HBG, Independent Directors Sacked

[liltiger]

Richo wasn't sacked, he resigned, so I would be really surprised to see him return.

HBG knew full well Richo wouldn't stay under a HBG run board. Richo said so him self sitting next to Julie Romero. If he felt HBG wernt going to follow through on the reviews finding of implementing the independant board members, he specifically stated he wouldn't have stuck around. HBG knew full well when they got rid of the board members Richo was gone as well. They knew exactly what they were doing and it was 100% intentional.

 

[BZN]

Yes. It was an ultimatum. Fix your governance or we'll fix it for you.

All this backflipping has been under the threat of force.

So, who is your source that told you that, and I'd like to know what context it was said in.
From what I have seen and heard the feeling wasn't nearly as bad as you are making out.

 

[BZN]

He did it because he wanted a single reserve grade side and they refused, so he stacked one of the sides. The "other side" would always have been justified to complain.

But Sheens was vindicated, we won the comp.

With 2 teams to choose players from, so he should have won the comp.
Do you think it was a good move on Sheens part to make the MAGPIES look like fools.
Then after that I can't imagine the Magpie board members agreeing for him to come back.

 

[cochise]

With 2 teams to choose players from, so he should have won the comp.
Do you think it was a good move on Sheens part to make the MAGPIES look like fools.
Then after that I can't imagine the Magpie board members agreeing for him to come back.

He decided it was better for team cohesion if all the reserve players were playing in the same team.

 

[BZN]

How can you say that he will be controlled by HBG, a puppet not allowed to use his individuality vision.

HUH??? Are you talkin to me, cause if you are I don't have a clue what you are talking about.

 

[Winston Churchill]

This still going on? Last weeks news.

 

[Dr_Ice]

Fallah is a very unserious individual on social media. All he does is post memes. Very out of character to see him fire up like that.

The old “not his go” defence

 

[BZN]

I noticed that.

Have become quite addicted to this discussion so I've read most of the pages on this topic and I've noticed it's dominated by that WestsTigers guy.

Also noticed abuse at not only alternative views but nuanced ones.

Don't let the d/h's on here intimidate you LT.
For a newby that's only been here such a short time, you're doing well.

 

[GNR4LIFE]

The old “not his go” defence

Facts are facts, I’ve rarely ever seen him post anything that wasn’t taking the piss, let alone something like that, I knew he was a staunch Magpie. But you can be a staunch Magpie while also being behind the JV.

 

[innsaneink]

I dont think hes behind the JV going by his post yestrday

 

[BZN]

Good points but what it all concludes for me is this debenture system has to some degree a 3rd Reich smell to it.

Sorry if this offends anyone.

We're really into a heavy dose of theatrics with this post, mentioning the 3rd Reich.
Strange that you apologise for offending anyone.
You obviously put it in here because you knew it would be offensive.
But no, you didn't offend me as I am becoming used to seeing this style of post from you.

 

[BZN]

You're only new & I don't know what you're angle is etc. Take everything on face value.

weststigers is not a bad poster on here. I've spoken to him & he's a cool guy as far as I'm concerned. There are a few others on here that have started using similar styles in this 'emotive topic'.

Don't blame the posters for the way this place responds. It's been allowed to happen.

"emotive topic" is a shield to use to allow some aggression to be let out. If you can deal with the consistency of 'education' you are given on here, it's generally a good place to be.

Sorry to disagree with a top poster such as yourself, but I happen to think there is more trash than treasure on here.

And I reckon it's a real pity that it has been "allowed to happen".

 

[Vicious]

I dont think hes behind the JV going by his post yestrday

I disagree.
He may have went a bit overboard and got caught up in the emotion of it all,l but he stated he wants what is best for Wests Tigers.

 

[mtd#2]

But you can be a staunch Magpie while also being behind the JV.

I don't think it's possible to be all in on both.
One is always going to hold more of a place in the heart than the other. When push comes to shove, there's going to be a preference of one over the other...
...

 

[innsaneink]

I disagree.
He may have went a bit overboard and got caught up in the emotion of it all,l but he stated he wants what is best for Wests Tigers.

Yep...rightio

 

[batboy]

I dont think hes behind the JV going by his post yestrday

If he was behind the JV - he wouldn’t be on their board…
None of those clowns are for the JV

 

[batboy]

Yep...rightio

He disagrees - there’s a shock.

 

[weststigers]

Sorry to disagree with a top poster such as yourself, but I happen to think there is more trash than treasure on here.

And I reckon it's a real pity that it has been "allowed to happen".

Most people that don't like something usually stop returning. Could that be an option for you?

 

[BZN]

Right. So despite doing really well on and off the field last year, you are only concerned with the make up of the board?

Is it fair to say that prior to last years independent board, the board had been HBG majority for 10 years presiding over the worst period in the clubs history?

Let's for a moment imagine the last 10 years was run under a Balmain majority. Would you be marching to the same tune as now?

I've got no correct answer to a hypothetical.

 

[crazycat]

Yep and confirms the fighting has not stopped

Wish the nrl brought in the administrators

Look other then Batboy and some others.

Do we really still 'fight' about this in forum land?

I really feel Denis and about 8 old men are fighting. .. That's about it.


Sure a few people are bating here. I think most members are really passed this so called Balmain vs Magpies thing.