JAC

[Jedi_Tiger]

we gave souths time with our delaying and dithering with storm
oh well disappointing but not end of world Tamau is a good signing

He wanted Souths, what if we gave up Talau to get him and then next year he is sulking because he wants to be at Souths and walks out?

True if he ahd sulked for a year then it would have been a bad decision agree cochise

 

[cochise]

we gave souths time with our delaying and dithering with storm
oh well disappointing but not end of world Tamau is a good signing

He wanted Souths, what if we gave up Talau to get him and then next year he is sulking because he wants to be at Souths and walks out?

True if he ahd sulked for a year then it would have been a bad decision agree cochise

I believe we were always second choice.

 

[westy81]

What is the hand gesture he keeps flashing

 

[cochise]

What is the hand gesture he keeps flashing

Gangsta rubbish I believe lol

 

[weststigerman]

Don’t think that comment means anything. Having mates in Redfern doesn’t automatically mean you play for Souths

 

[Moh]

Don’t think that comment means anything. Having mates in Redfern doesn’t automatically mean you play for Souths

Thanks for adding some common sense.

 

[compensate]

Calm the bloody hell down. He said shoutout to my family in Redfern 🤦‍♂️

 

[swag_tiger]

Calm the bloody hell down. He said shoutout to my family in Redfern 🤦‍♂️

Nice to see not everyone is a pessimist.

 

[Curaeus]

On a more hopeful note, the parasites at the DT have said nothing as yet about us missing out on JAC. And we all know how much these hacks hate our club and never miss a chance to put the boot in. Might still happen but nothing on their website yet!

 

[Newtown]

What is the hand gesture he keeps flashing

The hand gesture seems very much like T shape. T for Tigers.

 

[TonyTiger]

Calm the bloody hell down. He said shoutout to my family in Redfern 🤦‍♂️

I’ve played his comments over and over ... sounds like a mention of Cairns then “One Eye in Redfern”

 

[AJ1]

I can foresee another 5 pages interpreting his post match interview.

 

[WT2K]

I can foresee another 5 pages interpreting his post match interview.

Wait until the body language experts have their say

 

[Tiger_Steve]

I’m sure he looked towards the north when being interviewed. I’d say he’s going to Newcastle. Yep that’s it! Newcastle!!
Wow! His comments meant nothing!!

 

[AJ1]

I can foresee another 5 pages interpreting his post match interview.

Wait until the body language experts have their say

They have already started....on his gangsta signs

 

[gallagher]

I’m sure he looked towards the north when being interviewed. I’d say he’s going to Newcastle. Yep that’s it! Newcastle!!
Wow! His comments meant nothing!!

He made a circular jester with one hand and pointed down with the other.
A hole, down south...
South West Sydney! That's confirmation for me.

 

[JD Tiger]

I’m sure he looked towards the north when being interviewed. I’d say he’s going to Newcastle. Yep that’s it! Newcastle!!
Wow! His comments meant nothing!!

You're right, his comments meant nothing.

Because everything was covered in the **intonation** of his voice. That high pitch rise at the end of red-FERN, meant that he was missing spending time with his family outside of the bubble, and he was planning on spending more time with them soon. And the fact he spoke with a short "r" at the start of R-edfern, indicated that he missed going shooting with his brother Mitchell, and he was looking forward to in four weeks when Origin is over he was going straight there.

 

[hobbo1]

I’m sure he looked towards the north when being interviewed. I’d say he’s going to Newcastle. Yep that’s it! Newcastle!!
Wow! His comments meant nothing!!

He made a circular jester with one hand and pointed down with the other.
A hole, down south...
South West Sydney! That's confirmation for me.

What’s the odds we’ll sign him then he goes to jail for firearm offences ?

 

[gallagher]

I’m sure he looked towards the north when being interviewed. I’d say he’s going to Newcastle. Yep that’s it! Newcastle!!
Wow! His comments meant nothing!!

He made a circular jester with one hand and pointed down with the other.
A hole, down south...
South West Sydney! That's confirmation for me.

What’s the odds we’ll sign him then he goes to jail for firearm offences ?

Honestly, who hasnt shot a gun at a country cousins farm? Cops not nothing else to do?

 

[Tiger5150]

Take this points system dribble elsewhere

It doesn't have to be a points system
A market value would be fare
And this would only need to be used when a player is looking at changing clubs not being re signed at his existing club

Would last five minutes in court if the Players Union (or someone willing to payroll) challenged it. Clear restraint of trade.

Can a $9.4 million cap be thought of as a restraint of trade ?
Because the league has set that figure

POssibly, but hasnt been tested, but that is not what you are talking about, you are talking about setting arbitrary values. What if Teddy wanted to come to the Tigers and we had $300K to offer him and he said yes but NRL said no he is worth $700K and cant come?

What is JAC's value
$600,000 as an untried fullback?

A player has the right to earn as much as possible (we all know and understand that) and that is determined by what a club is willing to pay


and that is the current system, not what you are suggesting.

Therefore the larger amount offered to a player should set a players value (not undervalued)
And that is the value that should be used and applied against the cap

Do you realise what the cap is for? It is not to level the talent, it is to stop clubs going broke. What you are suggesting would encourage the Tigers or Bulldogs to offer a Teddy $3M to force Roosters hands,

Or
Think of it as $1 equals 1 point (like flybuys)
Each club has 9,400,000 points to spend
You can only get so much with your points


Make up your mind. Points? Market value? NRL set value?.