Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

[Red88_Tiger]

Im resigned to believing that it doesnt matter who we are targeting at the moment until what's going on off the field - what ever that is - sorts itself out, we are mud. And because thats in the hands of the people who created the current problem while ever they are all still there, we remain a no go zone.
Do you really think any manager is going to negotiate a deal with their potential young talent with us when they have other options at clubs with experienced coaches and proven paths to success.How many knockbacks do they need to get before they get it - no one is buying what they are selling

This year is gone
Took until Xmas last year to know that we signed Bateman. I know it’s frustrating but I would rather wait for better than overpaying earlier in panic mode just to appease the wolves
Getting hyped up by media and rumours that are on social media is not good for a supporter’s mindset. Even on here I think there is posts to drive journalists and managers agendas

 

[Telltails]

This year is gone
Took until Xmas last year to know that we signed Bateman. I know it’s frustrating but I would rather wait for better than overpaying earlier in panic mode just to appease the wolves
Getting hyped up by media and rumours that are on social media is not good for a supporter’s mindset. Even on here I think there is posts to drive journalists and managers agendas

There is probably some truth in that but the proof is in the pudding as they say and our inability to compete with clubs for players we want. We weren't competing with other clubs to get Klemmer or Bateman. The club has been in freefall since they sacked Maguire - results have not improved and that just adds to the noise on the back of recent decisions.

 

[king_sirro]

Imagine that - imagine that you don't sign for a club because some other dude that your manager manages didn't get a gig.

It either sounds like pure baloney or top-tier bad advice.

Imagine your manager turning or talking down opportunities for you because some other bloke didn't get a golden ticket.

If this was true, well Schuster didn't sign for the Dolphins either.

I'm sick of this trend that seems to have crept into the game where the players bow to what their manager wants. Bring back the old days when players told their managers what to do and took control of their own life.

 

[TV Ted Ellery]

btw how is feledy not in first grade ?????

He needs time in NSW Cup first. The other NSW centre, Ethan Strange was a standout last night but he's done little in the 6-7 games he's played in NSW Cup this year.

I'd like to see Feledy and Faagutu promoted to NSW Cup for the rest of the season. Faagutu could even be given a game in firsts - I reckon he could handle it.

 

[king_sirro]

If you read between the lines, the Braydon Trindall boat has sailed and Wests Tigers now ideally want Jonah Pezet, Ethan Sanders or potentially Lachlan Ilias as the starting number 7 for 2024.
Any of the 3 would be fantastic, just not sure if we are a realistic chance on any of them.
That’s why I believe we need to sign an older more experienced and much cheaper halfback to apply pressure to any potential young halfback we may sign.
As for a 6, I don’t think we should bother even contemplating big money for a young player such as Fainu as we have some highly promising young 6’s of our own and just need a stop gap 6 until they are ready.
I think Taafe would be great playing 6 for us, but it seems he’s going to the Bulldogs ss their starting fullback.
Metcalfe would be great, but it seems he’s now established himself as the number one 6 at the Warriors.
Croft might be ok, but I just feel we ideally need someone a bit bigger in stature and better defensively as our 6.
Junior Amone maybe an option ?
Anyone think Paul Alamoti would be a good recruit ?

We simply can't go into next year with half that has no kicking game. Ilias straightens the attack as good as anyone, he defends well, but he has a terrible long and short kicking game. He would really struggle with us.

 

[coivtny]

Go the Swans!

Was there. Great game. Swans didn't play well but gee they fight. Reminds me of WT ........ not.

 

[Needaname]

100%

He is the personification of ego overriding ability & application!

Style over substance!

Plus he is an abject moron try-hard!!

* On that note - why all of a sudden have "Romey" "Bizza" and "Critta" decided to wear HEADGEAR as if it was a fashion statement!

If you need to wear a helmet to protect a cut/split that is fine!

But otherwise when you have always played without it.....

To'o only played well for NSW tonight when he finally ditched it after Tabuai-Fidow made him look stupid again!

Critta has been wearing it since he lost half his ear in the head clash. Maybe they all like their faces too much and don’t want the same thing to happen to them.

 

[bptiger 0]

btw how is feledy not in first grade ?????

He’s not in 1st grade because the bloke can’t tackle, lost count how many times he got burned on the outside, he runs the ball well but he needs to really work on his defensive work

 

[bptiger 0]

We simply can't go into next year with half that has no kicking game. Ilias straightens the attack as good as anyone, he defends well, but he has a terrible long and short kicking game. He would really struggle with us.

I think he doesn’t kick well because south’s have others to do it and they play a different game , if we grabbed him I am sure he could learn to become a better kicker

 

[earl]

Fulton can show us what a good recruiter he is by negotiating a release from the Sharks

Is he really a strong recruiter ? How much difference does that really make ?

 

[earl]

Here's a rumour from Bunnies, pretty good info too. Cody at 7, Wighton 6, Furguson and Graham 3 and 4. Taafe and Illias up for sale.

I can see this happening but it's interesting because they are two running halves. I think 80% of the fans on this forum feel you need an organizing 7. Wighton and Walker are definitely not that type of player.

 

[king_sirro]

I think he doesn’t kick well because south’s have others to do it and they play a different game , if we grabbed him I am sure he could learn to become a better kicker

I don't think so, Illias does most of Souths kicking. Cody chimes in occasionally

 

[earl]

Im resigned to believing that it doesnt matter who we are targeting at the moment until what's going on off the field - what ever that is - sorts itself out, we are mud

We've been mud for years and we signed Aip, IP, Bateman and Klemmer. Money talks.

 

[Needaname]

I think Volkman is most likely to drop out given he hasn’t got much of a go in the NRL. TMM could be released as well.

There is no way they’ll go into 2024 with all of those players in the halves.

TMM and Volkman won’t play 1st grade pending injuries. Depends on their lifestyle outside of Footy as to whether they are happy to stay in NZ and remain part of the squad or whether they want to challenge themselves elsewhere. Harris Tavita returns to play a hooker utility role I feel.

 

[BlackWhiteGold]

I don't think so, Illias does most of Souths kicking. Cody chimes in occasionally

Didn't the Wighton deal get approved by the NRL because Souths valued him as a centre. Be a bit smelly if straight away he was thrust into the halves. Ricky would blow up!

 

[PabloX]

Here's a rumour from Bunnies, pretty good info too. Cody at 7, Wighton 6, Furguson and Graham 3 and 4. Taafe and Illias up for sale.

Tass would be a handy pick up

 

[Ekaj2994!]

Here's a rumour from Bunnies, pretty good info too. Cody at 7, Wighton 6, Furguson and Graham 3 and 4. Taafe and Illias up for sale.

Illias managed by Anasta no way he sends a young half to the tigers. Would love Jonah pezet but same issue

 

[BlackWhiteGold]

So in summary from rumours in recent days, we are in talks with:

- Fainu brothers
- Ethan Sanders (only that it would be remiss of us not to be in talks)
- Aidan Sezer
- Brodie Croft
- Brayden Trindall (although Sharks have denied a release)
- Jeral Skelton (apparently signed)

Anyone else?

 

[TigerSJ]

Anyone know the story on Blore? Talk of him leaving the club seems to have dropped off. Of all the players that have been mentioned as off contract or free to shop around, him and Staines are probably the only ones I’d bother extending.

 

[Telltails]

We've been mud for years and we signed Aip, IP, Bateman and Klemmer. Money talks.

Id argue our position since signing Api and IPap is far more suspect than when they signed.
We couldn't replace the coach we sacked and have shown no improvement results wise under the coach/s we ended up with. Money talks but it's not going to buy us the players we need when competing with other clubs.