GAME: Unpopular opinions

Demps

Demps

Moderator
Staff member
Forum Leader
- Post an unpopular opinion
- Others post up if they agree or disagree
- Post your own opinion on something

I'll start;

Dugan is not a good player, average at best.
Injury prone and doesn't deserve the wraps he gets or a NSW jumper
 
The side that has a try scored against it has to kick to the opposition and therefore has to immediately face another six tackles.
 
7 tackle sets - hate it. I think it should be changed to only if kicked dead from behind the 50m line
 
Unpopular opinion: Jason Taylor is not a complete moron

I disagree re: Dugan. He's a player with limited skills but he's a very good ball runner and a good defender at fullback. Definitely above average in my view.

I also disagree re: retaining possession after being held up in goal, I think that's a fair enough rule.
 
:nerd:

@marzie said:
7 tackle sets - hate it. I think it should be changed to only if kicked dead from behind the 50m line
Click to expand...

Agreed brilliant…. Was only brought in because of negative wingaholic Bennett...
Tries from a kick worth only 3 points
 
Dugan over rated. Agree.

Jason Taylor. Agree. Not a moron.

Daley/Fulton and co pick pathetic nsw sides on reputation and boys club constantly, which makes the 'champion' Qld side look better than they are.
 
I don't get the hate for Jamie Soward. Quite an able player and would offer plenty to most clubs with his boot alone.
 
If you catch the ball on the full (barring kick offs and failed penalty attempts ), you automatically go to the point from where the kick was taken

The minute you reach 5 penalties the captain gets sin binned for 5 minutes , 10 penalties captain goes for 10 minutes , 15 penalties for 15 minutes etc

Tries scored from inside own half 5 points

Tries from bombs 3 points

Bonus point for 6 tries scored

Free transfer period during SOO season , maximum of three players , only top tier players for top tier players and then have a no play v former side edict
 
@Cultured Bogan said:
I don't get the hate for Jamie Soward. Quite an able player and would offer plenty to most clubs with his boot alone.
Click to expand...

It's his head. It's extremely punchable.
 
@happy tiger said:
If you catch the ball on the full (barring kick offs and failed penalty attempts ), you automatically go to the point from where the kick was taken

The minute you reach 5 penalties the captain gets sin binned for 5 minutes , 10 penalties captain goes for 10 minutes , 15 penalties for 15 minutes etc

Tries scored from inside own half 5 points

Tries from bombs 3 points

Bonus point for 6 tries scored

Free transfer period during SOO season , maximum of three players , only top tier players for top tier players and then have a no play v former side edict
Click to expand...

Disagree with point 1.
The game would turn into a primary school game of Force Em' backs
Disagree with point 2.
We would be a player ( captain ) short every game !
The rest have some merit .
 
@Nelson said:
@Cultured Bogan said:
I don't get the hate for Jamie Soward. Quite an able player and would offer plenty to most clubs with his boot alone.

It's his head. It's extremely punchable.
Click to expand...
Click to expand...

Agree , I've met Soward a couple of times , he's quiet a good bloke tbh ..
But there's a massive urge to put one on him :laughing:
 
@happy tiger said:
The minute you reach 5 penalties the captain gets sin binned for 5 minutes , 10 penalties captain goes for 10 minutes , 15 penalties for 15 minutes etc
Click to expand...

Kyle Lovett ©
 
have a maximum of only one or two defenders tackling a player at the one time, so gives a chance for the player to run on and would also prevent some injuries as less chance of being held than a diving tackler coming in. In tonight Broncos/St G game a third or fourth bronco came and pushed the tacklers over causing the St G runner possible neck injury and had to stop playing. Give the runners a break without being injured.
 
@Demps said:
- Post an unpopular opinion
- Others post up if they agree or disagree
- Post your own opinion on something

I'll start;

Dugan is not a good player, average at best.
Injury prone and doesn't deserve the wraps he gets or a NSW jumper
Click to expand...

I think Dugan read your post before the game tonight Demps…can you please call Teddy crap before Sunday's game as well?
 
@Nelson said:
Unpopular opinion: Jason Taylor is not a complete moron

I disagree re: Dugan. He's a player with limited skills but he's a very good ball runner and a good defender at fullback. Definitely above average in my view.

I also disagree re: retaining possession after being held up in goal, I think that's a fair enough rule.
Click to expand...

I agree that JT is not a complete Moron. I think that he's still got at least 2% to go.
LOL
 
@marzie said:
7 tackle sets - hate it. I think it should be changed to only if kicked dead from behind the 50m line
Click to expand...

Disagree. It forces the attacking team to be more selective. When was the last kick that went dead from beyond halfway. That would be something you'd see 2 or 3 times a yr, if that.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Members online

Total: 1,587 (members: 24, guests: 1,563)
Back
Top