anderson_silva
New member
@Marshall_magic said:
exactly jarrod crocker >>>>> idris
Kevin gordon >>>>>> idris
Josh dugan >>>>>> idris
he is extrememly over rated
Ayshford for rookie of the year
- Thread starter fulleightyminutes
- Start date
exactly jarrod crocker >>>>> idris
Kevin gordon >>>>>> idris
Josh dugan >>>>>> idris
he is extrememly over rated
@Yossarian said:
:laughing: funniest post this week. Mortimer is a gun, weighs 65 kg's wringing wet, tackles blokes head on twice his size, runs all day, can kick, pass, run, has pace and can read a game of football. And best of all, he seems to have a bloody good head on his shoulders. This kid is the next big thing.
Mortimer…..............daylight...............Dugan
A
alien
Guest
Idris started the season well, then he got injured and when he came back he wasn't as good because his fitness had dropped. He will be a good player again when he gets his fitness back. Could happen pretty soon too.
Marshall_magic
New member
@stryker said:
He's only considered because of the massive media love in after he had early season form. The Dogs score all their points down the other side of the field with Slippery Josh Morris and Lord Bryson Goodwin. Jarrod Croker has shown up plenty of rep quality players in his weeks in the top grade. His schooling of Hodges springs to mind imediately. Does he have a media love in around him? no. Does he do a better job than Idris? yes.
G
Guest
Guest
@anderson silva said:
I hope for your sake the Tigers handle him on Friday night.
Sooo…....... I take it by all this Moritimer, Dugan, Idris talk..Elmo didn't get a nomination....
Meh..Dugan the best of that lot ...IMO Mortimer close second................Idris.... :laughing:
Gareth Ellis....second rower of the Year......
Meh..Dugan the best of that lot ...IMO Mortimer close second................Idris.... :laughing:
Gareth Ellis....second rower of the Year......
For me the best is Dugan. He always breaks the first tackle, he looks dangerous, supports his players well, makes a lot of metres (Most in the comp i think) and he doesnt make a lot of errors.
Mortimer has had a great year, but i also think Hayne and Fuifui have made him look good too.
Jarrod Croker would be 3rd on my list followed by Idris, Gordon, and then Locke.
Mortimer has had a great year, but i also think Hayne and Fuifui have made him look good too.
Jarrod Croker would be 3rd on my list followed by Idris, Gordon, and then Locke.
innsaneink
Well-known member
@anderson silva said:
A lack of comprehension and an inability to debate a simple topic means you have sfa…come back with a valid counter argument boot off nuffy
Im talking about now, in 2 years time he'll be ineligible for rookie of the year, nostradamus.
T
TIGS
Guest
Antonio Winterstein
851
Well-known member
@Tiger_Al said:
I agree,he has played all year,Dugan got dropped for a month,both good players though.
anderson_silva
New member
@innsaneink said:
right now hes probably 5th in line behind:
Mortimer
crocker
Dugan
Gordon
\
\
Whats so great about idris?, hes like a poor mans falou, he is the weakest aspect of the dogs outside backs.
anderson_silva
New member
@851 said:
he had got injured and came back through under 20s for one game i believe
anderson_silva
New member
@TIGS said:
there is another player idris is behind, so now hes down to 6th, LMAO idris rookie of the year
Marshall_magic
New member
@anderson silva said:
I'd have Idris behind Blake Ferguson as well.
T
TIGS
Guest
Heres a list of rookies and games played…...
Note - Daniel Mortimer has only played 6 games!
My vote would be going to:
1\. Antonio Winterstein (Played every game and equal 7th leading try scorer)
2\. Alex Glenn (Played every position for the broncos this year: centre, wing, back row, lock, hooker, utility - and was selected 18th man for NZ in the anzac test match)
3\. Tim Mannah
4\. Jarrod Croker
Antonio Winterstein 23
Tim Mannah 23
Alex Glenn 22
Jarod Croker 20
Kevin Gordon 20
Blake Ferguson 19
Matthew Wright 16
Josh Dugan 15
Steve Rapira 15
Blake Ayshford 14
Josh McGuire 14
Lewis Brown 14
Nathan Stapleton 14
Scott Porter 13
Johnny Mannah 12
David Mead 11
James Tamou 11
Kevin Locke 11
Aaron Heremaia 10
Jharal Yow Yeh 10
Travis Waddell 9
Ukuma Ta'ai 9
Josh McCrone 8
Stanley Waqa 8
Tom Symonds 8
Atelea Vea 7
Daniel Vidot 7
Jeremy Latimore 7
Jordan Tansey 7
Junior Tia Kilifi 7
Kieran Foran 7
Sisi Waqa 7
Daniel Mortimer 6
Dave Tyrrell 6
Guy Williams 5
Iwi Hauraki 5
Palmer Wapau 5
Alan Schirnack 4
Anthony Suniula 4
Dale Copley 4
Etu Uaisele 4
James Maloney 4
Jared Waerea-Hargreaves 4
Rohan Ahern 4
Shaune Corrigan 4
Sonny Tuigamala 4
Willie Mataka 4
Bodene Thompson 3
Chris McQueen 3
Isaac John 3
Joel Romelo 3
Robert Lui 3
Sandor Earl 3
Tim Natusch 3
Trent Merrin 3
Ben Hunt 2
Constantine Mika 2
Hep Cahill 2
Jonathan Wright 2
Junior Vaivai 2
Lancen Juodo 2
Leeson Ah Mau 2
Martin Kennedy 2
Shaun Fensom 2
Simon Dwyer 2
Ben McFadgen 1
Daniel O'Regan 1
Daniel Vidot 1
David Hala 1
Donald Malone 1
Gerard Beale 1
Jason Clark 1
Kayne Lawton 1
Khaild Deeb 1
Luke Kelly 1
Ray Moujalli 1
Sione Tovo 1
Siuatonga Likiliki 1
Taniela Lasalo 1
Tim Weyman 1
Note - Daniel Mortimer has only played 6 games!
My vote would be going to:
1\. Antonio Winterstein (Played every game and equal 7th leading try scorer)
2\. Alex Glenn (Played every position for the broncos this year: centre, wing, back row, lock, hooker, utility - and was selected 18th man for NZ in the anzac test match)
3\. Tim Mannah
4\. Jarrod Croker
Antonio Winterstein 23
Tim Mannah 23
Alex Glenn 22
Jarod Croker 20
Kevin Gordon 20
Blake Ferguson 19
Matthew Wright 16
Josh Dugan 15
Steve Rapira 15
Blake Ayshford 14
Josh McGuire 14
Lewis Brown 14
Nathan Stapleton 14
Scott Porter 13
Johnny Mannah 12
David Mead 11
James Tamou 11
Kevin Locke 11
Aaron Heremaia 10
Jharal Yow Yeh 10
Travis Waddell 9
Ukuma Ta'ai 9
Josh McCrone 8
Stanley Waqa 8
Tom Symonds 8
Atelea Vea 7
Daniel Vidot 7
Jeremy Latimore 7
Jordan Tansey 7
Junior Tia Kilifi 7
Kieran Foran 7
Sisi Waqa 7
Daniel Mortimer 6
Dave Tyrrell 6
Guy Williams 5
Iwi Hauraki 5
Palmer Wapau 5
Alan Schirnack 4
Anthony Suniula 4
Dale Copley 4
Etu Uaisele 4
James Maloney 4
Jared Waerea-Hargreaves 4
Rohan Ahern 4
Shaune Corrigan 4
Sonny Tuigamala 4
Willie Mataka 4
Bodene Thompson 3
Chris McQueen 3
Isaac John 3
Joel Romelo 3
Robert Lui 3
Sandor Earl 3
Tim Natusch 3
Trent Merrin 3
Ben Hunt 2
Constantine Mika 2
Hep Cahill 2
Jonathan Wright 2
Junior Vaivai 2
Lancen Juodo 2
Leeson Ah Mau 2
Martin Kennedy 2
Shaun Fensom 2
Simon Dwyer 2
Ben McFadgen 1
Daniel O'Regan 1
Daniel Vidot 1
David Hala 1
Donald Malone 1
Gerard Beale 1
Jason Clark 1
Kayne Lawton 1
Khaild Deeb 1
Luke Kelly 1
Ray Moujalli 1
Sione Tovo 1
Siuatonga Likiliki 1
Taniela Lasalo 1
Tim Weyman 1
