Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

[Mighty_Tiger]

Elite players would not be interested if we offer more than anyone else ?
People are quick to forget Luai only signed with us because we offered him more than anyone else.
You can say and think what you like, but neither player is putting the club first if they do not sign to extend with us by the end of this week.

Luai did say in his press announcement that the Bulldogs offered him more. He has also said multiple times he wants to turn things around.

What he has done recruiting and behind the scenes wise isn’t a sign of a player just here for a pay check. Yes he needs to win us more games & be a bigger difference maker. But he hasn’t acted like someone collecting a pay check - and we have had many of those over the last 20yrs.

So you’re wrong again.

 

[tigahhh]

Regarding Luai you would think and hope that’s the case, as you say based on what he has publically stated.
But it makes you wonder what he’s waiting for ?
Could he be waiting to see if he gets MOTM in the Pacific Nations final then potentially hit us up for a pay rise?

pretty obvious it’s a safeguard if benji gets sacked and the club goes back to being a basket case.

 

[Vicious]

Luai did say in his press announcement that the Bulldogs offered him more. He has also said multiple times he wants to turn things around.

What he has done recruiting and behind the scenes wise isn’t a sign of a player just here for a pay check. Yes he needs to win us more games & be a bigger difference maker. But he hasn’t acted like someone collecting a pay check - and we have had many of those over the last 20yrs.

So you’re wrong again.

Until he removes the get out clause and doesn’t expect us to pay him anymore than what his current contract stipulates, I am neither right or wrong.
What is he waiting for ?

 

[innsaneink]

I think you are underestimating the impact yet another rebuild would have on our ability to recruit.

They will put their interests first (when it comes to contracts etc.), wouldn't you?

Bingo

This is my concern...not just recruitmemt but cohesion as a team it sets us right back really negating the improvement weve shown

 

[Vicious]

pretty obvious it’s a safeguard if benji gets sacked and the club goes back to being a basket case.

There is no risk of Benji being sacked in the foreseeable future unless we start the 2026 season very poorly.

 

[Rock Hopper Steve]

pretty obvious it’s a safeguard if benji gets sacked and the club goes back to being a basket case.

Wouldn't be surprised If Benji's written into the clause, he is the reason he signed with us.

 

[Tom Shines]

Apparently, Nathan Brown is potentially coming to the Tigers on a 1 year deal. Does anyone have any intel on that?

It’s BS from what we can sleuth here … the article that originally mentioned it has been edited to remove it

 

[innsaneink]

Mind blowing stuff...

Players stats improve when they play for two of the best sides in the comp... Yet they aren't quite as great when they play at a club who's had 3 back to back spoons with the worst adminstration in the comp.

Who would have thought?

Some conveniently ignore this

 

[Vicious]

Bingo

This is my concern...not just recruitmemt but cohesion as a team it sets us right back really negating the improvement weve shown

Well if the players in question sign the contract extension/remove the get out clause and do not hold us to ransom in doing so, it will not be a problem.

 

[GNR4LIFE]

There is no risk of Benji being sacked in the foreseeable future unless we start the 2026 season very poorly.

Ridiculous if that’s the case. Three years without finals, the drums should be beating. Not many other clubs would tolerate it.

 

[Tom Shines]

Regarding Luai you would think and hope that’s the case, as you say based on what he has publically stated.
But it makes you wonder what he’s waiting for ?
Could he be waiting to see if he gets MOTM in the Pacific Nations final then potentially hit us up for a pay rise?

He is likely waiting until Nov 1 to officially negotiate with Perth Bears

 

[GNR4LIFE]

He is likely waiting until Nov 1 to officially negotiate with Perth Bears

Doubt it, The Dolphins struggled signing marquee players and they are based in South East Qld and had Bennett. The Bears are on the other side of the country. I don’t see many marquee players queuing up.

 

[Tom Shines]

Doubt it, The Dolphins struggled signing marquee players and they are based in South East Qld and had Bennett. The Bears are on the other side of the country. I don’t many marquee players queuing up.

Ok … what’s your theory then ?

 

[GNR4LIFE]

Ok … what’s your theory then ?

I just told you. The Dolphins.

 

[Tom Shines]

I just told you. The Dolphins.

Huh ? Maybe look at my post again and what I was replying to

 

[GNR4LIFE]

Huh ?

That’s my theory. They are the barometer. A new club, who didn’t attract any stars their first year. And they are in much more convenient location and they had one of the greatest coaches of all time at the helm. The Bears have a lot less going for them. They already look like being turned down by Tino and Munster. There’s two marquee players right off the bat. I think they will field a team of middle of the road first graders. Not many out and out stars.

 

[gregjm87]

Regarding Luai you would think and hope that’s the case, as you say based on what he has publically stated.
But it makes you wonder what he’s waiting for ?
Could he be waiting to see if he gets MOTM in the Pacific Nations final then potentially hit us up for a pay rise?

I don't think for a second he would be expecting to get a pay rise from us, regardless of what happens between now and round 10 (I think the deadline is, just from memory. Could be way off).

There could be plenty of other stuff happen between now and then that I could see resulting in him abandoning ship. Why would you not wait as insurance against that?

Let's paint a totally unrealistic worst case scenario. Luai struggling for form, 10 straight losses, Marshall fired, Richo died of a heart attack, Latu perennially injured, Pole still struggling, Hunt reaches 130kg, Terrell injured long term, Taylan jailed long term, club struggling financially with media reports questioning if we can afford to pay players.

All Luai had to do was wait a few months and he could have avoided being tied to that for another year. In what situation is signing early the better option for him?

It is so unreasonable to expect him to do so that if he did, sure, most of me would think heck yeah thats the commitment we want from a leader but a part of me would go is this bloke stupid? And he is supposed to be a leader here?

 

[Tom Shines]

That’s my theory. They are the barometer. A new club, who didn’t attract any stars their first year. And they are in much more convenient location and they had one of the greatest coaches of all time at the helm. The Bears have a lot less going for them. They already look like being turned down by Tino and Munster. There’s two marquee players right off the bat. I think they will field a team of middle of the road first graders. Not many out and out stars.

I was trying to provide an answer to this question … what the Dolphins did when they started is irrelevant..

Regarding Luai you would think and hope that’s the case, as you say based on what he has publically stated.
But it makes you wonder what he’s waiting for ?

Why do you think he hasn’t he already decided his future in 2027 with Wests yet ?

 

[GNR4LIFE]

Huh ? Maybe look at my post again and what I was replying to

I know. You were talking about Luai. A marquee player.

 

[Tiger Stripes]

I would play Turuva before Mason at fullback, his size reminds me of Tyrion out of Game of Thrones, even though Turuva not much taller lol.

Don't know why Mason is even mentioned as an NRL backup fullback. He struggles in KOE. Now aged 20.
He is totally confused where he should play; so is master of none!
He has maxed out like the Felledy, Matumua, Turmuth types.
Just not quite up to NRL level. Needs to be in KOE for 2026 and fingers crossed for improvements or it's bye bye IMO.