Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

[bigsiro]

That's what we thought with barrett sacking, Ciraldo and JAC.

IMO we should have moved heaven and earth for JAC.
Generational talent.
Wingers are not what they used to be and he is probably the best since Grothe, and arguably better.

 

[Demps]

yo

u got a much better memory than me brother

I eat a lot of vegetables bra
Razor sharp memory

Shout out to vegetables 🥦

 

[Demps]

Nathan Brown laid on the ground acting like he got shot. Embarrassing that he had to resort to those tactics.

Getting more common in the game,
Embarrassment 💯

 

[trentrunciman]

sorry if this has been posted but my mate sent me poms podcast forum update on MM...has that been posted here? if so plz delete my msg @Demps

 

[Love_the_WestsTigers]

Joffa will have his best season ever this year. He wont have to tackle his ass off and then try to carry the team up the field.
I like twal alot but i rate Joffa over Twal

Twal is a no frills player. I love him but I don’t see him being a world beater.
Despite that, he will make my team.
I think he will also improve in 23, like many in our team.

 

[gallagher]

my memory is pretty bad but i seriously remmeber blore ran up to him. But honestly maybe you're right.

Yeah, I probably am. 😅
Wrong that is.

 

[Love_the_WestsTigers]

Getting more common in the game,
Embarrassment 💯

Hasn’t Noffa pulled a couple of those too ?
I don’t like it at all. It’s not good sportsmanship.
And if they really wanna go into acting then they should start at the Broadway, like Jackman

 

[trentrunciman]

edit- i'm not sure where this is from but my mate sent it. just relaying. Feel free to delete Mods.

 

[Kaito]

Twal is a no frills player. I love him but I don’t see him being a world beater.
Despite that, he will make my team.
I think he will also improve in 23, like many in our team.

He's got a cheeky step & offload
in his holster too, unfortunately
it was coached out of him with
Madge for 3 seasons — he
preferred using him as a battering
ram and tackle machine. Covered
up for so many over our defensive
deficiencies in the middle there
to be fair, but he's got more to
him as a footballer, will go up a gear

 

[JRDee]

View attachment 3952
edit- i'm not sure where this is from but my mate sent it. just relaying. Feel free to delete Mods.

Just because we have offered more doesn’t mean he will sign with us, he’s only using our offer to get as much as he can out of Parra

 

[liltiger]

Parra won't be doing us any favours.

Not holding my breath

I tend to agree with you, but just wonder if they remember his ability to kick stones and figure they might as well get something out of it. I'm a firm believer irrespective of what Parra say Brown was always the priority. Now they have him locked up they might just try to find away for themselves to come out with something. All speculation on my part of course, don't really think Moses will leave Parra tbh.

 

[Demps]

Hasn’t Noffa pulled a couple of those too ?
I don’t like it at all. It’s not good sportsmanship.
And if they really wanna go into acting then they should start at the Broadway, like Jackman

I hate it hey, it's disgraceful.

Should be looked down upon by all players.
This is a tough game, not one for cowardice.

 

[Love_the_WestsTigers]

I hate it hey, it's disgraceful.

Should be looked down upon by all players.
This is a tough game, not one for cowardice.

The other bit I frown upon is the going to ground with the ball in the last minute pretending to have a cramp etc. Whilst I understand the ball security and all at that stage, it also doesn’t look too good at the time.

 

[sleeve]

IMO we should have moved heaven and earth for JAC.
Generational talent.
Wingers are not what they used to be and he is probably the best since Grothe, and arguably better.

Wrong ! Grothe was good, but i could name far better,but that's for another time !
J A C is great ,one of the best, without doubt, but wasted in the Tigers side that had weak forwards,and possibly the slowest backline of all time. He has struggled at the Dogs, with a far better backline, then the Tigers. Wingers excel in good sides, but get lost in sides without flair.
As a priority signing, that was stupid.

 

[WesternSuburbsBoy]

He's got a cheeky step & offload
in his holster too, unfortunately
it was coached out of him with
Madge for 3 seasons — he
preferred using him as a battering
ram and tackle machine. Covered
up for so many over our defensive
deficiencies in the middle there
to be fair, but he's got more to
him as a footballer, will go up a gear

I remember someone telling me that he didn’t offload because he was scared of being dropped by Madge

 

[Tiger5150]

IMO we should have moved heaven and earth for JAC.
Generational talent.
Wingers are not what they used to be and he is probably the best since Grothe, and arguably better.

Brian To'o is a better winger than JAC.

 

[trentrunciman]

Brian To'o is a better winger than JAC.

 

[hammertime]

Is there a possibility however minute, that Moses has signed for 24 but the clubs are negotiating for his release in 23 hence no news yet ?

Pom said that decision only this week. I doubt it's happened yet.

 

[liltiger]

Pom said that decision only this week. I doubt it's happened yet.

True I forgot about that.

 

[Mighty_Tiger]

He'll prove a few wrong over the next two years I reckon.

Hope you’re right but I don’t see it. His weakness is with the ball and Sheens is attacking style coach so that works against him.

He is 24 before season starts and regressed in 22 from 21 he needs to show something this year & early with a quality support cast around him otherwise the kids will take over and he will become a nsw cup regular.

On 22 form he provides little value to our upgraded pack.