Brooks vs Moses

[Geo]

This what one Parra fan thinks of him - LOL - i thought it must have been a WT forum member who snuck in to their forum.

Don't blame Moses??? The little coward was missing all night and when it mattered most he misses a conversion Stephen Hawking could of thrown over. He had absolutely nothing to do with any of our tries tonight and we looked far more dangerous when he was nowhere near the ball. Paulo and Guth played more first receiver than he did. He's not a 7's ........... he's a running 6 at best i have been saying this since 2017. Too bad the bald muppet in charge doesn't have a ............ clue.

Alan Hunt October 11, 2020 at 1:48am
We don't have anyone capable of playing 7 at the entire club, there is not a lot on the market either. We are stuck with him and Bea Arthur and more mediocrity.

unt October 11, 2020 at 2:05am
Who are you again you abusive worm??? Angry Eel indeed. Moses is a down hill sking gutless little worm just like you. Moses struts around like he's king ............ abuses team mates for mistakers yet he has done nothing and won nothing. He still has no idea how to pace a game let alone lead a team around the park. In their 20 m zone he was MIA for almost the entire game. It's not all his fault though because you can't lay all the blame on him when you have a coach who is better suited to the Grafton Ghosts.

but the Slimey fart was tutored by Joey Johns this year..

 

[hobbo1]

This what one Parra fan thinks of him - LOL - i thought it must have been a WT forum member who snuck in to their forum.

Don't blame Moses??? The little coward was missing all night and when it mattered most he misses a conversion Stephen Hawking could of thrown over. He had absolutely nothing to do with any of our tries tonight and we looked far more dangerous when he was nowhere near the ball. Paulo and Guth played more first receiver than he did. He's not a 7's ........... he's a running 6 at best i have been saying this since 2017. Too bad the bald muppet in charge doesn't have a ............ clue.

Alan Hunt October 11, 2020 at 1:48am
We don't have anyone capable of playing 7 at the entire club, there is not a lot on the market either. We are stuck with him and Bea Arthur and more mediocrity.

unt October 11, 2020 at 2:05am
Who are you again you abusive worm??? Angry Eel indeed. Moses is a down hill sking gutless little worm just like you. Moses struts around like he's king ............ abuses team mates for mistakers yet he has done nothing and won nothing. He still has no idea how to pace a game let alone lead a team around the park. In their 20 m zone he was MIA for almost the entire game. It's not all his fault though because you can't lay all the blame on him when you have a coach who is better suited to the Grafton Ghosts.

but the Slimey fart was tutored by Joey Johns this year..

But Johns was hepped up on goofballs when he played ..

 

[cochise]

Kicking- Moses (by a fair bit)
Confidence-Moses
Ball running -Brooks
Defence- Brooks ( completely different level to Moses)
Spine- Moses is spineless
Both got their flaws but I’d take brooks any day

My opinion ....both Brooks and Moses running game was their greatest strength and in 2020 it should have been what made them as players

They have both fallen off a cliff as running players


You’re not wrong
Brooks only ran the ball this season when he couldn’t see options out wide.kinda like a last resort.
Needs to learn to play what’s in front of him eg cody walker

Wow, I saw it completely differently, I thought he ran too often this year. Dummy and run was his 1st option on too many occasions.

Ya, I felt like his goto move was dummy and run into defender straight on

How I saw it too

 

[OzLuke]

This what one Parra fan thinks of him - LOL - i thought it must have been a WT forum member who snuck in to their forum.

Don't blame Moses??? The little coward was missing all night and when it mattered most he misses a conversion Stephen Hawking could of thrown over. He had absolutely nothing to do with any of our tries tonight and we looked far more dangerous when he was nowhere near the ball. Paulo and Guth played more first receiver than he did. He's not a 7's ........... he's a running 6 at best i have been saying this since 2017. Too bad the bald muppet in charge doesn't have a ............ clue.

Alan Hunt October 11, 2020 at 1:48am
We don't have anyone capable of playing 7 at the entire club, there is not a lot on the market either. We are stuck with him and Bea Arthur and more mediocrity.

unt October 11, 2020 at 2:05am
Who are you again you abusive worm??? Angry Eel indeed. Moses is a down hill sking gutless little worm just like you. Moses struts around like he's king ............ abuses team mates for mistakers yet he has done nothing and won nothing. He still has no idea how to pace a game let alone lead a team around the park. In their 20 m zone he was MIA for almost the entire game. It's not all his fault though because you can't lay all the blame on him when you have a coach who is better suited to the Grafton Ghosts.

wow....these battlers are arguing amongst themselves at 2 in the morning blaming both Moses and Arthur......

I thought we were at the top of the savage ourselves after a loss, but these guys are next level

But finishing 3rd is their idea of mediocrity.....bahahahahaha

 

[ATown]

There is no way I’d swap Brooks for Moses. Moses is an absolute imposter.

 

[mike]

This what one Parra fan thinks of him - LOL - i thought it must have been a WT forum member who snuck in to their forum.

Don't blame Moses??? The little coward was missing all night and when it mattered most he misses a conversion Stephen Hawking could of thrown over. He had absolutely nothing to do with any of our tries tonight and we looked far more dangerous when he was nowhere near the ball. Paulo and Guth played more first receiver than he did. He's not a 7's ........... he's a running 6 at best i have been saying this since 2017. Too bad the bald muppet in charge doesn't have a ............ clue.

Alan Hunt October 11, 2020 at 1:48am
We don't have anyone capable of playing 7 at the entire club, there is not a lot on the market either. We are stuck with him and Bea Arthur and more mediocrity.

unt October 11, 2020 at 2:05am
Who are you again you abusive worm??? Angry Eel indeed. Moses is a down hill sking gutless little worm just like you. Moses struts around like he's king ............ abuses team mates for mistakers yet he has done nothing and won nothing. He still has no idea how to pace a game let alone lead a team around the park. In their 20 m zone he was MIA for almost the entire game. It's not all his fault though because you can't lay all the blame on him when you have a coach who is better suited to the Grafton Ghosts.

I hope they keep him long term and never win a comp. His failures at the Eels would “almost” make the way he left us tolerable, almost.

 

[cktiger]

A lot of love on here for a bloke playing so poorly this year he got dumped out of the team.

 

[jrtiger]

Moses has more options to hit. his edge consists of Matterson, Waqa Blake and Ferguson. he also plays off the back of a far superior forward pack. you give Brooks those players around him and make him the dominant half and he would quickly prove who's the better player. I'm confident him and Doueihi will turn into a decent pairing next year providing our pack lays a platform.

 

[The_Return]

The fact that Brooks is complete and utter 3rd rate garbage that will never take the Tigers to the finals, id say Moses is better. Much better.

Bring in the mediocrity accepting fans and downvote away instead of acknowledging reality. That'll work. Im sure Brooks will do the job next year, or the year after, or the year after.

 

[the_third]

To be fair Moses was in the top 10 point scorers - where was Brooks. However that is the only thing he has over him - a goalkicker. Still wouldn't have him anywhere near WT.

One was in a team that finished top 4 and kicked goals. The other was with us

 

[Speed2burn]

A lot of love on here for a bloke playing so poorly this year he got dumped out of the team.

I don’t think anyone here is saying brooks is a superstar. But when you look at it, Moses has the right environment to be a dominant playmaker when it comes to a big mobile forward pack and fast outside pacy backs. Yet he’s still hopeless

Brooks literally has none of those to work with

 

[the_third]

I like how every tv news in the sports section they replay Moses’s missed kick. Hope it haunts him for a very long time.

Personally I liked the double chip attempt, then the stand up and complain to the ref while Souths are charging towards the try line.

Speaks so nicely to his character

 

[cktiger]

A lot of love on here for a bloke playing so poorly this year he got dumped out of the team.

I don’t think anyone here is saying brooks is a superstar. But when you look at it, Moses has the right environment to be a dominant playmaker when it comes to a big mobile forward pack and fast outside pacy backs. Yet he’s still hopeless

Brooks literally has none of those to work with

First it was blaming everyone around him for not giving him the ball and now it’s all of our dud team, forwards and backs for not giving him ammunition.
Truth is he’s a five year flop- the definition of insanity is to keep doing the same thing and expect a different result.
Who could forget the ‘Dally M ‘ half of the year wasting away with us while Cronk led the Roosters to the grand final and Cherry-Evans and Cleary were playing Origin.

 

[mike]

I like how every tv news in the sports section they replay Moses’s missed kick. Hope it haunts him for a very long time.

Personally I liked the double chip attempt, then the stand up and complain to the ref while Souths are charging towards the try line.

Speaks so nicely to his character

Yes, instead of tackling Cook, he whinged to the ref like a toddler, and Cook runs down the field, sidestepped Gutherson to score a try.

 

[tbones10]

My personal feeling on Brooks are well documented and Madge is backing him big time for 2021. That being said Brooks is ours and Moses can get stuffed.

 

[the_third]

I like how every tv news in the sports section they replay Moses’s missed kick. Hope it haunts him for a very long time.

Personally I liked the double chip attempt, then the stand up and complain to the ref while Souths are charging towards the try line.

Speaks so nicely to his character

Yes, instead of tackling Cook, he whinged to the ref like a toddler, and Cook runs down the field, sidestepped Gutherson to score a try.

Literally made my weekend seeing that from the pea heart.

 

[Geo]

A lot of love on here for a bloke playing so poorly this year he got dumped out of the team.

I don’t think anyone here is saying brooks is a superstar. But when you look at it, Moses has the right environment to be a dominant playmaker when it comes to a big mobile forward pack and fast outside pacy backs. Yet he’s still hopeless

Brooks literally has none of those to work with

First it was blaming everyone around him for not giving him the ball and now it’s all of our dud team, forwards and backs for not giving him ammunition.
Truth is he’s a five year flop- the definition of insanity is to keep doing the same thing and expect a different result.
Who could forget the ‘Dally M ‘ half of the year wasting away with us while Cronk led the Roosters to the grand final and Cherry-Evans and Cleary were playing Origin.

Yeah but the Slimey's have been doing it for 34 years..

 

[GNR4LIFE]

The fact that Brooks is complete and utter 3rd rate garbage that will never take the Tigers to the finals, id say Moses is better. Much better.

Bring in the mediocrity accepting fans and downvote away instead of acknowledging reality. That'll work. Im sure Brooks will do the job next year, or the year after, or the year after.

What’s Moses ever done?

 

[GNR4LIFE]

A lot of love on here for a bloke playing so poorly this year he got dumped out of the team.

I don’t think anyone here is saying brooks is a superstar. But when you look at it, Moses has the right environment to be a dominant playmaker when it comes to a big mobile forward pack and fast outside pacy backs. Yet he’s still hopeless

Brooks literally has none of those to work with

First it was blaming everyone around him for not giving him the ball and now it’s all of our dud team, forwards and backs for not giving him ammunition.
Truth is he’s a five year flop- the definition of insanity is to keep doing the same thing and expect a different result.
Who could forget the ‘Dally M ‘ half of the year wasting away with us while Cronk led the Roosters to the grand final and Cherry-Evans and Cleary were playing Origin.

You’re missing the point of this thread, as are a couple other routine Brooks bashers. This isn’t about pumping Luke’s tyres up, it’s about whether he’s truly any worse than the poser who failed to stand up yet again in a final last night.

 

[mike]

The fact that Brooks is complete and utter 3rd rate garbage that will never take the Tigers to the finals, id say Moses is better. Much better.

Bring in the mediocrity accepting fans and downvote away instead of acknowledging reality. That'll work. Im sure Brooks will do the job next year, or the year after, or the year after.

What’s Moses ever done?

Got a wooden spoon.