Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

Backs always a concern...

They locked Toa in...
Maybe they're happy with what we've got? 🤦🏻

1 Bula
2 Nofo / some one else ?
3 Toa / Feledy
4 Naden / Tupou / Reilly
5 Tupou / some one else

It's not the worst but it's not great either....

Realistically,
Simpkin- good kid, OK player but surplus to needs.

Nofo - bad attitude, aging player, well past his best.... should be shown the door to free up space with the future in mind.

AJ - not a fan, doesn't offer a lot on field and we need the space desperately.

AD - will he even play next year ? Work something out, put him in the cooler for a year to allow a new signing and for him to recovery and us to see IF he can bounce back.
 
Demps said:
Backs always a concern...

They locked Toa in...
Maybe they're happy with what we've got? 🤦🏻

1 Bula
2 Nofo / some one else ?
3 Toa / Feledy
4 Naden / Tupou / Reilly
5 Tupou / some one else

It's not the worst but it's not great either....

Realistically,
Simpkin- good kid, OK player but surplus to needs.

Nofo - bad attitude, aging player, well past his best.... should be shown the door to free up space with the future in mind.

AJ - not a fan, doesn't offer a lot on field and we need the space desperately.

AD - will he even play next year ? Work something out, put him in the cooler for a year to allow a new signing and for him to recovery and us to see IF he can bounce back.
Click to expand...
Probably is the worst backline in the comp when you put it like that
 
I don't mind the squad. Hopefully we have some more turnover and get some class players in but I reckon it's unlikely we'll get class players.

It'll be up to the juniors coming through to give us some class.

2024
1. Jahream Bula
2. David Nofoaluma
3. Starford To’a
4. Triston Reilly
5. Junior Tupou
6. Jayden Sullivan
7. Aidan Sezer
8. Stefano Utoikamanu
9. Apisai Koroisau (c)
10. David Klemmer
11. Isaiah Papali'i
12. John Bateman
13. Alex Twal

14. Latu Fainu
15. Samuela Fainu
16. Fonua Pole
17. Shawn Blore

Forwards:-
18. Sione Fainu
19. Brandon Mansfield
20. Brandon Tumeth
21. Asu Kepaoa
22. Jordan Miller
23. Alex Seyfarth
24. Justin Matamua
Hookers/Halves/Utilies:-
25. Lachlan Galvin
26. Jake Simpkin
27. Adam Doueihi
28. Tallyn Da Silva
Outside Backs:-
29. Brent Naden
30. Josh Feledy
 
tony soprano said:
Doubtful, has been a player magnet got lots of knock backs.
Click to expand...
Oh ffs 🤦 can you ever ever say anything positive ? Or even just not respond with negative “opinion “ on everything? It’s not just you , but FFS some people on this like Tucker and vicious and fallen angel and Bagno5 really need to get on Zoloft or some Anti depressants or some damn thing. As far as they concerned every single player is terrible , everybody is overpaid . Every coach is terrible every signing is crap and we Will never improve !! I’m sick to death of seeing it , opinion dressed as PROVEN FACT !! It’s a supporters forum , at least try to support the team and give an inch of respect to other supporters opinions.. please 🙏 for the love of god !
 
TigerNeddyK said:
Oh ffs 🤦 can you ever ever say anything positive ? Or even just not respond with negative “opinion “ on everything? It’s not just you , but FFS some people on this like Tucker and vicious and fallen angel and Bagno5 really need to get on Zoloft or some Anti depressants or some damn thing. As far as they concerned every single player is terrible , everybody is overpaid . Every coach is terrible every signing is crap and we Will never improve !! I’m sick to death of seeing it , opinion dressed as PROVEN FACT !! It’s a supporters forum , at least try to support the team and give an inch of respect to other supporters opinions.. please 🙏 for the love of god !
Click to expand...
Many of the names you mentioned, including tony, don't have any carried negativity bias from my perspective.
 
TigerNeddyK said:
Oh ffs 🤦 can you ever ever say anything positive ? Or even just not respond with negative “opinion “ on everything? It’s not just you , but FFS some people on this like Tucker and vicious and fallen angel and Bagno5 really need to get on Zoloft or some Anti depressants or some damn thing. As far as they concerned every single player is terrible , everybody is overpaid . Every coach is terrible every signing is crap and we Will never improve !! I’m sick to death of seeing it , opinion dressed as PROVEN FACT !! It’s a supporters forum , at least try to support the team and give an inch of respect to other supporters opinions.. please 🙏 for the love of god !
Click to expand...
I can tell you what response you'll get: some version of "well we've been crap for years, they deserve it". They think they are (a) the only ones who have noticed that we haven't been real good of late, (b) that everyone else is perfectly happy with the state of affairs, and (c) that because the club has made lots of poor decisions over the past decade or so it is reasonable to conclude that no decision it ever makes can possibly be anything other than terrible. You'll notice that no vaguely plausible ideas about how the club gets out of the current mess are ever suggested, just endless moaning that every development is a disaster.

I got called a "happy clapper" because I argued that we'd be better off building from within than trying to fix everything overnight with pricey free agent signings. This apparently means I think the club has done and is doing everything right and I don't want them to get better. Bonkers.
 
tigermate said:
I was so happy Twal was leaving.

No more taking a hit up every 4th tackle we get and wasting a play.

No more hogging the ball in the ten meter attacking zone trying to get a try.

No more hit ups without bending the line.
Paying him $400k for three years is a complete waste of a roster spot.

We should’ve just kept him for next year and then let him go.
Another 3 years of having to watch his averageness.

Dam
Click to expand...
I think it’s teriffic .. Twal runs hard as anybody , just needs a bit of work on defence and putting the man on the ground and timing his runs better .. having a decent half throwing him good ball should really help .. he LOVES the club , is loyal to it and that is FANTASTIC.. it might run off onto the kids we want to keep ,, us supporters whine when a player we like signs elsewhere but we want to get rid of ones that want to stay that play well ?? WTF is that about ? Success comes from players having a common goal and working for each other when the chips are down .. playing as a team with people motivated to succeed for that team is good place to start and TWALLY has that in spades ! You can see how the other players feel about him ! We need that as a a club
 
earl said:
I thought vicious was mr positive.
Click to expand...
they may be .. I was kind of working off the cuff trying to recall the posts that had got under my skin from time to time , all of them seem to be genuine fans that want success for the club so it was probably a mistake for me to single anyone out with out supplying evidence or examples
 
TopTiger said:
Surely over the coming weeks the Tigers will move on a player or two, with a number of candidates mentioned previously that are surplus to requirements. I know this is more easily said than done but Joffa was moved on quickly which no one really saw coming.
Click to expand...
Yep, now with full books, the players trades and taps on shoulder for better deals elsewhere come in to play. Here's hoping Fulton and Marshall can pull some interest and options for us (and indeed the players in question too to be fair).
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Members online

Total: 960 (members: 31, guests: 929)
Back
Top