HBG, Independent Directors Sacked

IMHO I would have thought a better venue for a protest would be outside PVLs office at Fox Studios, not pretty little Pratten Park.
It seems that the NRL can help but listening to a whole lot of dedicated but toothless supporters cannot.
 
I’m just anti magpies and ….. anti Balmain ! It’s the reason our club is shit . It’s the reason there’s at the moment 4 investigations from various parties around our club, and honestly if people arnt here for wests tigers I’m gonna try and drive them out of the forum . This is a wests tigers forum .
If you want to talk wests tigers , I’m here for it . I’m happy to even start afresh if I’ve misjudged you. If that’s true that’s my bad . I apologise. Sincerely !
But I’m not happy to read Pro magpies or Balmain propaganda anymore. It should be viewed like nazism in this forum . So toxic that it’s one of the few things that are banned from talking about . Do you understand my point ? Do you get divisive this subject is , and how alienating it is for people who have NFI what the problem is ? I’m not trying to shit on your past or anyone else’s , for me that’s collateral damage for 1 united club.
It’s either get on board or we boot you off at the next stop. There’s no exceptions. We’ve been doing that for 25 years and we are the worst sports team in Australia … for any sport ! I’d honestly take the Newcastle jets hierarchy over ours . We are a joke. And it hurts my soul to admit it . And it’s because of bullshit from 25 years ago. And nothing else . So if you’re happy to drop the wests magpies stuff , I’m happy to admit fault and since been unreasonable . If not then we will go back to the way it’s been for a long time now. Which is toxic for everyone including myself and yourself . I love the wests tigers mate . I wouldn’t be on a wests tigers forum if I didn’t . There is no other love re. Sports clubs for me. And in 2025 there really shouldn’t be for any other so called wests tigers supporters. I couldn’t be any clearer .

Godwins Law at work.
 
Tbh this should be the catalyst for us to toally rebrand wests tigers not half arse it. Reserve grade, wests tigers, juniors wests tigers honestly until we kill balmian and the magpies this will always happen. Neither of those clubs exists wests tigers solo
Absolutely..all players in all junior catchment area rep teams from Matt’s up to first Grade should be Wests Tigers players in Wests Tigers team colours and kit.. so they grow up looking at the first grade and feeling that connection that they are on track to 1 day be a Wests Tigers NRL player..kids love that kind of tribal belonging and it would be strongbfor the Brand and the Club in general…
 
Last edited:
Apparently that's half the reason they got rid of the independent directors.. they wanted to do exactly this.. and the HBG didn't like the idea of giving up the magpies in NSW cup
Amazing hey , the senile selfish prigs just loved watching that magnificent magpies reserve grade side struggle into 13 place on the KOE ladder whilst the boom crowd of 300 croaked out their cries of support …Lidcombe oval abuzz with excitement and the Ambulances of the ER rooms of all surrounding suburbs on standby with the calendar date marked in advance because the trend of excitement causing cardiac concerns amongst the fan base was undeniable… strangely
 
Last edited:
Absolutely..all players in all junior catchment area rep teams from Matt’s up to first Grade should be Wests Tigers players in Wests Tigers team colours and kit.. so they grow up looking at the first grade and feeling that connection that they are on track to 1 day be a Wests Tigers NRL player..kids love that kind of tribal belonging and it would be for the Brand and the Club in general…
But we’ve pretty much all agreed on this many times before, but it seems Richo suggested it to the board and it seems like it created a cataclysmic event.
That shows what they actually think of the merger.
Mate, I was a rabid Balmain fan all my life( up until the merger). I admit it was a bit awkward in the first couple of years but now it’s just the way it is and the WT are my team.
And I’m an old fart who’s not renowned for changing views !! 🤣
 
Absolutely..all players in all junior catchment area rep teams from Matt’s up to first Grade should be Wests Tigers players in Wests Tigers team colours and kit.. so they grow up looking at the first grade and feeling that connection that they are on track to 1 day be a Wests Tigers NRL player..kids love that kind of tribal belonging and it would be for the Brand and the Club in general…
Ima fan of 3,nah 2 grades down its WestTigers orange ,WestTigers black ? to maximize our junior pool
 
Here's a look back at the dysfunction of the HBG board & amongst the debenture holders over the past 2 years from media articles with a few excerpts I've pulled out.

Oct 26 2023 - https://www.smh.com.au/sport/nrl/we...y-not-always-be-the-case-20231025-p5eey6.html

The Wests Ashfield-commissioned report, prepared by former NRL chief financial officer Tony Crawford and businessman Gary Barnier, is near completion, with Crawford saying: “We took the board of Wests Ashfield through the process, explaining our thinking, and will then move to other key stakeholders, such as Balmain and Wests Magpies. The final report should be completed inside a month.”

It is likely the report will recommend the addition of independent directors to the present seven-person board, which Wests Ashfield currently dominates via an entity known as the Holman-Barnes
Group.

One director, speaking anonymously because discussions had been confidential, said Wests Ashfield would never “sell off the farm” but could choose to carve out essential reserve powers, take a back seat and allow directors with specialist skills to make football decisions.

Aug 29 - 2024 - https://www.smh.com.au/sport/nrl/we...from-wests-tigers-merger-20240829-p5k6gp.html

Balmain director and former Tigers first grade player Garry Leo told this masthead on Thursday he and his fellow board members had “lost faith” in HBG and was calling on fellow directors to endorse the end of the troubled joint venture 25 years after it was established.

Balmain have already held private conversations about approaching 91-year-old billionaire property developer Harry Triguboff, a diehard Tigers fan, to gauge his interest in potentially backing a Balmain licence given their limited financial resources. The other name being discussed is billionaire automotive businessman, Neville Crichton, also a Balmain fan.

Balmain directors feel they were blindsided by the external review at the end of last year, and believe many of HBG’s decisions have had a negative impact on the NRL club.

“One day we’re being told Barry O’Farrell would be reappointed as one of the independent directors, now they’re saying he’s not,” Leo said.

“They want people they can control. Unfortunately, it’s why they have been going so bad all these years, and that’s because the Wests directors have had too much influence on what is happening at the club. I felt sorry for Justin Pascoe. He was basically being told what to do by Wests.”

-more-
 
Here's a look back at the dysfunction of the HBG board & amongst the debenture holders over the past 2 years from media articles with a few excerpts I've pulled out.

Oct 26 2023 - https://www.smh.com.au/sport/nrl/we...y-not-always-be-the-case-20231025-p5eey6.html

The Wests Ashfield-commissioned report, prepared by former NRL chief financial officer Tony Crawford and businessman Gary Barnier, is near completion, with Crawford saying: “We took the board of Wests Ashfield through the process, explaining our thinking, and will then move to other key stakeholders, such as Balmain and Wests Magpies. The final report should be completed inside a month.”

It is likely the report will recommend the addition of independent directors to the present seven-person board, which Wests Ashfield currently dominates via an entity known as the Holman-Barnes
Group.

One director, speaking anonymously because discussions had been confidential, said Wests Ashfield would never “sell off the farm” but could choose to carve out essential reserve powers, take a back seat and allow directors with specialist skills to make football decisions.

Aug 29 - 2024 - https://www.smh.com.au/sport/nrl/we...from-wests-tigers-merger-20240829-p5k6gp.html

Balmain director and former Tigers first grade player Garry Leo told this masthead on Thursday he and his fellow board members had “lost faith” in HBG and was calling on fellow directors to endorse the end of the troubled joint venture 25 years after it was established.

Balmain have already held private conversations about approaching 91-year-old billionaire property developer Harry Triguboff, a diehard Tigers fan, to gauge his interest in potentially backing a Balmain licence given their limited financial resources. The other name being discussed is billionaire automotive businessman, Neville Crichton, also a Balmain fan.

Balmain directors feel they were blindsided by the external review at the end of last year, and believe many of HBG’s decisions have had a negative impact on the NRL club.

“One day we’re being told Barry O’Farrell would be reappointed as one of the independent directors, now they’re saying he’s not,” Leo said.

“They want people they can control. Unfortunately, it’s why they have been going so bad all these years, and that’s because the Wests directors have had too much influence on what is happening at the club. I felt sorry for Justin Pascoe. He was basically being told what to do by Wests.”

-more-
Good luck Mestrov. Good luck Benji.
 
Nov 15 2024 - https://www.dailytelegraph.com.au/s...e/news-story/f3efacae58a63e6009d7d5eaf2c098e0

Rick Wayde, Tony Andreacchio and David Gilbert have been banned from any premises under the control of the Holman Barnes Group - the majority owner of the Tigers - pending an investigation into their conduct.

The trio plan to defend themselves against the allegations, which Wayde described as trivial.

It is understood that among the allegations - some of which are more than a year old - are claims that:

* Andreacchio referred to the wife of a fellow director as “darl”, which it is understood he vehemently denies;

* Gilbert and Wayde put pressure on a fellow director to back Andreacchio, which again they deny; and

* Wayde informed a fellow director he was in the wrong corporate box and failed to sit with his fellow directors at a number of events.

As for the allegations of putting pressure on fellow director Vince Tropiano, Wayde said: “We asked him the question of whether he was still voting for Tony as chair, which seemed like a reasonable question.

“Then he has accused us of taking him into a back room and pressuring him.'

“I am accused at one of the games in Campbelltown of telling (a director) they were in the wrong box when they started (eating) the food that was available there.

“I knew that because I was in the wrong box … but I had been invited to say hello to some of the Wests Tigers people by Danny Stapleton.”

Wayde was flabbergasted at claims he had failed to sit with fellow directors.

“There are seven events - I am not sure what the list is for the other two guys - where we are accused of not sitting with the guys and wives at various events,” Wayde said.

“Out of my list of events, there were two (events) I was running … where I didn’t sit with anybody. There is another one I didn’t even attend.

“So I don’t know how I couldn’t sit with them if I wasn’t there.”

Dec 14 2024: https://www.news.com.au/sport/nrl/t...y/news-story/f5fff0ea809bca811642cf5f038f30fe

former HBG chairman Tony Andreacchio has sent a text to several club members saying a HGB power struggle will end up with a board of directors that could push for the removal of the Tigers brand.

Andreacchio’s latest text shows he fears for the club’s direction if members of the HGB hold sway on the NRL club’s board.

“If the plan devised by these … individuals unfolds as expected later this week, our removal as directors will be finalised and our club membership will be banned indefinitely,” Andreacchio sent, according to the SMH.

“Consequently, the HBG will fall under the control of a cabal of four, supported by an outdated debenture holder system (currently comprising only 18 individuals). Their misguided ambition is to see the Western Suburbs Magpies replace the Wests Tigers in the NRL competition.”

-more-
 
Ima fan of 3,nah 2 grades down its WestTigers orange ,WestTigers black ? to maximize our junior pool
Mate,, get the kids onside early… get the kids supporting the club and its colours from as early as possible.. one of my earliest memories was of my parents excitedly handing me my sought after Tigers footy pants that i could wear and imagine i was Larry Corowa sprinting down the sideline for a TRY…made me a fan for life …. Balmain till the Merger but Wests Tigers from the minute they ran onto the field for the first game as a JV.. its not fair to want Balmain back becuse we have a shared heritage now and should be focussed on using all of the strength that the merger was supposed to bring.. Richo sees that and he is hard at work on focusing all the strength of alll the supporters and the catchment areas to create a superpower club… Jesus i hope he stays and is allowed to finish his rebuild
 
Last edited:
Jan 1 2025: https://www.smh.com.au/sport/nrl/th...-for-a-combined-15-years-20250101-p5l1iq.html

The three Holman Barnes Group (HBG) directors who were the driving force behind the independent review that forced significant change at the Wests Tigers have been banned by the club’s majority owner for almost 15 years combined.

Tony Andreacchio, Rick Wayde and David Gilbert were all hit with significant bans on New Year’s Eve for a range of alleged misdemeanours dating back several years.

Andreacchio, Wayde and Gilbert were the chief instigators of the review, which was conducted by businessman Gary Barnier and former NRL chief financial officer Tony Crawford.

Their banishment throws into doubt whether the recommendations of the Barnier-Crawford report will be implemented in their entirety.

“The tragedy is the club is in great shape through the work of the CEO and the executive team. The remaining directors are only worried about self-interest and winding back the review which is a problem for the Wests Tigers,” Wayde said.

“In the short term, Shane Richardson and Barry O’Farrell are doing remarkable despite the interruptions. If the Gang of Four get away with this movement, they’ll be intruding even more. That’s the major concern for the Tigers."

Allegations against Andreacchio, who has also been asked to undertake an anger management course, include:

That he yelled at a fellow HBG director, calling him a “f---ing suck” approximately 10 times in front of other board members in an aggressive manner. Andreacchio repeated the comments later on despite being told words to the effect, “You can’t do this”, “Enough’s enough, we’re one team. Calm down”;
That he allegedly became red in the face and made abusive comments to a fellow director in a threatening tone;
That while waiting for a taxi after a function for the West Tigers launch of the 2024 NRL season he approached a fellow director and stood close to him and made a comment to the effect: “You f----- softie”;
That at an HBG board meeting last September he engaged in aggressive behaviour towards a fellow director, calling him a “parrot” in a raised voice.

The allegation against Gilbert was in relation to comments and actions made to a fellow director concerning his allegiances on the board.

The banned trio fell out of favour after current HBG chair Julie Romero led a coup in March which overthrew Andreacchio at the helm of the HBG board. Documents recently obtained by this masthead show that Romero had previously expressed “grave concerns” about the review.

The documents and emails also showed that Romero threatened legal action against Tigers chairman O’Farrell should he hold a Tigers board meeting without her blessing.

Jan 2 2025 - https://www.smh.com.au/sport/nrl/in...s-of-wests-tigers-owners-20250102-p5l1r1.html

Liquor and Gaming NSW has opened an investigation into the running of the Holman Barnes Group, conducting interviews with the three directors who have been banned for a combined 15 years.

The news of Wayde, Andreacchio and Gilbert’s exile prompted Inner West Council mayor Darcy Byrne to call on the NSW government to intervene in the boardroom stoush at the HBG.

“That’s what the fans want, and that is what’s needed for Wests Tigers to survive and thrive,” Byrne said.

“We’ve finally got things moving in the right direction on the football field. Tigers fans can’t afford for backroom brawling to undermine our team’s long-awaited recovery in 2025.”

-more-
 
IMHO I would have thought a better venue for a protest would be outside PVLs office at Fox Studios, not pretty little Pratten Park.
It seems that the NRL can help but listening to a whole lot of dedicated but toothless supporters cannot.
Its going to start at Pratten, I assume guest speakers will say their bit...therell be lots of media there....then we move on to Wests Ashfield

Id love to see 1000 WTs fans in WTs gear enter the club as a guest, and then drink iced water, not spend a cent lol
 
That’s the best he’s got on Richo; being hesitant to sign a guy who hadn’t played in over a year and was coming off domestic abuse accusations.

Vicious is really struggling right now lol
well not quite - there is a little bit more - inflated payments to his and his sons business, employment of other family members
 
Yeah, notreally mate, if they had a contract and deferred payment in any way in order to free up immediate cashflow in order for the club to meet immediate financial obligations then by definition they loaned the club money…even though it may have been just an accounting adjustment it was something they agreed to to help the club at a time it required help…. Coincidentally Farahs 9 predecessor also made an arrangement with his former club but back door managed to arrange terms that benefited him geatly when he secured the collateral agreed to as security for the loan in case of default…. 🧐😉

Salary cap relief, not loans to the club. Very different things
 
Jan 14 2025 - https://www.dailytelegraph.com.au/s...p/news-story/6ce61413ef14a827d1c79a9cb4845f02

One of the longest serving debenture holders at the Holman Barnes Group – the owners of the Wests Tigers – has sensationally called for the ownership structure to be changed immediately in the wake of three board members being banned.

John Hardgrove – who has been a debenture holder for more than three decades – said it is time for a major revamp of the Holman Barnes Group governance structure.

“The debenture system has served its purpose,” Hardgrove said. “I supported the system up until now because it served its original purpose of protecting the assets of the club and the support of rugby league.

“What’s happening now is outside the original intent of the group. We need to look at another system that will protect the interests of the club, its assets and the long history of a foundation rugby league club as well as the Wests Tigers.

“The debenture system is no longer fit for purpose. A new system needs to be developed and this could require an administrator to be appointed while this is being done.

“What has been done to these three people is grossly unfair and lacks procedural fairness.”

They include; Hardgrove, Gilbert and current Holman Barnes board of directors Julie Romero, Dennis Burgess, Stephen Montgomery and Vince Tropiano.

Other debenture holders include Kevin Hammond, Daniel Lane, Clare Burgess, Fiona Shand, Russell Smith, Brian Cook, Mick Liubinskas, Scott Beynon and Peter DiMichiel (chairman).

Paul Marsh – who acted for Gilbert, Wayde and Andreacchio in their dealings against Holman Barnes – is also a debenture holder.

“The penalties are a joke,” Hardgrove said. “I’ve seen what they were charged with and the penalty they were given. The penalty does not fit the alleged crime even if you believe they deserved some sort of penalty.

“What they have been given is a joke and seems to be ploy for other people to gain even more control.”

Jan 16 2025 - https://www.dailytelegraph.com.au/s...e/news-story/10e0369cd662e8b5ca6a60b4673a4648

“All I’ll say is that in our Barrister’s summary (he says) that we have been ‘stitched up’,” Gilbert, the former Cricket NSW boss said. “That says it all.”

The guilty trio were represented by lawyer Paul Marsh through a range of hearings including the week of December 9.

Marsh defended his client’s in-front of the disciplinary committee which consisted of Romero, Stephen Montgomery and Dennis Burgess. Romero, Montgomery and Burgess are fellow Holman Barnes Directors.

-more-
 

Mate,, get the kids onside early… get the kids supporting the club and its colours from as early as possible.. one of my earliest memories was of my parents excitedly handing me my sought after Tigers footy pants that i could wear and imagine i was Larry Corowa sprinting down the sideline for a TRY…made me a fan for life …. Balmain till the Merger but Wests Tigers from the minute they ran onto the field for the first game as a JV.. its not fair to want Balmain back becuse we have a shared heritage now and should be focussed on using all of the strength that the merger was supposed to bring.. Richo sees that and he is hard at work on focusing all the strength of alll the supporters and the catchment areas to create a superpower club… Jesus i hope he stays and is allowed to finish his rebuild
If Richo makes it back , we can all rejoice. Means that a plan is hatched between who ever ,and he is running the football operations , he is nobodies lacky
 
Back
Top