OFFICIAL Alex Twal #206

Its funny, my opinion of Twal hasn’t changed in the last 2 seasons. He’s the sort of player you need on the bench to run on when you need to tighten up the game.
He’s a reliable worker without being a game breaker and you can’t afford to have too many of those in the 17. 111 games and still not a single try, says it all.
If he wants to go the extra yard, then put on 10kg and drive those middle forwards back.
 
I agree. Twal needs to stay in the squad. He's a no-nonsense forward who does his job well. But the main thing for me is he is great for culture - a real hard-working, likable bloke. He strikes me as a bit of the glue that holds the squad together.
 
twentyforty said:
Its funny, my opinion of Twal hasn’t changed in the last 2 seasons. He’s the sort of player you need on the bench to run on when you need to tighten up the game.
He’s a reliable worker without being a game breaker and you can’t afford to have too many of those in the 17. 111 games and still not a single try, says it all.
If he wants to go the extra yard, then put on 10kg and drive those middle forwards back.
Click to expand...
He's not that type of front rower. His strengths are leg speed and lateral mobility. Props don't need to be try scorers. Make metres, get quick play the balls and make your tackles. He does those 3 well.

An extra 10kg isn't going to turn him into Junior Paulo.
 
Todd Packer said:
I've been a Twal fan since his first game simply because he hits and sticks in defence but I have to admit to losing faith over the first 7 games.
I don't know what's happened in the last few weeks but he really has improved a heap.
He's still a rock in defence but in attack he's now making dents and poking his nose through the line.
Click to expand...

I have liked him from the start, I think he was 5 games into his career before h missed a tackle.
 
GCfan said:
Watching live at magic round last week he looked like the forward in our side that created the most damage to the defensive line. I was pretty surprised. The Dragons really struggled to contain him
Click to expand...

I think there has been a change to his approach. He used to get close to the markers and look to cut behind the ruck, but he now seems to be getting a bit wider, using late footwork to position himself in between defenders. Much more effective.
 
Same thread every year, especially when he's coming back from injury. For whatever reason he is a slow starter, people forget he is decent in his role and then inevitably he gets praised too much because he looks real good when he has a few games under his belt.

In future if he has a few weeks off I'd give him 2 - 4 weeks in Reggie's, but when he's match fit and found his rhythm I reckon he is one of the better career bench props going around.
 
I note he takes the fourth tackle hit up more often than not when he’s on the field. I think that’s coached as he seems to he on his belly quickly and effects a fast play the ball allowing halves more time to tick on fifth.

May not look spectacular (even frustrating) but is still important.
 
weststigerman said:
weststigerman said:
He's not that type of front rower. His strengths are leg speed and lateral mobility. Props don't need to be try scorers. Make metres, get quick play the balls and make your tackles. He does those 3 well.

An extra 10kg isn't going to turn him into Junior Paulo.
Click to expand...

He's not that type of front rower. His strengths are leg speed and lateral mobility. Props don't need to be try scorers. Make metres, get quick play the balls and make your tackles. He does those 3 well.

An extra 10kg isn't going to turn him into Junior Paulo.
Click to expand...
😂 c’mon? His ptb’s are the slowest (not by much) of all our props, plus his technique of running to the D line getting tackled, then walking a couple more metres is a real momentum killer. He needs to find his front, opposition know they’ve tackled him as they go about setting their D for the next play.
I don’t want to bag the guy, because I love his contribution to the team, but just saying he needs to improve in a couple of things and let’s call it as we see it?
 
I might be of the minority, but i reckon he slows down our attack massively when he takes the hit up.

It also seems to be in all the players sub conscious to pass him the ball to score a try when he's close to the line- its infuriating, its so obvious to the defense. He is an easy tackle too, no power to him whatsoever in the final 10 meters.

I remember when he first started in the team, he had a dangerous offload and ran hard and fast. Don't know who it was but they coached that out of him and now he's incredibly one dimensional.
 
Zach said:
I might be of the minority, but i reckon he slows down our attack massively when he takes the hit up.

It also seems to be in all the players sub conscious to pass him the ball to score a try when he's close to the line- its infuriating, its so obvious to the defense. He is an easy tackle too, no power to him whatsoever in the final 10 meters.

I remember when he first started in the team, he had a dangerous offload and ran hard and fast. Don't know who it was but they coached that out of him and now he's incredibly one dimensional.
Click to expand...
Last year & At the start of the season yes. He was running straight into the middle without doing much. He seems to be finding more space and not slow the momentum down now. An improvement from the last year or so.
 
twentyforty said:
😂 c’mon? His ptb’s are the slowest (not by much) of all our props, plus his technique of running to the D line getting tackled, then walking a couple more metres is a real momentum killer. He needs to find his front, opposition know they’ve tackled him as they go about setting their D for the next play.
I don’t want to bag the guy, because I love his contribution to the team, but just saying he needs to improve in a couple of things and let’s call it as we see it?
Click to expand...
We’ll have to agree to disagree on that one.

The stats seem to support what I’m saying, this the avg play the ball speed in the game against Penrith. Pretty quick against St George as well.

1683792862742.jpeg
 
Tigerwould said:
Last year & At the start of the season yes. He was running straight into the middle without doing much. He seems to be finding more space and not slow the momentum down now. An improvement from the last year or so.
Click to expand...
I would argue everyday that once good,talented players that reach NRL level from either country group teams or juniors in the system learn the way that NRL is played ,they either improve greatly or fall off the cliff...Twal is a keeper ,he is just starting to understand his role and position in the team,,,Rome wasnt built in a day and the youth can only learn over time...
 
Always loved twally could never understand the hate he used to get by a lot of people. Always worked harder than most forward we have, tackles anything that moves and his efficiency is outrages. He’s now getting decent meters every week and is still only young. Plenty of time to bag a few meat pies
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Members online

Total: 10,853 (members: 1, guests: 10,852)
Back
Top