Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

[Tom Shines]

He would be worth a bit more to a UK Super League team, but he doesn’t seem to want to take that option.
He’s only value to us if we don’t retain Heath Mason, but if we re-sign Heath there is not much need for Bud.

They need 4 halves in the Top 30 ..so if you pay big money for him to play elsewhere…. He will still need to be replaced

 

[Vicious]

schnider and garner on the bench for Penrith … going light too

Garner generally looks like he’s 6 foot 5 and bulletproof against us, he will probably come on and score a hat trick,

 

[Vicious]

They need 4 halves in the Top 30 ..so if you pay big money for him to play elsewhere…. He will still need to be replaced

Yes Luai, Fainu, Mason and a genuine halfback with a kicking game.
Young Alex Conti or Jonah Glover could be that genuine halfback option unless we opt for someone more experienced such as Jake Arthur ?

 

[tigahhh]

Garner generally looks like he’s 6 foot 5 and bulletproof against us, he will probably come on and score a hat trick,

average player has career defining game against west tigers arc

 

[Tom Shines]

Yes Luai, Fainu, Mason and a genuine halfback with a kicking game.
Young Alex Conti or Jonah Glover could be that genuine halfback option unless we opt for someone more experienced such as Jake Arthur ?

Like I’m saying …If depends on how cheap you can get Bud away for to another team … no one is taking him at $550k … I dont think it makes sense financially to pay another club like $350-$400k of his wage and then pay for someone else to come on board ….you might just need to live with Bud at the bottom of your squad in 2026 at least …

 

[Vicious]

Like I’m saying …If depends on how cheap you can get Bud away for to another team … no one is taking him at $550k … I dont think it makes sense financially to pay another club like $350-$400k of his wage and then pay for someone else to come on board ….you might just need to live with Bud at the bottom of your squad in 2026 at least …

The problem with that is we would essentially have 4 x 5/8’s all with below average kicking games as the halves on our roster.
We desperately need one genuine halfback with a good, confident kicking game to call on if required.
That’s the season I like the idea of someone like Jake Arthur. I reckon he would only cost around 200k and although he’s never really taken his chances at NRL level, he has been a NSW Cup standout for 3 or so years, has a decent, confident kicking game, is a bigger body for a halve, defends intelligently and solidly, knows how to play straight with good structure and has fitness levels up there with Galvin’s.
I’d say he goes to the UK Super League for bigger money at this stage of his career, but you never know he could possibly consider signing for 12 months to challenge the likes of Latu Fainu, Heath Mason, Talyn Da Silva for a NRL spot in the halves or as a 14.

 

[Tom Shines]

The problem with that is we would essentially have 4 x 5/8’s all with below average kicking games as the halves on our roster.
We desperately need one genuine halfback with a good, confident kicking game to call on if required.

Aren’t Bud and Latu 7s ? And we know JL can play there if need be

But the problem with your idea of bringing in another guy is that you are paying 5 people now and that we will be spending too much money at the position and it will unbalance the squad .. this is the problem when you overspend on dud players…

Edit - Jake Arthur has his faults to … has even less pace than Galvin

 

[Alex Seyfarth's #1 Fan]

Koroisau to Perth rumours are just part of the negotiation process. I highly doubt it happens. Benji is in love with his play style. They will make it work somehow.

 

[Vicious]

Aren’t Bud and Latu 7s ? And we know JL can play there if need be

But the problem with your idea of bringing in another guy is that you are paying 5 people now and that we will be spending too much money at the position and it will unbalance the squad .. this is the problem when you overspend on dud players…

Edit - Jake Arthur has his faults to … has even less pace than Galvin

I’ve never seen Bud or Latu play anything like a genuine 7 to be honest, even when they wear the 7 on their back.
I hope I’m wrong, but Latu is a running 6 with a very limited kicking game.
I really like him as a running 6 with power, speed and class, but he’s not even close to a 7 from what I’ve seen.

 

[Tom Shines]

I’ve never seen Bud or Latu play anything like a genuine 7 tj bd honest, even when they wear the 7 on their back.
I hope I’m wrong, but Latu is a running 6 with a very limited kicking game.
I really like him as a running 6 with power, speed and class, but he’s not even close to a 7 from what I’ve seen.

I disagree with Latu …he has a passing game and can play 7 …

Bud ain’t good anywhere

 

[Vicious]

I disagree with Latu …he has a passing game and can play 7 …

Bud ain’t good anywhere

Don’t forget we already have a fullback who has no idea how to kick a ball in general play, that means it’s essential our 6 and 7 can both do it and do it well.

 

[Tom Shines]

Don’t forget we already have a fullback who has no idea how to kick a ball in general play, that means it’s essential our 6 and 7 can both do it and do it well.

Latu and Luai are the preferred halves pairing now … so let’s see how they go the rest of the year ..if Latu can stay on the field … if they don’t work then I guess they will need to bring in someone else

 

[KH1988]

Kinda like how releasing an overpaid player and replacing him with another player for more money wouldn’t be considered cap relief..

Didn’t ’make it up at all’ it Was mentioned by one of his team mates in a podcast - they wanted to offload Latu and were spewing it cost them Samuela as well (or words to that effect) mentioned on the back of Samuelas year with us.

I’d reckon one of his team mates would have some idea - maybe more than me, maybe even you…

You assume I’m wrong / or making shit up - do you have anything outside your opinion to back up your take on it?

Can you let us know the teammate and podcast - would like to check it out

 

[Canadian Club]

I can’t wait to see an attacking right edge of Latu, KPP, To’a and Turuva with Bula sweeping.

 

[stephen]

I can’t wait to see an attacking right edge of Latu, KPP, To’a and Turuva with Bula sweeping.

I'd really hope Bula gets a bit of coaching on how to unlock his outside men. He's doing OK but often is passing a little early. Like to see him straighten more before passing.

 

[user118245]

Overpay for Staggs honestly

 

[tigahhh]

i know we lost the game and it sucks but honestly , there are brighter days coming for this club . they are playing for each other and the coach , latu regularly playing will be so good to watch .

 

[Vicious]

i know we lost the game and it sucks but honestly , there are brighter days coming for this club . they are playing for each other and the coach , latu regularly playing will be so good to watch .

Latu is a class act, but what is his best position and where does he suit us best ?

 

[tiger05premier]

i know we lost the game and it sucks but honestly , there are brighter days coming for this club . they are playing for each other and the coach , latu regularly playing will be so good to watch .

Better things coming hey

Let's just hope they arrive b4 we add another spoon to the cabinet

 

[tigahhh]

Latu is a class act, but what is his best position and where does he suit us best ?

i’ve been trying to convince everyone on this forum for ages what he is capable of haha , kid can play anywhere he’s just that lethal but i’d say 6 atm .