Alex Seyfarth's #1 Fan
Well-known member
Benji has my vote. Sorry not sorry to the haters.
Benji 2025
- Thread starter GNR4LIFE
- Start date
BAGNF05
Well-known member
I give him at least one more recruitment cycle, the team is competing and still has obvious holes in the forwards. If we can’t recruit to improve that next year, then he’s under the pump.
We won 6 from our first 9 games.
Galvin, a player Benji decided to blood and build the team around, publicly comes out and says his career will be elsewhere for the benefit of his development.
Galvin was a central focus of the team. 4 time premiership winner Luai took a back seat to accommodate the coaches plan.
This was going to have a detrimental impact.. In my opinion, it impacted the eels, Souths and storm games.. The Eels and Souths games we could have won... (I still can't believe Moses wasn't sin binned or a penalty try awarded for that tackle on lauallili
Benji now has to adjust on the fly - mason and Luai or Latu and Luai?
Before this dilemma he had the right formula and I'd say 6/9 considering our last 3 seasons is a pretty special start..
He's not going backwards by any fault of his own. I doubt many coaches get through a drama like Lachy Galvin unscathed...
Last edited:
So I've just had a post deleted but have no clue on what basis it was deleted. On the most part I applaud the mods but deleting messages without explanation is unhelpful. Also my post was hardly as incendiary as the posts exchanged a day or two ago between a couple of forum protagonists that went on for pages.
TigerJunior4
Well-known member
I like Benji’s coaching philosophies and he can obviously sell a vision to players and recruit but he simply doesn’t have the experience to be a successful head coach.
He doesn’t have the experience in establishing pathways and systems, doesn’t have the tactical nous required and hasn’t surrounded himself with exemplary assistant coaches or a coaching director/football manager that could relieve him of pressure and make up for his lack of experience/gap areas.
The Sheens/Benji five year plan was utter madness and probably the worst coaching decision any NRL club has made in the modern game.
We’re stuck with Benji though and will have to work through his flaws because we’ve simply got rid of too many coaches and we’ve got no coaches in the lower grades that can step into the role.
Sacking another coach before his contract is up would probably be the nail in the coffin for the Tigers. I couldn’t see any coach wanting to be here after that.
He doesn’t have the experience in establishing pathways and systems, doesn’t have the tactical nous required and hasn’t surrounded himself with exemplary assistant coaches or a coaching director/football manager that could relieve him of pressure and make up for his lack of experience/gap areas.
The Sheens/Benji five year plan was utter madness and probably the worst coaching decision any NRL club has made in the modern game.
We’re stuck with Benji though and will have to work through his flaws because we’ve simply got rid of too many coaches and we’ve got no coaches in the lower grades that can step into the role.
Sacking another coach before his contract is up would probably be the nail in the coffin for the Tigers. I couldn’t see any coach wanting to be here after that.
Help me understand because I genuinely don't know.
How much do coaches like Bennett or Hasler have on building pathways? I just can't imagine either would be doing that at their respective clubs..I also don't think it's the role of the NRL coach. There would be a role specifically for that. Sure Benji and the coaching team can help shape it from an influence perspective, but it's a totally different responsibility.
innsaneink
Well-known member
Way too early tonbe talkingnof sacking him.
We are going through a very rough patch right now...theres a.lesson here for everyone involved at the club and if they all learn from it theyll be better for it.
Theres no deep decline...three Ls in the trot is never good but there were good signs too bar Storm game.
We should be getting some injured players back very soon and hopefully we can start putting 60 70 80 minute games together and we will see more Ws.
We are going through a very rough patch right now...theres a.lesson here for everyone involved at the club and if they all learn from it theyll be better for it.
Theres no deep decline...three Ls in the trot is never good but there were good signs too bar Storm game.
We should be getting some injured players back very soon and hopefully we can start putting 60 70 80 minute games together and we will see more Ws.
TigerJunior4
Well-known member
Yeah it is hence why I think a coaching director/football manager is required to help Benji in this area.
My point is that I don’t think Benji is making the right selections with assistants and staff. Do you really think a coach like Payne is an adequate pick for State Cup or Matthew Betsey a good fit for head of football?
Really good points!!!
Richo should have a long talk with Benji re:
1. Guarantee he sees his contract out provided an assistant coach, agreed by both, is appointed asap.
2. If Benji doesn’t work out as coach, move him to General Manager Football Operations and the assistant appointed takes over.
3. Move Luai to Lock should Latu/Mason or other combo work out over time.
GNR4LIFE
Well-known member
I wouldn’t be moving a 4 time premiership winning half anywhere.
BAGNF05
Well-known member
There were enough signs last week to leave Luai right where he is. Mason or Latu will do well next to him.
TIGERS
Well-known member
You could be right. It's too early to tell after 1.5 seasons and I agree in avoiding just sacking yet another coach. It's too early to say that he can't coach. He's doing it now pretty good. I think we are describing making the 8 and getting this infernal wait for finals footy over and done with.
Whatever happens I think it would be totally toxic for this club to burn another legend by sacking too quick or not seeing something through. He's got some things to learn, but I don't think they're things you pick up coaching in the lower grades either.
I don't think the 5 year plan really exists in real terms. I don't think its worse than appointing Jason Taylor or Mick Potter. Richo is a world class GM of football not just a corporate officer. John Morris is a fine and very experienced coach.
But if we keep recruiting better players like May and Turuva and they're coming mostly to play for Benji... Let's keep on with it
crazycat
Well-known member
Still huge alarm bells but we have improved massively in defense.
What's sad is... At the start of the year we were working really well with Skelton + Turuva at the wings. Having solid wings in defense meant our centers could depend on their outside players.
Skelton gets injured and that side of our defense crumbles.
Naturally melbourne gets that were running with a light pack and just goes straight through our middle. Heck once you pass that 5 round stage, coaches have watched your game and can pick up weaknesses.
Hoping Benji can finish strong OR that we can nab Brad Arthur as coach.
HUNT 101
Active member
Yep ,stick with Benji if he wasn't the coach and he was announced in a Andrew Johns type roll everyone would think it's a good move..if we avoid the the spoon it's a improvement and then if we get more quality players next year with the young fellas having a season under there belt we will be closer to the pointy end .
TIGERS
Well-known member
Brad Arthur didn't make the finals with Parra until the end of his 4th season as a coach, and got a wooden spoon the following year after that.
Yep that’s exactly who I was thinking about . He was a good ref . Fell out of favour with the Cabal who are ruining the game .
I heard he actively disobeyed a directive from them , as he disagreed , and they’ve banished him . Pretty funny that when a new crop of refs not influenced by the Sutton brigade , which includes aitkins and the worst ref of all time Klein , start to emerge and excel , that 2 years later the same mediocrity is back on top .
And the young ones coming through . Are shit scared to actually make a decision , because the most technically right , even though it’s not within the spirit of the game , is the right decision apparently…. I’ve been screaming it for the the last 5-10 years .. the sooner there’s a clean out in who has the power in the ref ranks , the better off the game will be .
Getting rid of guys like Gavin Badger , Chechin , and not finding roles for gun past refs like Harrigan and Tim mander , but find ones for failed politicians who was a mediocre ref in his day … is just meh … the game is suffering because of this . It feels like the guys making decisions in the games have never actually played it . They don’t know what it feels like , so there for can’t empathise , and effectively adjudicate on the matches .
Last edited:
Cam ciraldo had a couple of rough years. Remember
Benji is smart and a hard worker, he does not have the squad yet.
We are building
Be patient,
Benji is smart and a hard worker, he does not have the squad yet.
We are building
Be patient,
Strange Comparison....
Also had plenty of experience and the best mentor in the game.
Also not surrounding himself with his mates to help out
Batmans Parents
Well-known member
This. I was all for giving Benji until at least the end of next season but bringing in the dunce of our 2010 finals run, with no coaching experience, as an assistant coach was a joke. Not to mention bringing back Hodgo when he did nothing last time he was an assistant here and had done nothing since.
I can live with Morris as he has the experience and our defence has showed signs of improvement this year.
Tom Shines
Well-known member
The COE for the pathways is being constructed at Campbelltown I believe, so this won’t be changing anytime soon