Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

Kelce68 said:
Reece Walsh is the best player in the game right now and single handedly winning the Broncos games.

On that basis alone, they are miles ahead.

You then add the goalkicking steering wheel in Reynolds, Walters (somehow) in career best form and Mam playing a supporting role the belies his age and they're on a different planet to our potential spine for next year.

We've hopefully got a lot of upside in key positions and the spine is definitely on the improve, but I fail to see any way that we're comparable to Brisbane.
Click to expand...
Almost identical. I can't separate them.
Except Api, he's the best!
 
tigerballs said:
Broncos fullback is the same age as ours, Broncos 5/8 is 20, younger than Sullivan, 2 years older than Fainu. Broncos half is around same age as Sezer. Our hooker is better. Our spine is veeerry similar to the Broncos. Maybe even a bit better....
Click to expand...
Api is obviously better than Walters but to say Fainu, Sullivan, Sezer and Bula are on the same level or close to Walsh, Reyno and Mam is laughable 😂
 
Needaname said:
Well I’m not sure your point. We’ve signed players in a similar fashion really.
Klokstad, experienced and unwanted but signed to return home in a position of need. Sezer.
Ford. Good junior backrower not getting a look in. Fainu.
Metcalf. Outstanding junior half who had a bit of a tough time with injuries and not getting a lot of first grade.
Sullivan.

It’s not just these signings that transformed the Warriors. It’s the Niakore, Walker, Barnett, Martin inform and experienced combination.

Maybe in November we’ll sign ourselves a couple of experienced guys off y but I doubt it.
Click to expand...

My point was initially raised as a way of countering someone saying that there is “no talent on the market”…I do get a bit tired of hearing this…

The three players were not really big names previously … and were signed relatively cheap…

They may not be the best players like AFB or Johnson… but I believe they have played their part in their success this year.

You mention Martin - TMM? … what did he do this year? …And Dylan Walker? He didn’t play as well as these three this season…

These guys turned out to be three above average players,,, I think you are underestimating them
 
Last edited:
Needaname said:
Didn’t realise Ford’s age. But deputed 4 years ago and played a bit part of a role with the dragons throughout his time there.
I guess you’re suggesting someone like this bloke. Who has had a similar career to date.
https://www.nrl.com/players/nrl-premiership/sea-eagles/sean-keppie/ though most are throwing their arms in the air filthy that we would sign him over Seyfarth and not at the expense of releasing Twal.
Click to expand...

Not really a fan of Keppie….

The club is paying Scott Fulton to find these guys… hope he just isn’t looking at his ex Manly players ….
 
Tom Shines said:
My point was initially raised as a way of countering someone saying that there is “no talent on the market”…I do get a bit tired of hearing this…

The three players were not really big names previously … and were signed relatively cheap…

They may not be the best players like AFB or Johnson… but I believe they have played their part in their success this year.

You mention Martin - TMM? … what did he do this year? …And Dylan Walker? He didn’t play as well as these three this season…
Click to expand...
I wasn’t across everything last year. We’re Ford, Klokstad and Metcalf off contract when they were signed?
There’s what’s on market as in off contract, what’s open to be released as in through discussions with contacts. List number 2 isn’t always revealed to all.
 
Tom Shines said:
Not really a fan of Keppie….

The club is paying Scott Fulton to find these guys… hope he just isn’t looking at his ex Manly players ….
Click to expand...
I am he has mongrel, stamina and good awareness but I guess you can’t please everyone. Personally I thought Barnett was a useless signing to the Warriors but Webster showed how effective he was moving off the edge into a simpler role.
 
Needaname said:
I wasn’t across everything last year. We’re Ford, Klokstad and Metcalf off contract when they were signed?
There’s what’s on market as in off contract, what’s open to be released as in through discussions with contacts. List number 2 isn’t always revealed to all.
Click to expand...

I don’t know… but contracts don’t mean much these days right?

The end result was that the Warriors got them over there and they blossomed … maybe you gotta give some credit to the coaching staff as well…
 
Tom Shines said:
I don’t know… but contracts don’t mean much these days right?

The end result was that the Warriors got them over there and they blossomed … maybe you gotta give some credit to the coaching staff as well…
Click to expand...
Absolutely, but that’s taking this conversation in a completely other direction. The Warriors when they stood down Nathan Brown got on the front foot and made the exact same statement as Lee and Pascoe in terms of no longer accepting Mediocrity. They conducted a world wide search and ended up no further than the edge of Sydney. It’s worked out so far for them. Good on them.
 
The Chad said:
You guys keep laughing at the suggestion, but Hymel Hunt would be a great addition to a young squad.

Good defensive player, popular everywhere he has played, low mistake rate, averages 120m a game on the wing in his 4 starts this year.

His biggest faults- he HAS had some significant injuries & top tier talents eventually beat him out.

If you can name our top tier talents in the centres & wingers....

He covers both wing & centre. Off contract. 100kg. 29 years old. Was a regular starter until 2022 where he lost a season & came back behind 2 very good wingers this year.

Additionally, off contract- add Corey Allen from the Roosters. Suddenly our lack of depth & experience has 2 players who have taken part in the Origin arena that offer versatility across the wing, centres & even fullback.
Click to expand...
We do need a big body metre eater winger who is safe under the high ball and can handle first grade to apply pressure and keep Tupou on his toes.
Hunt could be that player, but we first need to offload Nofa and Kepaoa and he would need to come at the right price and be prepared to be mainly a back up player if Tupou is playing near his best.
 
tigerballs said:
Broncos fullback is the same age as ours, Broncos 5/8 is 20, younger than Sullivan, 2 years older than Fainu. Broncos half is around same age as Sezer. Our hooker is better. Our spine is veeerry similar to the Broncos. Maybe even a bit better....
Click to expand...

I hope you are right. I'm less concerned about their ages. The issue is will they be quality players. We are going to find out.
 
tigerballs said:
Broncos fullback is the same age as ours, Broncos 5/8 is 20, younger than Sullivan, 2 years older than Fainu. Broncos half is around same age as Sezer. Our hooker is better. Our spine is veeerry similar to the Broncos. Maybe even a bit better....
Click to expand...

I'll just quote this post again because good old @tigerballs stated last season Bula was the one to watch. I trust him a little more than my own opinion about Doueihi becoming an elite running 6.
 
Flippedy said:
Yes Fulton really needs to start fishing in different waters. The pond at Manly isn’t really that deep and I think we’ve already landed the best couple of fish they have available.
Click to expand...
Agree, I think we've pretty much drained that swamp and can't see Haumole Olakau'atu coming here.
 
Steve Georgallis is available if we are after another experienced Assistant Coach.

He brings Wests Tigers DNA, decades of experience most recently with the Cowboys, not sure what his relationship is Benji is like.


Payten will have a totally revamped coaching set-up next season with Dean Young and Steve Georgallis leaving their posts.

Young has returned to the Dragons where he will assist Shane Flanagan while Georgallis remains on the lookout for a new position.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Members online

Total: 659 (members: 9, guests: 650)
Back
Top