out of that lot mate and I’m not Lebanese 😂

 

[Batmans Parents]

With Musgrove gone we should go after Lodge as well as Klemmer.

This. Pretty sure Lodge is off contract as well so we could have actually have two starting props with aggression and go-forward in 2023.

We won't know what hit us.

 

[hsvjones]

I am starting to get a little excited with all this action..
Every player we have let go by either not resigning and releasing them to another club has been the right decision. Most of us have been asking for the club to turn over players that are just not performing at a consistently high level.
I think Benji knows who they are as he played with them and won't want them here when he takes over as HC.
You add Api, IP, Klemmer if true plus a few more as we have the money and I can really see us turning this around quicker then most think.

I would love to see Hastings extended ASAP, If AD doesn't want to extend I hope we go hard for a Moses or Brown type guy.
Forwards are a big area to improve so adding maybe N Brown, Faffita type guys will add the missing mongrel we lack.

If people don't think we are heading in the right direction they just need to have a look at clubs like Dragons or Knights.. They are taking our players that we want to get rid of and thats says a lot.

 

[king_sirro]

So the new way of moderating is to actually change what you write so it looks like you wrote something that you actually didn't? That's wrong

 

[Cobarcats]

I am starting to get a little excited with all this action..
Every player we have let go by either not resigning and releasing them to another club has been the right decision. Most of us have been asking for the club to turn over players that are just not performing at a consistently high level.
I think Benji knows who they are as he played with them and won't want them here when he takes over as HC.
You add Api, IP, Klemmer if true plus a few more as we have the money and I can really see us turning this around quicker then most think.

I would love to see Hastings extended ASAP, If AD doesn't want to extend I hope we go hard for a Moses or Brown type guy.
Forwards are a big area to improve so adding maybe N Brown, Faffita type guys will add the missing mongrel we lack.

If people don't think we are heading in the right direction they just need to have a look at clubs like Dragons or Knights.. They are taking our players that we want to get rid of and thats says a lot.

Well Sheens did say that several players won't be here next year. I do give him credit with for his conviction.
I just hope that there are no more embarrassing happenings in 2023.

 

[wet tiger coloured bird]

does knight and dragons have money issues?

 

[Telltails]

The lure of working with Andrew Johns, Pongha halves pairing, a decent forward pack all must have some level of appeal.
Pretty sure Brooks has got a house in Putney where he grew up - financially set and now his own family. It was always going to be now or never to test himself away WTs

 

[Jedi_Tiger]

Reckon Des will be coaching Newcastle by end of 2023, who knows they may end up with Turbo at fb ponga at 6 Brooks at 7

 

[Mighty_Tiger]

Whilst i agree with much of what you've just said, we do have a bit of a history of going to water every time someone requests an early release.

Matterson, Moses, Lucy and im sure theres other's i just cant recall at this moment.
As much as i think Brooks is a hoax he's still our half back/ 5/8th for the moment and like you say there arent many decent half's floating about certainly not Albert Kelly. Maybe CLifford at a pinch is doable in the short term i guess.

That's the reality for us supporters unfortunately.
Every time we get confident things will turn bang a new low has happened.
It's just been getting worse and worse as the seasons go on.

Our confidence that those good players making a difference let alone last the distance of their contracts just has been worn out due to how bad things have been the last 10yrs or so.

Right now especially with the cap increase for next season I don't see why we would move Brooks on unless we have something lined up. Giving him to Knights without something in return (and not Klemmer)

 

[tigertuff]

I am personally disappointed Brooksy is leaving (if true). I was looking forward to him playing under Sheens. I thought he could have bought the best out of him again. Not sure if Hastings and AD are the answer. Let's hope Sheens has a plan.

 

[tigerap]

Reckon Des will be coaching Newcastle by end of 2023, who knows they may end up with Turbo at fb ponga at 6 Brooks at 7

Wow that will end up being his 3rd $1m payout….

 

[Jedi_Tiger]

That's the reality for us supporters unfortunately.
Every time we get confident things will turn bang a new low has happened.
It's just been getting worse and worse as the seasons go on.

Our confidence that those good players making a difference let alone last the distance of their contracts just has been worn out due to how bad things have been the last 10yrs or so.

Right now especially with the cap increase for next season I don't see why we would move Brooks on unless we have something lined up. Giving him to Knights without something in return (and not Klemmer)

Tyson Frizell would be good for 2023 in exchange for brooks release (also klemmer)

 

[tigerap]

Really? I actually spoke to his old man recently. Tigers haven't offered him anything. Gees there's some dribblers on this forum.

Contradiction……

 

[Cobarcats]

So the new way of moderating is to actually change what you write so it looks like you wrote something that you actually didn't? That's wrong

You don't know what goes on behind the scenes, if you have a problem PM me.

 

[happy_tiger]

Hopefully 🍑 isn't far behind them

If we can't upgrade them it is another step backwards ....who on the market is a better 7 ....I'm not unhappy they have gone .....