Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

crazycat said:
Man, I was going to reply but now can only think Xena and Gabriel (assuming that is the Jirskyr reference. I HATED that character).

We seem to make a mistake of picking players on their top performances, not how low their bottom performances are.

Ofcourse I would like Bradman best here. Yet his market value is over inflated due to a great performance at Origin + Newcastle playing finals.

The ideal is to pick players like Best when their form is down and will improve...
Click to expand...
Well said, Grasshopper, well said...
 
CornerPost said:
Naden has potential to be good NRL winger.. tall and fast.. hopefully smells the blood in the water and really puts in this offseason.. tupou and staines nrl.. naden and Lobb in regies.. still not origin quality but a slight improvement on last year... ( noffa released )
Click to expand...

When Naden has played wing for us, I liked how hard his carries were out of our own end, but he was a terrible finisher. Really lacked sideline awareness and the ability to switch the ball to the other hand for a diving put down next to the corner post. This can certainly be improved with hard work, but it is something that doesn't come naturally to him.
 
king_sirro said:
When Naden has played wing for us, I liked how hard his carries were out of our own end, but he was a terrible finisher. Really lacked sideline awareness and the ability to switch the ball to the other hand for a diving put down next to the corner post. This can certainly be improved with hard work, but it is something that doesn't come naturally to him.
Click to expand...
Completely agree, he hasn't showcased it much in his time here but he's a pretty decent ball player so it's not unreasonable to think he could learn it.
He would also need to work on his bomb difusals as he never looked comfortable at the back
 
Lukic said:
Paying $700k+ a year for centres isn't going to do you much good. Least important position on the footy field. A guy who can catch, pass and tackle will do you 90% of the job from there. Not fussed about missing out on Best at all.
Click to expand...
I disagree with this. The best sides have elite players in that position. Tigers would obviously have to pay overs to get one of those.
 
Tiger-ferret said:
I disagree with this. The best sides have elite players in that position. Tigers would obviously have to pay overs to get one of those.
Click to expand...
the best centres have been developed internally. think about it. Crichton, Olam, Farnworth, Staggs, Best, Manu, Tago, Timoko, Penisini, Koula, Ramien, Billy Smith and Campbell Graham all debuted and were developed at their current clubs. the only "elite" centres that have moved around are Dane Gagai and Val Holmes.

my point is, you're better off either backing your juniors or signing guys that can do a job in your system, like Reimis Smith, Tass, Vailea, Brian Kelly, even Star To'a. centre is not the position it was 10-15 years ago.

Olam will bridge a gap for us in both quality and age. he will do that at approximately $400k a year and will probably be gone in 2026 (PNG). Best on the other hand was going to cost nearly double that and come with the weight of expectation that he plays like Joey Manu or Justin Hodges.

if you're going to use the good sides as a marker then you need to go to find players in the pathways that will become elite centres. To'a absolutely has it in him, we've seen it. Heamasi Makasini is absolutely one of those. Josh Feledy has talent, same with William Craig and Navren Willett. those are your elite centres in waiting, not a bloke worth $800k on the open market.
 
Lukic said:
Paying $700k+ a year for centres isn't going to do you much good. Least important position on the footy field. A guy who can catch, pass and tackle will do you 90% of the job from there. Not fussed about missing out on Best at all.
Click to expand...
We've tried that for a while now & it hasn't really gotten us anywhere has it.
 
king_sirro said:
When Naden has played wing for us, I liked how hard his carries were out of our own end, but he was a terrible finisher. Really lacked sideline awareness and the ability to switch the ball to the other hand for a diving put down next to the corner post. This can certainly be improved with hard work, but it is something that doesn't come naturally to him.
Click to expand...
Wing is most definitely his best position for us. He's utterly useless at centre, always has been.

He makes decent metres, can finish in the corner and his awful decision making in defence is less exposed out wide.

I was complaining at the time he was extended, there was absolutely no need to extend him for so long so early in his time with us. A few ok performances on the win = 3 year extension. We re-signed a lot of trash in that period of time without players earning the extensions. Naden, Kepaoa, Toa for starters. At least whomever was taking charge of this decisions is no longer with us
 

Tigers in the box seat to land Jarome Luai

“There is an increasing confidence in the Wests Tigers.”
www.sen.com.au www.sen.com.au

​

TIGERS IN THE BOX SEAT TO LAND JAROME LUAI​

BY CHARLES GOODSIR 37 MINUTES AGO
GettyImages-1591657794.jpg



The Daily Telegraph’s David Riccio believes a move by Jarome Luai to the Wests Tigers is looking more and more likely with each passing day.
Luai’s current contract will see him remain at the Panthers until the end of the 2024 season but has yet to re-sign with the reigning premiers who have already tabled a two-year offer worth around $800,000 a season

Tigers rookie coach Benji Marshall is reportedly front and centre of the sales pitch to Luai and Riccio believes a decision on the 26-year-old's future is imminent.

“To Wests Tigers fans, I wouldn’t be prepared to say you are going to get a huge present under the Christmas tree in the shape of Jarome Luai just yet,” Riccio said on SEN 1170 Breakfast.

“However, there is a big chance.

“Benji Marshall, in his ability to woo and sell the dream to Luai.

“At a recent house visit to Benji’s place made by Luai, (a deal) is now starting to gain some traction.

“Let’s not forget the relationship of Api Koroisau and Charlie Staines, (both) former Panthers.

“The Wests Tigers have a board meeting this week and it will give some indication on how much they are willing to go all in for Jarome Luai.

“This will pick up and gain some traction in the next 48 to 72 hours.

“There is an increasing confidence in the Wests Tigers (that they’ll get him).”
 
  • Like
Reactions: 851
king_sirro said:
When Naden has played wing for us, I liked how hard his carries were out of our own end, but he was a terrible finisher. Really lacked sideline awareness and the ability to switch the ball to the other hand for a diving put down next to the corner post. This can certainly be improved with hard work, but it is something that doesn't come naturally to him.
Click to expand...
Completely agree Sirro.
 
vlad said:

Tigers in the box seat to land Jarome Luai

“There is an increasing confidence in the Wests Tigers.”
www.sen.com.au www.sen.com.au

​

TIGERS IN THE BOX SEAT TO LAND JAROME LUAI​

BY CHARLES GOODSIR 37 MINUTES AGO
GettyImages-1591657794.jpg



The Daily Telegraph’s David Riccio believes a move by Jarome Luai to the Wests Tigers is looking more and more likely with each passing day.
Luai’s current contract will see him remain at the Panthers until the end of the 2024 season but has yet to re-sign with the reigning premiers who have already tabled a two-year offer worth around $800,000 a season

Tigers rookie coach Benji Marshall is reportedly front and centre of the sales pitch to Luai and Riccio believes a decision on the 26-year-old's future is imminent.

“To Wests Tigers fans, I wouldn’t be prepared to say you are going to get a huge present under the Christmas tree in the shape of Jarome Luai just yet,” Riccio said on SEN 1170 Breakfast.

“However, there is a big chance.

“Benji Marshall, in his ability to woo and sell the dream to Luai.

“At a recent house visit to Benji’s place made by Luai, (a deal) is now starting to gain some traction.

“Let’s not forget the relationship of Api Koroisau and Charlie Staines, (both) former Panthers.

“The Wests Tigers have a board meeting this week and it will give some indication on how much they are willing to go all in for Jarome Luai.

“This will pick up and gain some traction in the next 48 to 72 hours.

“There is an increasing confidence in the Wests Tigers (that they’ll get him).”
Click to expand...
There we have it. Another wests story that contains absolutely no new information created only to garner clicks.
As if Riccio would know.
 
vlad said:

Tigers in the box seat to land Jarome Luai

“There is an increasing confidence in the Wests Tigers.”
www.sen.com.au www.sen.com.au

​

TIGERS IN THE BOX SEAT TO LAND JAROME LUAI​

BY CHARLES GOODSIR 37 MINUTES AGO
GettyImages-1591657794.jpg



The Daily Telegraph’s David Riccio believes a move by Jarome Luai to the Wests Tigers is looking more and more likely with each passing day.
Luai’s current contract will see him remain at the Panthers until the end of the 2024 season but has yet to re-sign with the reigning premiers who have already tabled a two-year offer worth around $800,000 a season

Tigers rookie coach Benji Marshall is reportedly front and centre of the sales pitch to Luai and Riccio believes a decision on the 26-year-old's future is imminent.

“To Wests Tigers fans, I wouldn’t be prepared to say you are going to get a huge present under the Christmas tree in the shape of Jarome Luai just yet,” Riccio said on SEN 1170 Breakfast.

“However, there is a big chance.

“Benji Marshall, in his ability to woo and sell the dream to Luai.

“At a recent house visit to Benji’s place made by Luai, (a deal) is now starting to gain some traction.

“Let’s not forget the relationship of Api Koroisau and Charlie Staines, (both) former Panthers.

“The Wests Tigers have a board meeting this week and it will give some indication on how much they are willing to go all in for Jarome Luai.

“This will pick up and gain some traction in the next 48 to 72 hours.

“There is an increasing confidence in the Wests Tigers (that they’ll get him).”
Click to expand...
The "Tigers fail again" article is presumably already drafted.
 
balmain boy said:
Wing is most definitely his best position for us. He's utterly useless at centre, always has been.

He makes decent metres, can finish in the corner and his awful decision making in defence is less exposed out wide.

I was complaining at the time he was extended, there was absolutely no need to extend him for so long so early in his time with us. A few ok performances on the win = 3 year extension. We re-signed a lot of trash in that period of time without players earning the extensions. Naden, Kepaoa, Toa for starters. At least whomever was taking charge of this decisions is no longer with us
Click to expand...
He may find himself our NSW Cup fullback for his experience & voice with Mason likely our JF fullback you would think.
 
vlad said:

Tigers in the box seat to land Jarome Luai

“There is an increasing confidence in the Wests Tigers.”
www.sen.com.au www.sen.com.au

​

TIGERS IN THE BOX SEAT TO LAND JAROME LUAI​

BY CHARLES GOODSIR 37 MINUTES AGO
GettyImages-1591657794.jpg



The Daily Telegraph’s David Riccio believes a move by Jarome Luai to the Wests Tigers is looking more and more likely with each passing day.
Luai’s current contract will see him remain at the Panthers until the end of the 2024 season but has yet to re-sign with the reigning premiers who have already tabled a two-year offer worth around $800,000 a season

Tigers rookie coach Benji Marshall is reportedly front and centre of the sales pitch to Luai and Riccio believes a decision on the 26-year-old's future is imminent.

“To Wests Tigers fans, I wouldn’t be prepared to say you are going to get a huge present under the Christmas tree in the shape of Jarome Luai just yet,” Riccio said on SEN 1170 Breakfast.

“However, there is a big chance.

“Benji Marshall, in his ability to woo and sell the dream to Luai.

“At a recent house visit to Benji’s place made by Luai, (a deal) is now starting to gain some traction.

“Let’s not forget the relationship of Api Koroisau and Charlie Staines, (both) former Panthers.

“The Wests Tigers have a board meeting this week and it will give some indication on how much they are willing to go all in for Jarome Luai.

“This will pick up and gain some traction in the next 48 to 72 hours.

“There is an increasing confidence in the Wests Tigers (that they’ll get him).”
Click to expand...
Take anything Riccio says with a grain of salt. He said Sullivan was touring Newcastle HQ when he’d already signed with WT.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Members online

Total: 214 (members: 19, guests: 195)
Forever online: Tigergran, Geo
Back
Top