Stefano Utoikamanu #241

Youve got rocks in your head if you think Richo hasnt already told him to leave. Richo is big on loyalty. Stef wanting to question a way over offer by the club shows zero loyalty to your current boss. Stef is already gone. And absolutely no loss at all. Drop off a complete waste of space taking up a jersey and having that money to spend elsewhere, win/win yet again for Richo.
After yesterday I tend to agree with you, he knocked back our offer of $800k a year, and he wasn't even in top 5 props on the field last night, let alone worth $900k a year
 
We certainly need that prop…. Two even …

Where do we get them?
Given we've a few players at both ends of the spectrum (starting their NRL careers and at the back end) I agree and say we turn our attention to our entire pack. Assessing each player's value to the team and what they bring will help determine who's worth holding on to and who we should target.

Turuva and Luai are solid recruits, but to compete with the top sides, we need to build a formidable pack for them to work with. Whether Stefano remains a part of this equation or not, his size alone is an asset in today's competition - where size, physicality, and athleticism are crucial.

Any of the Sharks forwards would be a great start.
 
Given we've a few players at each end of the spectrum (starting their NRL careers and at the back end) I agree and say we turn our attention to our entire pack. Assessing each player's value to the team and what they bring will help determine who's worth holding on to and who we should target.

Turuva and Luai are a great start, but to compete with the top sides, we need to build a formidable pack for them to work with. Whether he remains a part of this equation is hard to say, as while he struggles against heavyweight teams his size alone is an asset in today's competition - where size/physicality and athleticism and skill are dominant traits.

Any of the Sharks forwards would be a good start.

I like Turiva and particularly Luai … but looking at the squad as a whole … I think their addition is offset to some extent with losing Ice and likely Stef … there is a lot of two steps forward, one step back about it
 
We need a prop who is fanatical about line speed, who takes the brutal hit-ups fearlessly, even when getting belted, who turns and pulls the forwards in and directs them and points at them and shows them what he wants, someone who has pride in participating in the physical contest. I suppose it would be something equivalent to Olam's work in the centres. You wish Bateman was that sort of presence for our forwards but he is so often making errors and conceding penalties and is painfully ineffective that he can't really be that player for us. We should pay premium dollars for this prop. It's presumably what we wanted from Klemmer and Tamou, neither of whom cared enough to play with intensity.

Stefano has been here this whole time and has never been this prop. He is a role player and we shouldn't expect more from him. The contract size and length is far too much and I suspect it relates more to marketing than to his output on the field.
Take a stab at Zane Tetevano hasn’t played once yet for the Bulldogs but was credited by JFH and Leota for changing the way they play and approach games.
 
I like Turiva and particularly Luai … but looking at the squad as a whole … I think their addition is offset to some extent with losing Ice and likely Stef … there is a lot of two steps forward, one step back about it

Agree. It’s like we play bingo and each year the number of quality players stays the same but the position numbers to which they play shift.
 
Context is everything. Not saying your wrong but. It does look like Stef joins in to a lot of tackles where others have made the first contact is what I notice.
Possibly. But to miss an average of one tackle per game while making 30-40 in the middle is pretty strong evidence that he’s a reliable guy on that side of the ball.

In attack, Api looks for him close to the line because he’s a big body who is hard to stop. He almost scored a double v Raiders.

His average metres per game are down a bit this year which is what his critics are desperately clinging to. I argue that’s a stat that’s heavily impacted by how your team is travelling and we all know that’s not great.

As a coach, when you’re playing catch up football, you probably instruct your halves to become more involved and move the ball around. Front rowers aren’t going to be too involved in this scenario.

The reason Stef has an offer of 800K and likely a few higher is because people in the know can see what he is capable of - even if that doesn’t always show up on a bad football team.

Also the reason he wants to play on a good football team.
 
Possibly. But to miss an average of one tackle per game while making 30-40 in the middle is pretty strong evidence that he’s a reliable guy on that side of the ball.

In attack, Api looks for him close to the line because he’s a big body who is hard to stop. He almost scored a double v Raiders.

His average metres per game are down a bit this year which is what his critics are desperately clinging to. I argue that’s a stat that’s heavily impacted by how your team is travelling and we all know that’s not great.

As a coach, when you’re playing catch up football, you probably instruct your halves to become more involved and move the ball around. Front rowers aren’t going to be too involved in this scenario.

The reason Stef has an offer of 800K and likely a few higher is because people in the know can see what he is capable of - even if that doesn’t always show up on a bad football team.

Also the reason he wants to play on a good football team.
Unfortunately for us paying $800k (which you’ve got to remember is at the bottom end of his asking) is not going to enable us to add anything further to help Stefano out.
Klem is the one we should be taping but f me we signed him at the start of last year. Hardly even set foot in the joint but unfortunately we are going to be stuck relying on him to get us up field.
 
Unfortunately for us paying $800k (which you’ve got to remember is at the bottom end of his asking) is not going to enable us to add anything further to help Stefano out.
Klem is the one we should be taping but f me we signed him at the start of last year. Hardly even set foot in the joint but unfortunately we are going to be stuck relying on him to get us up field.
Its all we got right now. And Klem tries his best.
 
Back
Top