Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

[das tigers]

I hope we have a plan B , mine would be two pommies , Williams and Welby, now if we have offered Moses $1.2 million , I would offer Williams $800,000 and welby $650,000 that’s $1.45 million so for $250,000 we get two players , just my plan B

Man I'd nearly rather these two than MM. Welsby's a weapon both love a cutout pass,follow the
play,speed,direct play.

 

[Newtown]

1- Staines
6- Laurie
7- Brooks
13- Doueihi

It's a top 4 reserve grade spine.

How can it be improved?

 

[Demps]

How can it be improved?

1 Staines
6 Brooks
7 Moses
13 AD

 

[Newtown]

If dogs get him, so be it. We move. Don't dwell too much on it.

If Wests tigers miss out spend some of the money on Farnsworth and a couple of upcoming halves.

 

[boonboon]

How about
1. Douehi
6. Brooks
7. Moses
9. Api

 

[Camel2281]

How can it be improved?

1. Laurie
2. Staines
6. AD
7. Moses
14. Brooks

 

[earl]

How can it be improved?

I started writing a spiel and it was all dribble.

We either recruit better players or we just have the 4 of them fight it out it for the 3 positions. Maybe you can try Doueihi at lock but I don't like the idea. He isn't a ball player like Hastings was. He is a runner with poor defense.

Maybe one of them will prove they are high caliber NRL players over the course of the season but I don't have much confidence in our spine for next season.

Recruiting Moses or Welsby would mean we have 4 players into two positions and at least that way there is more competition for those key roles but I'm not sure there is a huge difference between them.

 

[earl]

How about
1. Douehi
6. Brooks
7. Moses
9. Api

This is better but we need Moses and it is probably unlikely. I wonder if Doueihi is better than Laurie and Staines at fullback though.

 

[das tigers]

Like when Hannant won $200k on a scratchie? Reckoned it was the only time he bought one. Sus as shit.

https://twitter.com/x/status/345119903923191808

Yeah I remember this,suss as to me at the time. Playing for the Roosters. Talk about luck aye.

 

[tigermate]

And you will never know the difference. So my point is - why bother to worry? You will never know for sure if it's a club leak or just media BS. It's probably media BS even if it involves a club leak.

True - but when all/most media outlets report something similar then you have to assume they haven’t all had the same cognition without it coming from somewhere.

I only worry (more so annoys) bc I think it hurts our brand whilst we’re in the rebuilding phase.

But agree with your points.

 

[jirskyr]

Don't know if it's from a recent article. Also don't have the full story, screenshot here was shared by his management
View attachment 3771

Can't be that recent, or at least accurate, because it's got the old logo.

 

[Curaeus]

Media loves WT
Re MM, we keep quiet for a change - it doesn't matter.
They report it because it suits their agenda (clicks) :
1. If we sign MM we have paid huge overs and they spend months on that
2. We don't sign MM and we have missed out AGAIN because no-one wants to go to the club in crisis - and they spend months on that

Its a win- win for the gutter crawlers.

We should never pander to media scum. We owe these creeps zip!

 

[pawsandclaws1]

This is better but we need Moses and it is probably unlikely. I wonder if Doueihi is better than Laurie and Staines at fullback though.

Doueihi has been placed at fullback, 5/8 or lock in three different posts! It probably sums up where he is in the squad - a utlity without having secured a position (as was the case at Souths).

 

[SeanT]

1 Staines
6 Brooks
7 Moses
13 AD

AD at centre..he struggles to defend there let alone lock. His defence wouldn't be up to it unless he bulks up over summer. Doubt it though because he wants to play at half.

 

[sleeve]

This is better but we need Moses and it is probably unlikely. I wonder if Doueihi is better than Laurie and Staines at fullback though.

Well Doueihi was awful at fullback, and it's a position that requires speed , i think the Tigers have already passed on that idea. Laurie, tried hard and was better, but not great. Stains has the size, and speed , and some experience and looks promising. It's a position that is critical, and if the above fail, it has to be the main aim of recruitment ,after sorting out the halves.

 

[earl]

Doueihi was awful at fullback

I don't think he was that bad. He just lacked pace and that meant he couldn't make those huge runs that some player make.

If you look at his stats he made good meters and he was great under the high ball.

I hope you are right on Staines. He is quick. I can see him making that fullback spot his own.

 

[Coastie_Tiger]

1. Laurie/Staines
6. Brooks
7. Moses/Williams
9. Api

that would be my preferred spine for 23/24 if possible id upgrade full back
Doueihi is not a 13 he's barely a 6 centre would be my place for him assuming he gets his defence in order. No way he plays in the middle anytime soon.

 

[colinbh]

How can it be improved?

I iook at it another way
All four can play in other positions. Laurie...fullback, 5/8 and wing. Brooks...1/2, 5/8 and at a pinch ..center. AD.....5/8, center fullback and maybe 1/2. Staines....fullback wing and possibly center. Very versatile and all first grade standard

 

[KingRobbie]

Don't know if it's from a recent article. Also don't have the full story, screenshot here was shared by his management
View attachment 3771

Never saw Robbie play at the same age but Da Silva is a gun.

Will definitely be the Koroisau replacement when he retires.

He’s only 17, but is already training with NRL this pre-season.

 

[sleeve]

I iook at it another way
All four can play in other positions. Laurie...fullback, 5/8 and wing. Brooks...1/2, 5/8 and at a pinch ..center. AD.....5/8, center fullback and maybe 1/2. Staines....fullback wing and possibly center. Very versatile and all first grade standard

First grade standard at the Tigers, not the standard of top 8 side in the comp. That's why we got the spoon. We all pray with some additions to the pack , that this will change. They all don't have 2024 contracts as yet, so the club does not think they are all first grade standard , neither do I .
Maybe 2 get extended, but i doubt all four will be here in 2024