Counting to Six SEMI FINAL SPOILER

[GNR4LIFE]

Big rumors around that the the Sharks are about to feel an almighty wrath over this ASADA investigation. I know we've been hearing it all yr, but the next couple days could be very interesting.

 

[happy_tiger]

Big rumors around that the the Sharks are about to feel an almighty wrath over this ASADA investigation. I know we've been hearing it all yr, but the next couple days could be very interesting.

Funny you bring this up GNR , what I have been hearing is mid October is when this will all hit the fan

 

[innsaneink]

Neither referee noticed it was the 7th tackle. The video ref didn't either. The commentators didn't either. None of the channel nine tech people noticed. I didn't notice and I was watching. Did anyone know?

quite a few people in a live game thread on another forum noticed straight away

 

[Eye_Of_Da_Tiger]

Give the game to he Cowboys this is just disgraceful. :brick:

 

[Flippedy]

Big rumors around that the the Sharks are about to feel an almighty wrath over this ASADA investigation. I know we've been hearing it all yr, but the next couple days could be very interesting.

Funny you bring this up GNR , what I have been hearing is mid October is when this will all hit the fan

It will be a real slap in the face for the Cowboys if the team that controversially beat them and put them out of the finals yesterday end up being disqualified due to the ASADA investigation, because yesterday will never be repeated, regardless.

 

[system]

Big rumors around that the the Sharks are about to feel an almighty wrath over this ASADA investigation. I know we've been hearing it all yr, but the next couple days could be very interesting.

Hope so. Can't stand Cronulla and a big majority their fans are nothing but drunken animals. Unfortunate for the good ones.
Some real bad reports coming out regarding poor behavior yesterday.
Hope they get what they deserve.
Up Up Cronulla my big white arse.

_Posted using RoarFEED 2013_

 

[WestsSupporter]

There should be some sort of consequence for the Sharks. i remember in 2009 the Dogs lost the minor premiership because they were penalised two competition points for having 14 men on the field at one point during an earlier game in the year.

 

[pHyR3]

There should be some sort of consequence for the Sharks. i remember in 2009 the Dogs lost the minor premiership because they were penalised two competition points for having 14 men on the field at one point during an earlier game in the year.

Yes, because the sharks are the ones who called 5th tackle on the 6th…... :crazy

 

[pHyR3]

Big rumors around that the the Sharks are about to feel an almighty wrath over this ASADA investigation. I know we've been hearing it all yr, but the next couple days could be very interesting.

Funny you bring this up GNR , what I have been hearing is mid October is when this will all hit the fan

It will be a real slap in the face for the Cowboys if the team that controversially beat them and put them out of the finals yesterday end up being disqualified due to the ASADA investigation, because yesterday will never be repeated, regardless.

If the sharks got done in tomorrow, surely the Cowboys would progress. Manly (i think) can't be allowed to just progress to the prelims having not won a match…

 

[balmain boy]

If Sharks get done now they'd have to be out of this seasons finals , and then deducted something like 20-30 points for next season. It's too late in the year to punish them now. Highly doubtful anything will happen before the grand final though. They've had all year and seemingly made bugger all progress.

 

[WestsSupporter]

No one seems to like the Sharks. I haven't seen one post on any forum, from somebody other than a fan of theirs, supporting them in any way. In fact, I see a lot of forum users hoping they get done.

 

[Newtown]

It's hypocritical how the NRL comes down very heavy on others for what they (NRL) see as bringing the game into disrepute yet hardly blinks an eye to last weekend's debacle.

 

[happy_tiger]

No one seems to like the Sharks. I haven't seen one post on any forum, from somebody other than a fan of theirs, supporting them in any way. In fact, I see a lot of forum users hoping they get done.

I used to like The Sharks , then for some reason they got this stupid idea in their heads thinking they were allowed to beat the Tigers

Since then I hate them like every other team

 

[Marshall_magic]

There should be some sort of consequence for the Sharks. i remember in 2009 the Dogs lost the minor premiership because they were penalised two competition points for having 14 men on the field at one point during an earlier game in the year.

Yes, because the sharks are the ones who called 5th tackle on the 6th…... :crazy

I agree, it's not their fault the ref is incompetent. Beau Ryan said he had no idea it was the 7th tackle until Freddy told him after the game. Todd Carney said he found out on the way home listening to the radio. To overturn it is ridiculous. Not to mention the Sharks ground out the win when they took the front. If they know they are having 6 points deducted from their score they would not be hitting it up and kicking to the corners to wind the clock down, they'd be throwing the ball around. Replaying it sets a dangerous precedent and is a road I don't want the game to go down. We didn't replay our game against Cronulla in round 1, 2012 when we got an advantage from a ref not knowing the rules in golden point.

 

[happy_tiger]

There should be some sort of consequence for the Sharks. i remember in 2009 the Dogs lost the minor premiership because they were penalised two competition points for having 14 men on the field at one point during an earlier game in the year.

Yes, because the sharks are the ones who called 5th tackle on the 6th…... :crazy

I agree, it's not their fault the ref is incompetent. Beau Ryan said he had no idea it was the 7th tackle until Freddy told him after the game. Todd Carney said he found out on the way home listening to the radio. To overturn it is ridiculous. Not to mention the Sharks ground out the win when they took the front. If they know they are having 6 points deducted from their score they would not be hitting it up and kicking to the corners to wind the clock down, they'd be throwing the ball around. Replaying it sets a dangerous precedent and is a road I don't want the game to go down. We didn't replay our game against Cronulla in round 1, 2012 when we got an advantage from a ref not knowing the rules in golden point.

Some Shark players would of known , even just watching the game I'm counting the tackle count both in attack and defence

People who think that players hear the ref yell out 5th tackle and they go " What 5th tackle , that went so fast " :laughing: tell em their dreaming

As a play maker you are setting to something and saying things like 3 plays til we bomb , or running a play I would say at the least the 6,7 and 9 would of known and Carney is just BS ing us

 

[Tiger_Watto]

Some Shark players would of known , even just watching the game I'm counting the tackle count both in attack and defence

People who think that players hear the ref yell out 5th tackle and they go " What 5th tackle , that went so fast " :laughing: tell em their dreaming

As a play maker you are setting to something and saying things like 3 plays til we bomb , or running a play I would say at the least the 6,7 and 9 would of known and Carney is just BS ing us

They normally dont count the tackles as a set of six, but they definitely count the set down to which ever play the are working towards. From time to time, this might not be counting to 5, as they might have a 4th tackle option, but I think its safe to say every 7 or 6 in the comp would've known something wasnt right. Most Fullbacks would've know also, but on this occasion, the Sharks had plenty of bodies in motion, so Bowen should be forgiven.

The idea of replaying or stripping victory is simply not gona happen… Either way, I still think the NRL have a duty of care to ensure a correct result where possible. The fact they would've know before halftime, I think they have failed the Cowboys and the Betting community on this occasion.

I'd say the fact Henry & Thurston weren't fined would suggest this is the compensation they are receiving?!

 

[happy_tiger]

Some Shark players would of known , even just watching the game I'm counting the tackle count both in attack and defence

People who think that players hear the ref yell out 5th tackle and they go " What 5th tackle , that went so fast " :laughing: tell em their dreaming

As a play maker you are setting to something and saying things like 3 plays til we bomb , or running a play I would say at the least the 6,7 and 9 would of known and Carney is just BS ing us

They normally dont count the tackles as a set of six, but they definitely count the set down to which ever play the are working towards. From time to time, this might not be counting to 5, as they might have a 4th tackle option, but I think its safe to say every 7 or 6 in the comp would've known something wasnt right. Most Fullbacks would've know also, but on this occasion, the Sharks had plenty of bodies in motion, so Bowen should be forgiven.

The idea of replaying or stripping victory is simply not gona happen… Either way, I still think the NRL have a duty of care to ensure a correct result where possible. The fact they would've know before halftime, I think they have failed the Cowboys and the Betting community on this occasion.

I'd say the fact Henry & Thurston weren't fined would suggest this is the compensation they are receiving?!

Probably the only reason fullbacks would know is cause halves can't count

Too busy pruning themselves for the cheerleaders

 

[Cultured_Bogan]

It's an unfortunate scenario, but I think the NRL has taken the only action they really could by suspending the match referees and officials and having them call the tackle going forward.

Cowboys fans have a right to feel a bit let down, but the reality is they were still in front later on and lost the game. The spray Thurston and Henry gave the NRL while at the time might have been emotionally driven, was excessive and the Sydney conspiracy claims were an outright joke.

I'd imagine the best scenario for the NRL is to have a NSW team vs QLD team in the grand final every year to generate as much interest as possible as it essentially becomes a de-facto origin game and maximises the audiences in both states. Especially when a team like Cronulla possibly look like they are in a world of trouble regarding the ASADA investigation, the NRL would be praying that they would bow out early on in the piece.

 

[innsaneink]

I wonder how many extra, incorrect sets of six tackles (not just one extra tackle) have been awarded to teams that lead to tries, over the years through stripping penalties that were really just lost possesions/loose carries?

 

[happy_tiger]

I wonder how many extra, incorrect sets of six tackles (not just one extra tackle) have been awarded to teams that lead to tries, over the years through stripping penalties that were really just lost possesions/loose carries?

Andew Moore on the Game Plan said he was talking to someone and it happens a lot more times than the NRL would care to admit

I suppose when you have zero tackle it can become confusing when things happen as quick as it does