Balmain Tigers Face Voluntary Administration

radiowave82

New member
http://tigers.org.au/index.php/press-release-2/#.VP0sgKzNyAJ

PRESS RELEASE

Balmain Tigers face being placed in voluntary administration following local Council’s decision to rezone historic clubhouse site

One of Australia’s most famous sporting clubs, the Balmain Tigers, faces the real prospect of being placed into voluntary administration within weeks because of a decision by Leichhardt Council to rezone the site of the club’s historic home on Victoria Road, Rozelle.

The Club’s directors said an unexpected decision by the Leichhardt Mayor, Rochelle Porteous, to rezone the historic site, would make a return by the Tigers to their home of more than 50 years impossible.

The ability for Tigers to meet their short term financial obligations is heavily dependent on the Club’s directors being confident the Tigers can eventually return to a fully-operational clubhouse at Rozelle.

In 2008, the Balmain Leagues Club won approval from Leichhardt Council to redevelop its Rozelle site, following four years’ of discussions with the Council.

The 2008 zoning carries a floor-to-space ration (FSR) of 3.9:1\. However, Cr Porteous has said the site should now carry an FSR of 1:1 for commercial development and 1.5:1 for mixed-use development.

It is simply not commercially feasible for a Tigers clubhouse to be part of a development of that size.

The club worked closely with the Council to secure the 2008 zoning.

The Tigers spent some $8 million acquiring properties adjacent to the site in 2005 and 2006 on the advice of Leichhardt Council, in order to secure the required zoning.

This zoning still covers the site and would allow for a development of a scale sufficient to include a new Tigers club house.

Last year the State Government’s independent Planning Assessment Commission (PAC) said the provisions of the current zoning provided “an appropriate framework for the future redevelopment of the site”.

The Club’s directors call on Cr Porteous to heed the PAC’s advice and retain the zoning applied by Council in 2008.

The site is owned by Rozelle Village, which has loaned substantial sums of money to BLC to allow it to establish temporary operations at Five Dock and Flemington and to ensure its ongoing support of both Balmain Football Club and Balmain Junior Rugby League.

This was also meant to ensure the Tigers could eventually return to Rozelle.

Rozelle Village has continued to support BLC through difficult times which has been greatly appreciated.

Any sale of the site will be with a caveat and agreement to lease for 45 years that would secure Balmain Leagues Club’s future.

But a rezoning would mean any new owner or development would not be of sufficient size to make a Tigers return to Rozelle commercially desirable and place in serious jeopardy the agreement to lease that was negotiated by the club.

Mayor Porteous says she wants the Tigers to return to Rozelle yet makes decisions that not only prevent such a move, but which place the very future of a sporting icon in jeopardy.

The Tigers’ 16,000 members have been through the wringer.

First the global financial crisis forced the club to sell the site; then the then NSW State Labor Government forced us to vacate the site to build a Metro Station, only for the Metro to be scrapped weeks later and now, just as there was light at the end of the tunnel, Leichhardt Council has pulled the rug out from under us.

We just want a fair go.

The current zoning would allow for the construction of three towers on the site, a 12-storey residential tower, with retail space on the lower levels, eight-storey and three-storey towers, with a new premises for the Balmain Leagues Club.

It took the Balmain Leagues Club four years, eight Leichhardt Council meetings, numerous expert reports and many millions of dollars to secure Council approval of the masterplan.

It’s unfair for the Council to shift the goalposts.

More information:
Dr Leslie Glen, Chairman BTRLFC, Director BLC – 02 8789 6314
 
Liechardt Council must have recieved some brown paper bags to shift the goal posts….a far to common occurence these days....
 
Given the club made serious financial decisions based on council information, the whole thing appears unjust.

Didn't even know about the metro situation.

Totally shafted

_Posted using RoarFEED 4.2.0_
 
A few at Leichhardt Council will have the blood of a proud 107 year old, iconic sports team and institution on their hands if this happened.
 
This is just becoming embarrassing for the past players that have represented this Club with so much love and commitment .
The whole Circus just needs to be done with one way or another so emotions can be laid to rest . IMO
 
Council's response to the above Press Release

**BALMAIN LEAGUES CLUB SITE REZONING COUNCIL STATEMENT**
>
The Mayor of Leichhardt is puzzled by a media release from Balmain Tigers alleging the Club faces voluntary administration due to a Council decision.
>
Mayor of Leichhardt Cr Rochelle Porteous said that the Tigers sold the Club land to Rozelle Village Pty Limited some time ago.
>
“The only party which can now benefit from rezonings and floor space ratio (FSR) bonuses is Rozelle Village, not the Club,” she said.
>
In 2013, Council had to defer the zoning of the site in the new Local Environmental Plan as the site was subject to a ruling by the Planning Assessment Commission.
>
The NSW Government has since ruled against the application and returned control of the site to Leichhardt Council.
>
Council has begun the process of developing new local planning controls that will ensure a more sympathetic – and ultimately successful – development.
>
In November 2014 Council resolved to review its current planning controls on the site in terms of updating its traffic modelling and reviewing the design, built form and building envelope. Furthermore, in line with previous council resolutions council resolved to continue with the process of rezoning the site to 1.1 for commercial and 1.5 for mixed development.
>
It should be noted that if a developer were to lodge a development today the FSR on the site remains currently at the site specific zoning of 3.9.1.
>
“As the Tiger’s Press Release says, the FSR is already in the former 2000 Local Environmental Plan (LEP) as a deferred matter,” said Cr Porteous. “Therefore if a developer were to lodge a development application today the FSR of 3.9:1.0 would be the zoning applied.”
>
Council are currently undertaking a review of the traffic modelling and with Council's Design Advisory Group reviewing the design, built form and building envelope to address ‘best practice’ and an appropriate framework for the future development of the site.
>
Staff expect to present recommendations regulating the new Local Environment Plan and Development Control Plan to Council at the March 2015 Ordinary meeting for consideration.
>
The Mayor expressed her concern about the spurious and inaccurate claims made by the Club regarding her role as the Mayor in development matters and the actions of Council.
>
“I am aware that the current owners, Rozelle Village Pty Limited, and the Trustees of the Rozelle Village Trust settled litigation with Balmain Leagues Club Ltd last year by a Deed,” said Cr Porteous. “That Deed was confidential, but has been disclosed to Council and is available to all the members of the Balmain Leagues Club.
>
“I call on all members of the Club to ask the Directors for a copy of that Deed to see what agreements and arrangements the Club have made with the developer in their name.
>
“The Deed itself allows disclosure to the members. Once members have seen what their Board have agreed to, let’s discuss again what it is Council is alleged to have done,” the Mayor concluded.
>
For interviews please contact Rochelle Porteous: 0418 213 054
>
Recent Timeline:
>
March 2015: Council officers due to report to Council’s Ordinary Meeting
>
November 2014: Council resolves that:
>
• Council staff implement the methodology for reviewing the current controls as outlined within the report, in particular by engaging ARUP to review: The Paramics Model - by deleting retail and commercial land uses, so to achieve a level of development that accords with the Joint Regional Planning Panel decisions date 19 July 2010.
>
• Engage Council's Design Advisory Group to review the building envelope and other built form controls to address "best practice" and the Planning Assessment Commission's view that the provisions of the Leichhardt Local Environment Plan 2000 provide an appropriate framework for the future development of the site.
>
• As per previous council resolutions council continue with the process of re¬zoning the Balmain leagues club site to a floor space ratio of 1:1 for commercial development and 1.5:1 for mixed use development.
>
• As an interim arrangement prior to council adopting revised controls of 1:1 for commercial development and 1.5:1 for mixed use development for the site, Council officers initiate and complete the procedures for amending Leichhardt Development Control Plan 2013, to incorporate the Balmain Leagues Club site specific provisions from Development Control Plan 2000.
>
Report: http://www.leichhardt.nsw.gov.au/About-Council/Meetings/Ordinary/2014-Ordinary-/2014-Ordinary-November-/25-November-2014-Ordinary-Meeting
>
July 2014: The State Government refers the former Balmain Leagues Club site back to Leichhardt Council.
>
April 2014: Planning Assessment Commission rejects the application by Rozelle Village Association
>
March 2014: Project referred to the Planning Assessment Commission for determination under Ministerial delegation dated 14 September 2011.
>
March 2014: Rozelle Village Association attempts to force the Balmain Tigers into receivership.
>
More Information on the Tigers is available at http://www.leichhardt.nsw.gov.au/Community-Issues/Balmain-Leagues

http://www.leichhardt.nsw.gov.au/News-and-Events/Media-Releases/2015/Balmain-Leagues-Club-Site-Rezoning-Council-Statement
 
Fair dinkum, when is the state or federal government going to step in and end this farce, I recall that part of the Balmain Club's decision to go ahead with the redevelopment was that there was going to be Sydney Metro train station underneath the club, Labor Premier Kennealley bailed out on that one.
Who can the club sue?, the previous Mayor Darcy someone?, anyone, it just needs to come to and end.
 
Well it looks like the end is not far off..what a debacle this whole mess has been and for the record the ALP sold the club a huge dummy the light rail was NEVER going to be built . Balmain leagues club Killed by the political party that probable most of the club patrons voted for well done ALP.
 
@the third said:
This whole thing is a showcase for why local councils should be removed

_Posted using RoarFEED 4.2.0_

Speaking for someone who works in council, i resent that :imp:
 
I think the whole issue from Day 1 has been poorly handled on our part,going to war with the Council is not the answer several YEARS down the track.

IMO the last couple of DA's by Rozelle Village were ridiculous and according to some were designed to fail for whatever reason.
 
Tigers have put out an updated press release:

Leichhardt Mayor oblivious to Tigers members’ plight

March 10, 2015
Leichhardt Mayor Rochelle Porteous is WRONG when she claims that the property developer, Rozelle Village, is the only party that can benefit if the current zoning on the historic Balmain Tigers site is maintained.

The Balmain Leagues Club directors have made it abundantly clear that irrespective of who owns the site, a proposed floor-to-space ratio of 1.5 to 1 would make it unfeasible for a commercially viable Tigers clubhouse to operate.

The people who will most benefit if Leichhardt Council stuck to its original 2008 zoning decision are the Balmain Tigers’ 16,000 members who desperately want to return to the spot they called home for more than half-a-century.

The Club’ directors cannot keep operating with so much uncertainty hanging over the club.

Uncertainty that could be removed if Cr Porteous simply accepted the advice of the Planning Assessment Commission that the provisions of the current zoning provided “an appropriate framework for the future redevelopment of the site”.

Cr Porteous’s media release of 27 November last year says in black and white: “Mayor Rochelle Porteous said a Council decision reached this week would see planning staff begin rezoning the Balmain Leagues Club site to a floor space ratio of 1:1 for commercial development and 1.5:1 for mixed use development”.

The Mayor’s release today says: “It should be noted that if a developer were to lodge a development today the FSR on the site remains currently at the site specific zoning of 3.9.1”.

This is disingenuous at best.

It would be impossible for any organisation, individual or business to proceed to develop a building with an FSR or 3.9:1 when the local council is in the process of changing the zoning on the site to 1.5:1 to 1:1.

Cr Porteous and the Leichhardt Council must stop playing politics with the hopes and dreams of Tigers supporters, many of whom have lived in the Balmain area for decades.

The Tigers spent some $8 million acquiring properties adjacent to the site in 2005 and 2006 on the advice of Leichhardt Council, in order to secure the required zoning.

The site is owned by Rozelle Village, which has loaned substantial sums of money to BLC to allow it to establish temporary operations at Five Dock and Flemington and to ensure its ongoing support of both Balmain Football Club and Balmain Junior Rugby League.

This was also meant to ensure the Tigers could eventually return to Rozelle.

Rozelle Village has continued to support BLC through difficult times which has been greatly appreciated.

Any sale of the site will be with a caveat and agreement to lease for 45 years that would secure Balmain Leagues Club’s future.

But a rezoning would mean any new owner or development would not be of sufficient size to make a Tigers return to Rozelle commercially desirable and place in serious jeopardy the agreement to lease that was negotiated by the club.

Mayor Porteous says she wants the Tigers to return to Rozelle yet makes decisions that not only prevent such a move, but which place the very future of a sporting icon in jeopardy.

The Tigers’ members have been through the wringer.

First the global financial crisis forced the club to sell the site; then the NSW State Labor Government forced us to vacate the site to build a Metro Station, only for the Metro to be scrapped weeks later and now, just as there was light at the end of the tunnel, Leichhardt Council has pulled the rug out from under us.

We just want a fair go.

The current zoning would allow for the construction of three towers on the site, a 12-storey residential tower, with retail space on the lower levels, eight-storey and three-storey towers, with a new premises for the Balmain Leagues Club.

It took the Balmain Leagues Club four years, eight Leichhardt Council meetings, numerous expert reports and many millions of dollars to secure Council approval of the masterplan.

It’s unfair for the Council to shift the goalposts.
 

Latest posts

Back
Top