Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

[Leck]

Why?

Look, Sure 6 months ago I would have taken Moylan. But now we have signed Sullivan, Latu and Sezer. We still have AD on the books.

Moylan would he 6 figures and likely begin with at least 5.
If we did not go Sezer, then maybe Moylan fits. I still don't see it.
It's just too late to fit him into our plans. We also needed a Halfback and that's our whole problem.

We are not strategic about who we sign and when. I expect Moylan to go for unders to St George.

Getting Charlie back on the field is a great thing.

 

[jirskyr]

I'm personally not a huge fan of Bradman Best. He played great during that Origin but I've been underwhelmed at club level.

Certainly he's still very young and he's physically imposing, but I just feel like I see too many opposition centres run past him on a semi-regular basis, at this stage in his career.

 

[hsvjones]

I'm personally not a huge fan of Bradman Best. He played great during that Origin but I've been underwhelmed at club level.

Certainly he's still very young and he's physically imposing, but I just feel like I see too many opposition centres run past him on a semi-regular basis, at this stage in his career.

Plus the Knights were shopping him just 12 months ago.. Rocks and Diamonds IMO

 

[crazycat]

I'm personally not a huge fan of Bradman Best. He played great during that Origin but I've been underwhelmed at club level.

Certainly he's still very young and he's physically imposing, but I just feel like I see too many opposition centres run past him on a semi-regular basis, at this stage in his career.

Man, I was going to reply but now can only think Xena and Gabriel (assuming that is the Jirskyr reference. I HATED that character).

We seem to make a mistake of picking players on their top performances, not how low their bottom performances are.

Ofcourse I would like Bradman best here. Yet his market value is over inflated due to a great performance at Origin + Newcastle playing finals.

The ideal is to pick players like Best when their form is down and will improve...

 

[balmain boy]

Plus the Knights were shopping him just 12 months ago.. Rocks and Diamonds IMO

Remember the Sharks and Talakai, comes from nowhere with his power game, somehow gets to origin, signs a big money deal only to then go back to being bog average.
I rate best higher then talakai, but there's a decent chance he goes on to just be one of those highly paid former origin players.

 

[balmain boy]

Can't see Tupou going to the Storm. He'd have half a dozen players in front of him. Warbrick, Coates, Meaney, Smith, Pap, Faalogo... Possible even Tonumaipea

 

[Magpie_Magic]

Remember the Sharks and Talakai, comes from nowhere with his power game, somehow gets to origin, signs a big money deal only to them go back to being big average.
I rate best higher then talakai, but there's a decent chance he goes on to just be one of those highly paid former origin players.

Alot of these types of backs lately.

The club should try to cut Burton loose with a promise he'll be left centre.

He surely couldn't be happy there.

 

[jirskyr]

Man, I was going to reply but now can only think Xena and Gabriel (assuming that is the Jirskyr reference. I HATED that character).

I never watched Xena, so not that

 

[GNR4LIFE]

That would be the most random reference for a username of all time

 

[crazycat]

Remember the Sharks and Talakai, comes from nowhere with his power game, somehow gets to origin, signs a big money deal only to then go back to being bog average.
I rate best higher then talakai, but there's a decent chance he goes on to just be one of those highly paid former origin players.

I remember the Sharks coming 3rd in their season and SMH did an article about some player they were paying 200k then (2008) who just sat on the bench all season.

Ricky, etc couldn't get the bum to move. Club offloads De Gois/etc while a key forward gets a spinal injury, then kept coming last.

We will need a good sports Psychologist to work with our players. There are clear mental issues in our squad with us coming last.

 

[CornerPost]

If they get rid of Naden and Nofo il sink the beers celebrating.

Naden has potential to be good NRL winger.. tall and fast.. hopefully smells the blood in the water and really puts in this offseason.. tupou and staines nrl.. naden and Lobb in regies.. still not origin quality but a slight improvement on last year... ( noffa released )

 

[OzLuke]

Remember the Sharks and Talakai, comes from nowhere with his power game, somehow gets to origin, signs a big money deal only to then go back to being bog average.
I rate best higher then talakai, but there's a decent chance he goes on to just be one of those highly paid former origin players.

Hahahaha I call this Tony WIlliams syndrome...

 

[Tiger_Fanatic3]

 

[Tiger_Fanatic3]

He was always a long shot anyway.

He was never gonna leave Newwy

It's the teams that Bradman Best reject, that makes Bradman Best the best.

Or It’s the offers from Wests he rejects that makes Bradman the best.

 

[crazycat]

So were punting Tristan Reilly and Mansfield..

Makes sense. We just can't have so much "potential" hanging around and we need spots in the 30.

Kinda sad to let him go, but good as well that Benji is doing a cleanout.

 

[Tito Santana]

Plus the Knights were shopping him just 12 months ago.. Rocks and Diamonds IMO

Tito agrees. I think he is Noffaesque.

In 2024 we will be saying we’re glad we didn’t buy him:

I smell a fraud

 

[Tito Santana]

So were punting Tristan Reilly and Mansfield..

Makes sense. We just can't have so much "potential" hanging around and we need spots in the 30.

Kinda sad to let him go, but good as well that Benji is doing a cleanout.

Opens a spot for Mr Whippy. Tito - excited

 

[Lukic]

Paying $700k+ a year for centres isn't going to do you much good. Least important position on the footy field. A guy who can catch, pass and tackle will do you 90% of the job from there. Not fussed about missing out on Best at all.

 

[GNR4LIFE]

He‘s trolling

 

[tigerman 0]

Thanks for bringing that to our attention