Sack Marshall

Yes...

Where were you when the former CEO and his ambulance chasing fraud mate were flushing the joint down the shitter for 10 fricking YEARS???

BUT you want a COACHING MIRACLE in 9 months....

You daren't question the two-bit CEO who was demonstrably incompetent - but you think you're better than a club legend and one of the best players of his generation in Benji so you throw stones!

Utter feckless dopes who are throwing these tantys now - BUT worshipped Pascoe because of the COE white elephant.... that was happening regardless of these corrupt fools..

@boonboon tell me how good a job Pascoe was doing again!

1723496658499.png
1723496709124.png
 
I have to agree with this. That was my take during the live game. Couldn't sleep tonight and watched the game again. Imo, 5 of their tries came directly from his bad defensive decisions.

The try at 12 minutes in, Douhi is jogging behind Frizell who takes the pass and crashes over the line. If he sprints to keep up, he could have taken Frizell down as soon as he catches the ball.

In the try in the 20th minute, he's way out of the line but not putting pressure on anyone because the attacking line is so deep. Since he's so far out of the line, it drags Alaimalo up and makes for an easy heads up play to kick over the top to the wing.

The try in the 30th minute is another bad read. He jams in again, this time it looks like he's covering Frizell, but he basically pushes across in front of Galvin who already has Frizel covered. That creates an overlap and there's not much Alaimalo can do.

The try on half time, he slides in after Galvin comes out of the line but appears to only have eyes for Gagai. It's as if he's taken by surprise that Ponga catches the ball behind Gagai. In any other game, Ponga knocks on at that point, but Douhi should have been ready to cover the player out the back. Special shout out here to Seyfarth as he's the only player in the defensive line who comes across to attempt to cover the play and doesn't give up.

The try in the 55th minute looks like Douhi only has eyes for Frizell and doesn't see how deep the attackers are standing or that Ponga is lurking around the back. Galvin has Frizell covered again and Douhi is left in no man's land and its 3 on 1 for Alaimalo. To top it off, Douhi stops in the line and has no urgency to get back.

Part of my issue is that Benji should have taken him aside at half time and told him to slide rather than jam in. Since he kept doing it in the second half, I can only assume that either Benji said nothing to him, ir he ignored the direction.

Sorry for the long post. Had to get it off my chest.

Yet many on here say Aliomolo let his opposite score 4 tries lol.
Very good analysis of how badly Doueihi let our left side down and really sold Aliomolo up the river.

If Benji drops Aliomolo and keeps Doueihi then there really is no use watching this team again while he is coach.
 
You don’t know anything lol.

You're right, I remember going to the First Fan day when Sheensy came back....
Standing by the signing line, I must have heard him say
"I'm just here to help Benji for a couple years, Then it's all his to take over"
Was so non-committal and sound like he was shirking the responsibility before he'd even started.

He should still be here,
Getting around talking to kids and doing the job he was supposed to be doing.
 
Yes...

Where were you when the former CEO and his ambulance chasing fraud mate were flushing the joint down the shitter for 10 fricking YEARS???

BUT you want a COACHING MIRACLE in 9 months....

You daren't question the two-bit CEO who was demonstrably incompetent - but you think you're better than a club legend and one of the best players of his generation in Benji so you throw stones!

Utter feckless dopes who are throwing these tantys now - BUT worshipped Pascoe because of the COE white elephant.... that was happening regardless of these corrupt fools..

@boonboon tell me how good a job Pascoe was doing again!

View attachment 14632
View attachment 14633
Actually I was a member. Have been ever since membership started and followed Wests Magpies before that since 1963. And it's my opinion. You do know what an opinion is I assume. Everybody has one-even you.
 
Actually I was a member. Have been ever since membership started and followed Wests Magpies before that since 1963. And it's my opinion. You do know what an opinion is I assume. Everybody has one-even you.
So why were you so content for the past 12 years while Rome burned under incompetent muppets?
 
So why were you so content for the past 12 years while Rome burned under incompetent muppets?
Who said I was content? Despite the club's many stuffups I continued membership hoping that things might change for the better. They didn't unfortunately. Hopefully Richardson can make the place successful again
 
Yep through Kimmorley in the deep end.

Was so non-committal and sound like he was shirking the responsibility before he'd even started.
 
Who said I was content? Despite the club's many stuffups I continued membership hoping that things might change for the better. They didn't unfortunately. Hopefully Richardson can make the place successful again
I said it - because you weren't the catastrophising prophet of doom your are now for over a decade while Pascoe - Marina and Lee royally screwed the club from within - PLUS spent members revenue on regular long lunches with the Fox/News Ltd crew... only to be a front-page laughing stock with their lunch companions...

But you want to pull the trigger on the new CEO and coach after less than 12 months...
 
I said it - because you weren't the catastrophising prophet of doom your are now for over a decade while Pascoe - Marina and Lee royally screwed the club from within - PLUS spent members revenue on regular long lunches with the Fox/News Ltd crew... only to be a front-page laughing stock with their lunch companions...

But you want to pull the trigger on the new CEO and coach after less than 12 months...
The point I was making is that any head coach other than Benji (who has a signed 5 year deal) would have been sacked long ago. I also said I liked Benji and hoped he'd be successful next year with the new recruits we've signed plus a few others. I've never suggested Richo be removed. Quite the contrary.
 
Everything is coachable, even speed - although Phil Gould will try and tell you otherwise.
There is no player who makes it to this level who doesnt have that dog in him that wants to win.
Good coaches get it out of them regularly.
Coach speed? All coaches coach speed so can you coach someone to go faster than the coached speed. No.
It finally becomes the natural thing. You have it or you don't.
 
The point I was making is that any head coach other than Benji (who has a signed 5 year deal) would have been sacked long ago. I also said I liked Benji and hoped he'd be successful next year with the new recruits we've signed plus a few others. I've never suggested Richo be removed. Quite the contrary.
WRONG - but no other rookie coach would be signed to a 5-year deal unless you've got suckers like Justin & Lee running the joint!

Even Terry Lamb got TWO full seasons with us (despite the Hoppa + Field and McGuinness scandals/suspensions in 2001) - before we had to pull the pin and bring in Sheensy in 2003!

So many short memories on here...

Lee Murphy
Hassan Saleh
Trent Runciman
Ben Black...

Ring any bells?
 
I have to agree with this. That was my take during the live game. Couldn't sleep tonight and watched the game again. Imo, 5 of their tries came directly from his bad defensive decisions.

The try at 12 minutes in, Douhi is jogging behind Frizell who takes the pass and crashes over the line. If he sprints to keep up, he could have taken Frizell down as soon as he catches the ball.

In the try in the 20th minute, he's way out of the line but not putting pressure on anyone because the attacking line is so deep. Since he's so far out of the line, it drags Alaimalo up and makes for an easy heads up play to kick over the top to the wing.

The try in the 30th minute is another bad read. He jams in again, this time it looks like he's covering Frizell, but he basically pushes across in front of Galvin who already has Frizel covered. That creates an overlap and there's not much Alaimalo can do.

The try on half time, he slides in after Galvin comes out of the line but appears to only have eyes for Gagai. It's as if he's taken by surprise that Ponga catches the ball behind Gagai. In any other game, Ponga knocks on at that point, but Douhi should have been ready to cover the player out the back. Special shout out here to Seyfarth as he's the only player in the defensive line who comes across to attempt to cover the play and doesn't give up.

The try in the 55th minute looks like Douhi only has eyes for Frizell and doesn't see how deep the attackers are standing or that Ponga is lurking around the back. Galvin has Frizell covered again and Douhi is left in no man's land and its 3 on 1 for Alaimalo. To top it off, Douhi stops in the line and has no urgency to get back.

Part of my issue is that Benji should have taken him aside at half time and told him to slide rather than jam in. Since he kept doing it in the second half, I can only assume that either Benji said nothing to him, ir he ignored the direction.

Sorry for the long post. Had to get it off my chest.
It's funny because this is what he was saying before his return from injury
"The more I get close to the boys in these next few weeks and the more I can take charge of the team, I can sort of be that dominant figure and help pull some of these younger blokes in line and show them what the standards are at this club.

"If they're not living up to the standards that I feel and the other leaders feel are the benchmark, then they can go and sit back in reserve grade as far as I'm concerned.

Wonder if he's taken his own advice about these standards & maybe said to himself he needs a couple of weeks in reserve grade.
 
It's funny because this is what he was saying before his return from injury
"The more I get close to the boys in these next few weeks and the more I can take charge of the team, I can sort of be that dominant figure and help pull some of these younger blokes in line and show them what the standards are at this club.

"If they're not living up to the standards that I feel and the other leaders feel are the benchmark, then they can go and sit back in reserve grade as far as I'm concerned.

Wonder if he's taken his own advice about these standards & maybe said to himself he needs a couple of weeks in reserve grade.
1723513908889.png


AND he actually believes this bullshit...

Delusional narcissistic piece of........

I called it on Sunday when he walked out of the tunnel for the kick-off directly behind Api - that would be the full extent of his "leadership" this afternoon.
 
Yet many on here say Aliomolo let his opposite score 4 tries lol.
Very good analysis of how badly Doueihi let our left side down and really sold Aliomolo up the river.

If Benji drops Aliomolo and keeps Doueihi then there really is no use watching this team again while he is coach.

Coaches instructions to jam in & nullify Ponga on
the sweep. We were doing it on the other side too
only Faataape had more success at bringing his
man down and picking when to jam in & when 2 slide
 
Coaches instructions to jam in & nullify Ponga on
the sweep. We were doing it on the other side too
only Faataape had more success at bringing his
man down and picking when to jam in & when 2 slide

It wasn't the same the other side at all. Faataape came up nowhere near the amount Doueihi did. Also, when Faataape pushed forward he was aggressive towards an opposing player, Doueihi came up and just stood there.

So maybe the instructions were to come up, but by no means were both sides defending the same. Doueihi got it horribly wrong over and over again.
 
Last edited:
People need understand Benji was rushed into Coaching position under the blind theory he would learn under the coaching guru Sheens well that was a cluster from the inception, Nothing from current season is showing any player having their skills developed, there is no real attacking structure our defensive structure is poor and constantly shows that we are unfit, lack strength, and heart to do the hard task.

Benji should have coached the lower grades before been handed the top job.

And by choice Benji is marched my choices would be 1.Sam Burgess 2. Josh Hannay 3. Dean Young.

Brad Arthur wants to coach the Western Australia side.
I agree good choice's, maybe Hannay first he'll have Billy to work with Bula, Sam next.
 
It wasn't the same the other side at all. Faataape came up nowhere near the amount Doueihi did. Also, when Faataape pushed forward he was aggressive towards an opposing player, Doueihi came up and just stood there.

So maybe the instructions were to come up, but by no means were both sides defending the same. Doueihi got it horribly wrong over and over again.
Thats because he cannot defend. Why are people so surprised by this?
 
Which one of our players have shown good defensive qualities so far this season ?
How is it possible that the entire 36 players that have played NRL for Wests Tigers in 2024 are all average at best to below average defenders ?
 
Back
Top