Doueihi does ACL again

Scans have confirmed high-grade partial ACL tear.

Club says, "Further medical investigations are required to determine the full extent of the injury and prognosis" but to my knowledge partial tears can require similar recovery periods to full tears.

Naden out for 2-4 weeks.
 
Can he play through it? Performance would be similar to previous weeks where he didn’t get to play his preferred 5/8 position
 
Harvey said:
Can he play through it? Performance would be similar to previous weeks where he didn’t get to play his preferred 5/8 position
Click to expand...
Not something you play through.
(EDIT: assume you're joking on second reading lol).

Just reading this:
"Best case for partial ACL tear is that damage is minimal and knee is functionally stable. This can sometimes mean a 2-3 month return. However, if knee cannot regain stability, reconstructive surgery is required, 6-9 month recovery."
 
I think best case scenario could be a 6 week return but probably highly unlikely given previous reco. Wishing him and Naden luck in their rehab.
 
KingRobbie said:
Scans have confirmed high-grade partial ACL tear.

Club says, "Further medical investigations are required to determine the full extent of the injury and prognosis" but to my knowledge partial tears can require similar recovery periods to full tears.

Naden out for 2-4 weeks.
Click to expand...
Thanks for the update mate
 
Buttface said:
I heard he played well on the weekend, won the game at the end.
Click to expand...
I’ll watch the game at work tonight, from the games I’ve seen him play he’s not bad but he’s not really an upgrade on brooks. Only my opinion though so could be wrong
 
carltonleach said:
I’ll watch the game at work tonight, from the games I’ve seen him play he’s not bad but he’s not really an upgrade on brooks. Only my opinion though so could be wrong
Click to expand...
Roughly my opinion to, until this year where LB has confirmed he is the worst and totally incapable of being an nrl half so Sexton must be better and how good would it be to have sex staines in the same team.
If you watch it let me know your opinion of Sextons game.
 
carltonleach said:
I’ll watch the game at work tonight, from the games I’ve seen him play he’s not bad but he’s not really an upgrade on brooks. Only my opinion though so could be wrong
Click to expand...
I watched the whole game Sexton basically single handedly pulled off the victory in the last few minutes
 
crazycat said:
I am sorry AD is gone. 3x ACL injuries and not good enough form.

We cannot renew his contract and he should only be given min 150k to see if he can play again.
Click to expand...

He already has a contract for next year. I think he just has to think if he wants to try and come back. So he'll get next year to prove himself if he chooses too.
 
carltonleach said:
Yeh completely agree trindall has shown he can control a good side, would be a big difference coming to us but I think he would do well. I could be wrong though but worth a shot I recon. I know he just re-signed but contracts don’t mean a great deal anymore
Click to expand...
Yeah surely a few more dollars and the chance to play regular first grade is attractive to him. I’m surprised they pick Moylan over him to be honest
 
Luke Heartbreaker Brooks said:
He already has a contract for next year. I think he just has to think if he wants to try and come back. So he'll get next year to prove himself if he chooses too.
Click to expand...
re AD and ACL.

No he is done.

3 ACL's. Look AD has had good attitude and done alright for us. Our mistake was picking a generalists when we needed specialists and someone like Alex Johnson would have gone better.

AD can prove himself ofcourse, he can't undo the 3x ACL's and him returning to the field means 4x ACL's. He is done, Min 150k offers only.
 
KingRobbie said:
Scans have confirmed high-grade partial ACL tear.

Club says, "Further medical investigations are required to determine the full extent of the injury and prognosis" but to my knowledge partial tears can require similar recovery periods to full tears.

Naden out for 2-4 weeks.
Click to expand...
Would depend on the % of ACL torn
 
crazycat said:
re AD and ACL.

No he is done.

3 ACL's. Look AD has had good attitude and done alright for us. Our mistake was picking a generalists when we needed specialists and someone like Alex Johnson would have gone better.

AD can prove himself ofcourse, he can't undo the 3x ACL's and him returning to the field means 4x ACL's. He is done, Min 150k offers only.
Click to expand...

I don't want to say he is done and he has a year to prove himself but I don't like his odds.
 
KingRobbie said:
Scans have confirmed high-grade partial ACL tear.

Club says, "Further medical investigations are required to determine the full extent of the injury and prognosis" but to my knowledge partial tears can require similar recovery periods to full tears.

Naden out for 2-4 weeks.
Click to expand...
Feel most devastated for Naden, he has had a good start to the season.

Jesus you poor tigers bastards 😳
 
Harvey said:
Can he play through it? Performance would be similar to previous weeks where he didn’t get to play his preferred 5/8 position
Click to expand...
ACL tear is months no matter the severity of the tear
Minimum 5-6 months worst possible outcome
Brad Parker had a partial tear last year and didn’t have surgery. He returned in 3 months.
Injured round 8, returned round 19.
 
Luke Heartbreaker Brooks said:
He already has a contract for next year. I think he just has to think if he wants to try and come back. So he'll get next year to prove himself if he chooses too.
Click to expand...
First off I hope Doueihi recovers ok and the rehab works - however long that takes, but immaterial of things I wouldn't rush him back into NRL comp when fit, let him ease himself back in and get some confidence again in the State Cup.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Members online

Total: 360 (members: 30, guests: 330)
Forever online: Tigergran, Geo
Back
Top