Lui

[tiger_tigers]

many on hear are way too emotionally attached to a few players… Benji got us out of the poo, but benji put us there with his ongoing stupid plays. Kicking on the 3rd, jignjive to crowd our left and right attack, calling for clean ball over backrowers running straight... These are all errors that dont get recorded!!!

FYI - Fitzy wouldve scored that try swooping on the loose ball... but to some, it was benji magic :roll

exactly TW and when somebody says the place needs a player cleanout they are attacked …i think its our forwards who are not tough enough when a pack gives it to them ...then the rest rolls on ...

 

[tiger05]

When Miller is our 1/2 we will look like a real contender Lui is average at best and is a 5/8 another converted postion by the Great man doesn't work coach you have the player use him!

Miller isnt at the level were he can run a first grade side. Lui is far superior.

Please - you can't have watched that game. He was terrible. Miller is young and I have no idea where he is at but he would have been 1000 times better than Lui. Half of the posters on this forum would have been as well.

hahahaha your just a stirrer ….next you will be gunning for sheens to put moltzen back at 7 ...remember he is going to be one of the great fullbacks in the future ...yeah lui had a bad game, they did their homework on his weakness, his defence ....miller will get his chance ... cream always rises to the top .....

No - I admit to stirring when mentioning Moltzen as the long term 1 but there is a valid point there. McKinnon lacks pace and as seen last night the ability to out-jump the opposition when required. Moltzen may have that abilty - he hasn't shown it yet but he may at some point.

As for the thread about Lui - that was pure frustration. I don't think I have seen a worse overall performance at 7\. His defence was as bad as it gets but when added to his inept attack especially the poor passes and dropped ball it was atrocious.

 

[tiger05]

many on hear are way too emotionally attached to a few players… Benji got us out of the poo, but benji put us there with his ongoing stupid plays. Kicking on the 3rd, jignjive to crowd our left and right attack, calling for clean ball over backrowers running straight... These are all errors that dont get recorded!!!

FYI - Fitzy wouldve scored that try swooping on the loose ball... but to some, it was benji magic :roll

Benji saved us and I am a Benji fan but you have a point. Why kick it on the third ? Why pass it in the last minute in our 10 metres.

Still compared to Lui it was chalk and cheese.

 

[tiger05]

I should add I'd keep Lui at 7 because he has been good for us.

 

[innsaneink]

Good on you Willow. Was at the game & watching it again now, Yes i agree that Lui didn't have a good game BUT DAMN let's face it there is definetly something up with our boys in general. I'm so over the whole LUI v's MOLTZEN crap, get over it!!!! They're both in our team & both ONLY 21, give em a break. They BOTH have ALOT to learn & lets leave it at that. Sorry guys for going on but 1 player alone doesn't win or lose a game.(Except for Ennis, Origin 3, 2010, hehehe).

I hear ya!

Groupies with their little fan clubs…cannot see the bigger picture.

 

[innsaneink]

No - I admit to stirring when mentioning Moltzen as the long term 1 but there is a valid point there. McKinnon lacks pace and as seen last night the ability to out-jump the opposition when required. Moltzen may have that abilty - he hasn't shown it yet but he may at some point.

As for the thread about Lui - that was pure frustration. I don't think I have seen a worse overall performance at 7\. His defence was as bad as it gets but when added to his inept attack especially the poor passes and dropped ball it was atrocious.

Yeah…youre just a troll.
Finally you admit it.
Something Ive known all along.
And you have the hide to call me a hypocrite.

 

[tiger4ever]

I agree with you stryker but unlike some ning nongs on here i wont say people have no idea if they dont agree with us.

you have no idea!

Yeah and you know it all dont you professor your a try hard.

Got nothing…... who do you think you are and how the hell your a moderator when you breaking forum rules so if its ok for you f.t boy its now ok for me

CRY ME A RIVER SOOK.

 

[tiger05]

No - I admit to stirring when mentioning Moltzen as the long term 1 but there is a valid point there. McKinnon lacks pace and as seen last night the ability to out-jump the opposition when required. Moltzen may have that abilty - he hasn't shown it yet but he may at some point.

As for the thread about Lui - that was pure frustration. I don't think I have seen a worse overall performance at 7\. His defence was as bad as it gets but when added to his inept attack especially the poor passes and dropped ball it was atrocious.

Yeah…youre just a troll.
Finally you admit it.
Something Ive known all along.
And you have the hide to call me a hypocrite.

No - I didn't admit it. You should go back to school and learn how to read. And yes you are a hypocrite.

 

[innsaneink]

You just posted you admit to stirring…6 posts up

Now youre flat out lying too.

Stirring, posting for a reaction, trolling....all one and the same, tedious boring and a waste of peoples time...should be deleted and banned.

I dunno what mods are doing here, old forum spam and obvious trolling was dealt with hard, made it a much more better forum, saved people having to read garbage 50-% of the time.

 

[happy_tiger]

Well I know one thing someone who can play 7 needs to find form and step up consistantly asap . Whether it is Moltzen or Lui . At their best Lui is the selection I would make . Lui has been bad last 2 weeks but was one of our best against Raiders . The whole team needs to find consistancy in their performances .

 

[Suzie-Q]

The rules have been relaxed a bit Ink, to make the forum a more interesting and friendly place to visit apparently, but I have to agree with you - I much preferred it when obvious trolling was deleted and habitual rule breakers and spammers were banned, or at least put on mod preview.

 

[tiger05]

You just posted you admit to stirring…6 posts up

Now youre flat out lying too.

Stirring, posting for a reaction, trolling....all one and the same, tedious boring and a waste of peoples time...should be deleted and banned.

I dunno what mods are doing here, old forum spam and obvious trolling was dealt with hard, made it a much more better forum, saved people having to read garbage 50-% of the time.

Ink - seriously just MTFU.

Your a little hypocritical girl. When you do its alright but if someone else makes a little joke you go to mummy and beg to the moderators for help.

 

[tiger05]

You just posted you admit to stirring…6 posts up

Now youre flat out lying too.

Stirring, posting for a reaction, trolling....all one and the same, tedious boring and a waste of peoples time...should be deleted and banned.

I dunno what mods are doing here, old forum spam and obvious trolling was dealt with hard, made it a much more better forum, saved people having to read garbage 50-% of the time.

You know the best way to get rid of the forum garbage. You not to post here.

Seriously you post more often than anyone and I'd state 90% is garbage and the other 10% crying.

 

[tiger4ever]

Thats true suz but when that was happening you would get a moderator have a go at you breaking forum rules then when you had a go back it was getting deleted or you got banned and that was annoying also.
\
\
Or they ban you and not have the gumption to tell you why they did it or who banned you.

 

[Tigerdave]

I think everyone needs to take a chill pill and take a step back from this thread

 

[Guest]

This crap has gone on long enough. The nit picking and pot shots at one another ends now or there will be more than one person going on mod preview. Agree to disagree and move on or debate the issue like civil adults. This childish garbage is not what this forum is about.

 

[king_sirro]

This crap has gone on long enough. The nit picking and pot shots at one another ends now or there will be more than one person going on mod preview. Agree to disagree and move on or debate the issue like civil adults. This childish garbage is not what this forum is about.

x2

 

[851]

Lui has had more than a couple of shockers in his 6 odd games this year,it is time to give him a wake up call and drop him for Miller,Lui has had a free ride for too long.

 

[Nix]

Lui has had more than a couple of shockers in his 6 odd games this year,it is time to give him a wake up call and drop him for Miller,Lui has had a free ride for too long.

Ditto.

And more than a few last year also.

 

[Nix]

I couldn't stand Morris at 7 but Lui last night took it to a new level. There was a point where I was saying just don't give him the ball. They did and sure enough he dropped it.

Not so much saying don't give him the ball as an absolute fear of him getting the ball as time and time again he'd stuff it up.

He seems to think he's the next Benji but when it comes down to it he's nowhere near that caliber.