HBG takeover, Independent Directors Sacked

[liltiger]

Everything is just a storm in a teacup apparently according to ol mate

I have no problem with someone defending an opposite position, but at what point are you just doing it to be right. The facts speak otherwise.

 

[liltiger]

But he hasn't explained anything? He made statements about not being informed... But boards do not work this way.. feel free to educate me where I am wrong... How can they have board meetings and the HBG not know about it when they have 2 members on the board? Why can no one explain this to me?

Also worth noting the class of HBG, the sacked board members found out via media, not via the HBG themselves

I see it one of two ways. The first is the HBG reason is true which I don't believe, but hypothetically they were in the dark while having boardmembers on the Wests Tigers board. The second is they lied and it was purely political and driven by personal agendas by HBG board members. If it's the first then it shows a total lack of professionalism within the HBG boardroom and imo shows they are unfit to either run or help run an N.R.L club. The second which I think is more likely shows that they are willing to destabilise an N.R.L franchise for their own political or personal agendas, which shows they are unfit to run or help run an N.R.L franchise. Either one is an endightment of the HBG and proves they have to go.

 

[Spartan117]

Last time Anthony blue man was asked in an article , he said he wanted to bring back a balmain tigers... still a better option

No balmain either. They're dead also.

We are West Tigers for 25 years.

It's not that hard, just move on and continue building.

 

[Goyougoodthng]

M

Nothing would surprise me …

2030 is a long way away though …. What do they expect to happen in the meantime?

I can imagine they'd hope the West's Tigers tank to make the process more justifiable.

 

[Squater]

Speaking from the Magpies point of view I totally support the anger being shown towards the HBG cronies and their decision to sack the independent board members

What I did find harsh were Forum members saying they wouldn't use a Victa Jersey to wipe their ass with

If the shoe was on the other foot and someone said they wouldn't wipe their ass with a Philips Balmain Jersey chaos would ensue

I can understand that. But I think someone has already used Dennis's hair for that.

 

[Big Red]

💯correct GNR. There has not been one poster cheering this.

Another excellent response BZN, keep that secret safe.

 

[Tom Shines]

I can imagine they'd hope the West's Tigers tank to make the process more justifiable.

Might happen… the crowds and membership will tank if this scenario is on the cards in 2030

 

[Goyougoodthng]

Might happen… the crowds and membership will tank if this scenario is on the cards in 2030

It's a conspiracy theory reach, but if in fact their plan is to bring back the Magpies it definitely won't happen if the club is a successful sporting organisation.

 

[mtd#2]

Might happen… the crowds and membership will tank if this scenario is on the cards in 2030

If Richo walks I'll be looking to get a refund for my 2026 membership and won't go to a single game next year. Don't like my chances but I'll be sure as hell to try every avenue possible.

 

[1908]

So. I have, until this turn of events, been one of the 'dinosaurs' who has long-dreamed of an 'unmerge' and the return of Balmain as a standalone entity. First game at Leichhardt in '83 blah blah blah. What has happened over the last couple of days, as well as making me furious, has made me finally realise that bringing Balmain back isn't going to happen and shouldn't happen. They were 'my club', but they aren't 'the club' (and nor of course are the Magpies) of the vast majority of people who support the Wests Tigers. For them, the Wests Tigers are their club. Which is great. It's been 25 years (minus one) of hurt for everyone involved in the JV. It's time we all move on, both from the old tribes and certainly from this ridiculous governance model that isn't fit to run an under 8s team. Given how angry this has made me, I finally realise the Wests Tigers are now 'my club'. I'm all in - I live in the UK and get up at half 4 to watch every game so this has always been obvious in hindsight. But the point being, if I can move on I figure anyone can. And if you can't leave the past behind - I get that. It's cool. But it doesn't help anyone really. Let's finally put all this old stuff to bed. If you want to watch Balmain or the Magpies, there is plenty of stuff on Youtube to keep you going. But if you want to be on the train, let's just move forward, sort this out, and become the powerhouse we really ought to be.

 

[jrtiger]

So. I have, until this turn of events, been one of the 'dinosaurs' who has long-dreamed of an 'unmerge' and the return of Balmain as a standalone entity. First game at Leichhardt in '83 blah blah blah. What has happened over the last couple of days, as well as making me furious, has made me finally realise that bringing Balmain back isn't going to happen and shouldn't happen. They were 'my club', but they aren't 'the club' (and nor of course are the Magpies) of the vast majority of people who support the Wests Tigers. For them, the Wests Tigers are their club. Which is great. It's been 25 years (minus one) of hurt for everyone involved in the JV. It's time we all move on, both from the old tribes and certainly from this ridiculous governance model that isn't fit to run an under 8s team. Given how angry this has made me, I finally realise the Wests Tigers are now 'my club'. I'm all in - I live in the UK and get up at half 4 to watch every game so this has always been obvious in hindsight. But the point being, if I can move on I figure anyone can. And if you can't leave the past behind - I get that. It's cool. But it doesn't help anyone really. Let's finally put all this old stuff to bed. If you want to watch Balmain or the Magpies, there is plenty of stuff on Youtube to keep you going. But if you want to be on the train, let's just move forward, sort this out, and become the powerhouse we really ought to be.

send this to the NRL mate. this is what it’s all about.

 

[clontarfkid]

It makes you think what they thought the reaction was going to be ?

Not sure they think that far ahead tbh..
If PVL gets involved as is inevitable for the benefit of the game,it will be a game changer...if he doesnt...the clowns will get to run the circus
PVL is way too smart to allow that to happen

 

[tigertragic]

I have just joined because I believe that this is I have been a tiger supporter all my life I'm now 70
I was a Balmain support but now I'm not a Balmain nor a western suburbs magpie supporter I'm a wests tigers supporter
I would hope that the NRL get involved and sack th HBG for bringing the NRL into disrepute
The HBG are making the NRL look like a 2nd class organisation
I've been a loyal supporter all my life but if this is what is happening the Swans may be my new winter sport to follow and I can't stand AFL

Welcome LWT you have exactly my profile and I support everything you have said.

 

[Tom Shines]

It's a conspiracy theory reach, but if in fact their plan is to bring back the Magpies it definitely won't happen if the club is a successful sporting organisation.

it’s not my theory ..someone else mentioned it … it needs to be ruled out publicly by the NRL in my view .,.then it won’t be an issue , conspiracy theory or not

 

[Odessa]

Yeah, I agree. I’m an old Magpie who couldn’t give two shits about HBG. But there is definitely an element of posters who are using this just to grind an ax at the Magpies and ex Magpies supporters in general. Like claims that there are Magpies supporters celebrating this. Total bullshit. Maybe the fanatics, or a couple dinosaurs calling 2SM. But no one here.

I was a Balmain guy that went to more magpies games in the 80's and 90's then Balmain games went to the first game at Campbelltown a friend purchased a house in woodbine so game day was


Walk down that hill
Go to the Leumeah Hotel
Get half tank
Get out of the Leumeah Hotel alive it was a hell hole in the 80's
Get in the ground
But the lucky dip tickets they use to sell first last try scored
Drink more
Go past the bottleo to pickup a few more to go home with then
To the Maccs or sizzler
Then back up that f..ing Hill


But West are dead so is Balmain

 

[Rock Hopper Steve]

Imagine putting up with the shite in the first year of the merger!!
Coaches, Players and Admin are still dealing with the Fkn Idiots
26 seasons later…

What do you think of this shit show mate, full speed ahead NRL and gaming commission to action please.

 

[BAGNF05]

So. I have, until this turn of events, been one of the 'dinosaurs' who has long-dreamed of an 'unmerge' and the return of Balmain as a standalone entity. First game at Leichhardt in '83 blah blah blah. What has happened over the last couple of days, as well as making me furious, has made me finally realise that bringing Balmain back isn't going to happen and shouldn't happen. They were 'my club', but they aren't 'the club' (and nor of course are the Magpies) of the vast majority of people who support the Wests Tigers. For them, the Wests Tigers are their club. Which is great. It's been 25 years (minus one) of hurt for everyone involved in the JV. It's time we all move on, both from the old tribes and certainly from this ridiculous governance model that isn't fit to run an under 8s team. Given how angry this has made me, I finally realise the Wests Tigers are now 'my club'. I'm all in - I live in the UK and get up at half 4 to watch every game so this has always been obvious in hindsight. But the point being, if I can move on I figure anyone can. And if you can't leave the past behind - I get that. It's cool. But it doesn't help anyone really. Let's finally put all this old stuff to bed. If you want to watch Balmain or the Magpies, there is plenty of stuff on Youtube to keep you going. But if you want to be on the train, let's just move forward, sort this out, and become the powerhouse we really ought to be.

(Mostly) preaching to the converted on here. It’s our dysfunctional ownership board (and realistically the NRL) that need to make us move forward as a club.

 

[Tom Shines]

Not sure they think that far ahead tbh..
If PVL gets involved as is inevitable for the benefit of the game,it will be a game changer...if he doesnt...the clowns will get to run the circus
PVL is way too smart to allow that to happen

Let hope…

This issue has been around a while …thought the NRL could have put it to bed years ago

 

[BAGNF05]

It's a conspiracy theory reach, but if in fact their plan is to bring back the Magpies it definitely won't happen if the club is a successful sporting organisation.

If they couldn’t fix WT over a 30 year period it’s hilarious to think the NRL would hand them a shiny new Magpies licence.

 

[Dabullmeister]

This whole situation has pissed me off so much. I feel the only way that the Wests Tigers can move forward is to cut any ties with Balmain and the Magpies. Both factions of the joint venture have been killing this club for its entire existence. We need a board that is solely Wests Tigers people. All our pathways need to be Wests Tigers. Its generally the only way forward for the club.