Big Willie

He has to be a better back up option than Buchanan, so at the right price would have to be seriously considered on a 1 year deal even with his track record (albeit he has been well behaved over the last few seasons re off field matters).
 
regardless of whether the club see him as a good fit, does he want to come to the tigers.

there aint a lineup of blokes wanting to come to the club,now is there?

we have arookie coach ,will struggle to win 6 games this year and apparently the club has no money.

so i dont think the club is talking from a position of strength.
 
3 yrs too late. If the moralists didn't scare the club off him, we could have gotten some decent value out of him.
 
No freaking way man. Mason would be a horrendous option with the interchange reduction next year.
 
@willow said:
No freaking way man. Mason would be a horrendous option with the interchange reduction next year.

100%… the players like Mason will struggle next year!

Maybe a younger version off the bench in short bursts, but not someone as old as him.

Shouldve signed him 3 years ago!!!
 
@Tiger Watto said:
@willow said:
No freaking way man. Mason would be a horrendous option with the interchange reduction next year.

100%… the players like Mason will struggle next year!

Maybe a younger version off the bench in short bursts, but not someone as old as him.

Shouldve signed him 3 years ago!!!

Not so sure about that. With only 2 less changes i think most teams will just push bigger minutes out of their back row and the front row rotation wont change a hell of a lot. I think going down to 6 would have made a massive difference.

As for Mason, if he wants to play for minimum wage its worth the gamble.
 
@VanillaThunder said:
@jirskyr said:
And that is why Woods is worth even more to us now.

People are knocking his form since Origin, the guy is the best long-minutes prop in the game, hands down.

Jesse Bromwich will see you now.

I posted this last week, Woods has Bromwich covered.
http://www.weststigersforum.com/viewtopic.php?f=2&t=24908&p=621660&hilit=woods#p621660
 
Trent robinson (rorters coach) was on sterlo last week. He said the interchange reduction wouldnt play too much on the front row rotation as they would still dedicate 6\. He said he would expect from backrow and lock and players like cartwright and sironen would come in to their own.
So willie would still be a feasible option. Like mentioned above, he'd add more than some we already have.
 
He is a GOOD PEST to have in your team (bit like Ennis)
One that you rather have in yours than against you.
He is well past his best but presence and niggle he brings is just about worth it
Bit like a cult hero
Will compliment Marty, Sue and Woodsy perfectly..

No more than a 12 month deal i would say
I dont think he will look odd in our colours.
 
@innsaneink said:
He's good for morale, he is a leader and players - team mates and opposition - respond and respect him

Thats what i think of him too
He is a moron but he can gel a team
Having amongst the boys will help lift when the back are to wall..

Bit like Beau Ryan, wont do much but will get the team together..
 
Next year with a reduced interchange Big Willie is not the signing we need. We need quality big engine backrowers. Not sure if their are any around, but the short stint impact players will be extinct soon
 
@Pyjamaztehboss said:
Trent robinson (rorters coach) was on sterlo last week. He said the interchange reduction wouldnt play too much on the front row rotation as they would still dedicate 6\. He said he would expect from backrow and lock and players like cartwright and sironen would come in to their own.
So willie would still be a feasible option. Like mentioned above, he'd add more than some we already have.

This was my thinking. They'll still keep the boppers in the game at the moment, there'll be more demand for the second row to play 80.

The other thing that this will do is that the game will be slowed down at every opportunity. Refs will have to start blowing penalties for deliberate time wasting.
 
1 year deal
Bring some life back into our boys
Most reports are he has pulled his head in
Could be handy replacement for big Red
 
We lack experience and we lack a bit of intimidation.

Against the Roosters last week….1st hitup of the Game JWH basically snapped Sue's neck back with an almighty hit....its most very good teams way of intimidating the opposition especially a young side like ours from the 1st minutes of a game. Apart from Taupau......we have no intimidators.

Willie has been a bit of a disaster in his career....but he's also cleaned up his act alot because he knows his days in NRL are numbered. He can still offer alot to a young side like ours ( as long as his head and attitude are in the right place )

At the right price $100k-$150k max I'd definately consider him.......we probably paid twice to three times that for galloway and he plays less than 40 minutes a week. Guys like Lovett, Santi & Buchannan are probably on similar money and how much intimidation have any of those guys had against opposition this year?....err None.

Rest my case.
 
@innsaneink said:
He's good for morale, he is a leader and players - team mates and opposition - respond and respect him

Ink… Come on. Respond to him. How... By behaving badly? It really seems to follow him.

_Posted using RoarFEED 4.2.0_
 
Gee whiz….we are scraping the bottom of the barrel here aren't we? I think I'd rather run out with 12 players to be honest.

And for those saying we should have signed him 3 years ago... With our history of backended contracts, that would mean he would be on at least 600K this year. Sill think he would be value for money?
 
Very few players are worth $600k a year IMO…thurston, Cam Smith, Inglis and a handful of others being the rare exception. Even when you look at Farah on his $900k, by the time he plays SOO and misses games for us and then comes back broken down.....we are lucky to get a good half a season out of him. Not throwing stones at Robbie...just pointing out facts.

With the current salary cap and needing a large squad to cater for injuries over a long season a young inexperienced team like the Wests Tigers needs a few old heads to bring the younger players through.

We don't need the $500k a year Blairs.....but the solid 1st graders who have 150 games under their belt that are solid performers on $250 -$300k a year.....eg Kade Snowdon, Luke Douglas, Elijah Taylor, etc etc....just as an example not saying that these are the exact guys I'd be aiming for.

Willie is worth far less but on $150k....he is a real stand up sort of bloke....if someone is putting it over one of our blokes you know Willie would be in the mix standing up for his team mates. That in my opinion is worth something to a young side like ours.
 
Stand up bloke?
lol…
More like stand-over guy.

No thanks.
Can see both the positives and negeatives tho.
 
Back
Top