Opened the forum at 2pm today after working and saw the Galvin thread had like 18 unread pages since 8:30 this morning and was confused why there was so much talk. Well, I now know.
A disappointing development that a player who is from the local area, got given a chance by the Magpies after Parra saw no future for him and then debuted in the NRL at 18 years old straight from SG Ball and has been a mainstay for all of last season decides "nah frick youse". Not only that but to the biggest contract the club has ever offered a junior is just absolutely ridiculous. Galvin would probably only be playing Flegg with a bit of Cup at any other club to be honest, so it's pretty insulting for a player to do something like this. Take Pole for example. Had offers from Storm, was a Storm junior, brother in the system, lots of mates (Faalago, Stefano), but he takes the deal with us and it comes out in a news article that he wanted to repay the club for having faith in him. Now that is a great attitude and if Pole theoretically leaves the club in the future, as it stands I'd never wish him a bad game (except against us).
To be honest, I was almost wanting Galvin to go to market so that we didn't have to choose between Galvin and Latu, because it would be frustrating if we signed Galvin long-term and lost Latu but he ended up being the better player. At least this way the choice was taken out of our hands and we still leave with a back up who is probably just as good.
In terms of Galvin's immediate future, I think we need to keep him at the club until his contract runs out. From what I know he's on like 350k next year which is pretty cheap overall and releasing him is just going to make other teams better. As for where he plays, I don't think putting him in Cup or whatever out of spite is necessarily the best option. At the end of the day we want to win and if his form warrants selection in our first grade team then he needs to be there, although I agree that we should definitely prioritize Latu as he is our long-term option in the halves.
Overall, I think the club is in a very strong position to deal with this and I see it as a repeat of the Utoikamanu situation. Galvin was offered big money (overs) to stay, but he refused it. We now have $1 million extra in addition to Klemmer, Olam, 1/2 Bateman and 1/2 Sullivan's money to now look elsewhere to bolster our forwards depth, look at potentially adding another centre (although, AD, To'a been very strong this year) and most importantly upgrading and extending from within most likely looking at TDS, AD (halves backup), Bula etc.
As for where he ends up, or the clubs who enter the race here is my shortlist and reasons why and it's somewhat ordered by who I think is strongest to weakest.
Panthers - They are seriously struggling without Luai. Blaize Talagi is terrible, Cole isn't much better.
Parra - Moses link, Parra fan growing up. Major downside though being Eels currently suck.
Dolphins - They want DCE, but if they don't get him having a long-term halves pairing of Galvin/Katoa could be pretty dangerous.
Dogs - Sexton and Burton are ok, but Gus has a lot of praise for Galvin although this could be a tactical move to create a market frenzy and screw over someone elses cap.
Dragons - They are linked to almost every player on the market. Ilias and Flanagan is not great, although Atkinson incoming.
Manly and Roosters already have said they won't be entering the race I'm pretty sure, although there is always still a chance they change their mind.
A disappointing development that a player who is from the local area, got given a chance by the Magpies after Parra saw no future for him and then debuted in the NRL at 18 years old straight from SG Ball and has been a mainstay for all of last season decides "nah frick youse". Not only that but to the biggest contract the club has ever offered a junior is just absolutely ridiculous. Galvin would probably only be playing Flegg with a bit of Cup at any other club to be honest, so it's pretty insulting for a player to do something like this. Take Pole for example. Had offers from Storm, was a Storm junior, brother in the system, lots of mates (Faalago, Stefano), but he takes the deal with us and it comes out in a news article that he wanted to repay the club for having faith in him. Now that is a great attitude and if Pole theoretically leaves the club in the future, as it stands I'd never wish him a bad game (except against us).
To be honest, I was almost wanting Galvin to go to market so that we didn't have to choose between Galvin and Latu, because it would be frustrating if we signed Galvin long-term and lost Latu but he ended up being the better player. At least this way the choice was taken out of our hands and we still leave with a back up who is probably just as good.
In terms of Galvin's immediate future, I think we need to keep him at the club until his contract runs out. From what I know he's on like 350k next year which is pretty cheap overall and releasing him is just going to make other teams better. As for where he plays, I don't think putting him in Cup or whatever out of spite is necessarily the best option. At the end of the day we want to win and if his form warrants selection in our first grade team then he needs to be there, although I agree that we should definitely prioritize Latu as he is our long-term option in the halves.
Overall, I think the club is in a very strong position to deal with this and I see it as a repeat of the Utoikamanu situation. Galvin was offered big money (overs) to stay, but he refused it. We now have $1 million extra in addition to Klemmer, Olam, 1/2 Bateman and 1/2 Sullivan's money to now look elsewhere to bolster our forwards depth, look at potentially adding another centre (although, AD, To'a been very strong this year) and most importantly upgrading and extending from within most likely looking at TDS, AD (halves backup), Bula etc.
As for where he ends up, or the clubs who enter the race here is my shortlist and reasons why and it's somewhat ordered by who I think is strongest to weakest.
Panthers - They are seriously struggling without Luai. Blaize Talagi is terrible, Cole isn't much better.
Parra - Moses link, Parra fan growing up. Major downside though being Eels currently suck.
Dolphins - They want DCE, but if they don't get him having a long-term halves pairing of Galvin/Katoa could be pretty dangerous.
Dogs - Sexton and Burton are ok, but Gus has a lot of praise for Galvin although this could be a tactical move to create a market frenzy and screw over someone elses cap.
Dragons - They are linked to almost every player on the market. Ilias and Flanagan is not great, although Atkinson incoming.
Manly and Roosters already have said they won't be entering the race I'm pretty sure, although there is always still a chance they change their mind.