Madge Maguire - Mega Thread

[facepalmer]

I’d like to go back and just keep
Sheens. Haha, I bet you we make the 8 at least twice in the last 11 years

agree

 

[Viking Warrior]

I'm over the club has made me a basket case. I'm desensitized to losing and my passion is waining. Do some thing, CEO and chair wield the axe on Madge or risk losing a lot of supporters.

 

[avocadoontoast]

Our roster is bad but I can see Madge starting to lose his mind. I think he needs help and would bring in the Sheenius as a coaching director. We need players and time with pathways providing talent.

We are a bottom 4 roster but the lack of effort is troubling. We just fold like a deck chair.
I can handle losing but we must fight.

I personally think our roster isn't that bad...Maguire has just lost them

Our roster is worse than any team except the bulldogs. Some promising players but it’s 15/16 teams. Our roster is the problem it’s a bottom 4 team all day. Wayne Bennett or Trent Robinson may get us to 12th.

I don’t think our roster is that bad. Cleary did much better with less.

 

[Viking Warrior]

Our roster is bad but I can see Madge starting to lose his mind. I think he needs help and would bring in the Sheenius as a coaching director. We need players and time with pathways providing talent.

We are a bottom 4 roster but the lack of effort is troubling. We just fold like a deck chair.
I can handle losing but we must fight.

I personally think our roster isn't that bad...Maguire has just lost them

Our roster is worse than any team except the bulldogs. Some promising players but it’s 15/16 teams. Our roster is the problem it’s a bottom 4 team all day. Wayne Bennett or Trent Robinson may get us to 12th.

I don’t think our roster is that bad. Cleary did much better with less.

It's our tactics that are bad

 

[Telltails]

I am a Madge fan he has done a lot more behind the scenes to get the Tigers back on track. Post Cleary he has been the best option.
I would not sack Madge mid season we are cactus. The only coach with the ability, experience and attacking prowess is Shane Flanagan.

I agree with this. I don't think getting rid of him now is the option, but hopefully the club is sounding out a coach for next year.

Sacking the coach for this squad just keeps the perception that nothing changes at the club and good luck getting players to think otherwise. If they can play well one week and then rubbish the next it demonstrates that they are not a squad capable of competing every week.
Our spine bar Brooks has had very little experience - against Turbo DCE and Foran - there was always the chance we would get outclassed just like the Titans did last week.

 

[Joelcainenumber1fan]

Our roster is bad but I can see Madge starting to lose his mind. I think he needs help and would bring in the Sheenius as a coaching director. We need players and time with pathways providing talent.

We are a bottom 4 roster but the lack of effort is troubling. We just fold like a deck chair.
I can handle losing but we must fight.

I personally think our roster isn't that bad...Maguire has just lost them

Our roster is worse than any team except the bulldogs. Some promising players but it’s 15/16 teams. Our roster is the problem it’s a bottom 4 team all day. Wayne Bennett or Trent Robinson may get us to 12th.

I don’t think our roster is that bad. Cleary did much better with less.

much less ??? didnt he have a intire cap to work with ?????
and most those players form didnt drop straight away mbye and packer werent always bad for us

 

[avocadoontoast]

Our roster is bad but I can see Madge starting to lose his mind. I think he needs help and would bring in the Sheenius as a coaching director. We need players and time with pathways providing talent.

We are a bottom 4 roster but the lack of effort is troubling. We just fold like a deck chair.
I can handle losing but we must fight.

I personally think our roster isn't that bad...Maguire has just lost them

Our roster is worse than any team except the bulldogs. Some promising players but it’s 15/16 teams. Our roster is the problem it’s a bottom 4 team all day. Wayne Bennett or Trent Robinson may get us to 12th.

I don’t think our roster is that bad. Cleary did much better with less.


much less ??? didnt he have a intire cap to work with ?????
and most those players form didnt drop straight away mbye and packer werent always bad for us

Maybe so, but on paper that team wasn’t as good as this one. Cleary is a much much much better coach

 

[tony soprano]

Let’s see what chamas has to say tomorrow

 

[Defiant]

No way known you can defend Chee to centre and Mbye to lock.

Liddle and Mikale in reserves.

No faith in the selections and its clear the players wont lift for him.

Look how well Benji is going 🙂

Given we have a doco filming this bebacle unfold would certainly help ratings if we sack the coach 🙂

 

[SeanT]

Our roster is bad but I can see Madge starting to lose his mind. I think he needs help and would bring in the Sheenius as a coaching director. We need players and time with pathways providing talent.

We are a bottom 4 roster but the lack of effort is troubling. We just fold like a deck chair.
I can handle losing but we must fight.

I personally think our roster isn't that bad...Maguire has just lost them

Our roster is worse than any team except the bulldogs. Some promising players but it’s 15/16 teams. Our roster is the problem it’s a bottom 4 team all day. Wayne Bennett or Trent Robinson may get us to 12th.

I don’t think our roster is that bad. Cleary did much better with less.


much less ??? didnt he have a intire cap to work with ?????
and most those players form didnt drop straight away mbye and packer werent always bad for us

Maybe so, but on paper that team wasn’t as good as this one. Cleary is a much much much better coach

Pffft has he won a premiership? He is not a better coach. I think Madge and Cleary are around the same level.

We need a Bellamy,Robinson to get this rabble off the ground.

Pascoe has to go to.

 

[avocadoontoast]

Our roster is bad but I can see Madge starting to lose his mind. I think he needs help and would bring in the Sheenius as a coaching director. We need players and time with pathways providing talent.

We are a bottom 4 roster but the lack of effort is troubling. We just fold like a deck chair.
I can handle losing but we must fight.

I personally think our roster isn't that bad...Maguire has just lost them

Our roster is worse than any team except the bulldogs. Some promising players but it’s 15/16 teams. Our roster is the problem it’s a bottom 4 team all day. Wayne Bennett or Trent Robinson may get us to 12th.

I don’t think our roster is that bad. Cleary did much better with less.


much less ??? didnt he have a intire cap to work with ?????
and most those players form didnt drop straight away mbye and packer werent always bad for us

Maybe so, but on paper that team wasn’t as good as this one. Cleary is a much much much better coach

Pffft has he won a premiership? He is not a better coach. I think Madge and Cleary are around the same level.

We need a Bellamy,Robinson to get this rabble off the ground.

Pascoe has to go to.

I actually don’t care that he’s won a premiership. It’s pretty obvious who’s the better coach.

 

[southerntiger]

Im not a Madge hater.

Our situation is not the fault of a single coach IMO but a series of very poor decisions.

I also don't like saying "sack the coach". I said in 2012 that sacking Sheens would result in us not making the finals for 5 years. I was obviously wrong. I should have doubled it.

However, the decision to play Chee Kam today was extremely puzzling. He has been largely terrible in reggies all year. Has done nothing to deserve a call up. Two weeks ago he had the biggest arm grab for a try I have ever seen.

That is a decision that makes me think Madge just doesn't have it.

 

[DarlingSt]

Ok so who do we get to replace?

Kristian Woolf would be good I think

 

[southerntiger]

No way known you can defend Chee to centre and Mbye to lock.

Liddle and Mikale in reserves.

No faith in the selections and its clear the players wont lift for him.

Look how well Benji is going 🙂

Given we have a doco filming this bebacle unfold would certainly help ratings if we sack the coach 🙂

I am a big Liddle fan but I think playing him in reggies was the right decision. Lids needs time to work on his game. Getting his confidence (and kicking game) back in reggies is the right call.

 

[SeanT]

Ciraldo from Panthers would be the go. He's a defensive coach at the moment. Bloody hell we need that.

Might bring some talent over too.

I don't know about Madge but Im over his post game talks. Same old stuff with nothing changing.

 

[TrueTiger]

I laugh at most of you guys on here with your straight out "sack the coach"garbage because its suits your personal agenda and want to be in finals this year..

Did any of you stop and think that the effort by our young inexperienced players last week may have taken a toll on them,did you stop and think that the Manly side have 80% rep and nrl finals players in their team who also are starting to gel and are becoming a very serious threat up to finals positions,did any of you stop and think that Madge was hampered by previous signings that may not suit his coaching,did most of you stop and think that he recruited young inexperienced players with talent just learning NRL and he recruited experienced players to help them along the way to reach the top level of NRL,did most of you stop and think how much he has put into youth pathways for a better future...Hopefully most of you should stop and think that success doesnt happen overnight,but with hardwork and time this club will be a force in the not to distant future...
Yes Im disappointed, but Im not going to slit my wrists because the season has a long way to go and I will judge this coach and team at the end of THIS SEASON rather than cry sack the coach,,,overall its just a sport and game..Im going to support them even if Im down and out and I keep getting kicked in the guts by the opposition supporters...you know why...IM NOT A QUITTER,if you want to pull your membership and follow another club...go ahead and DONT LET THE DOOR HIT YOU ON THE ARSE ON THE WAY OUT....

 

[avocadoontoast]

I laugh at most of you guys on here with your straight out "sack the coach"garbage because its suits your personal agenda and want to be in finals this year..

Did any of you stop and think that the effort by our young inexperienced players last week may have taken a toll on them,did you stop and think that the Manly side have 80% rep and nrl finals players in their team who also are starting to gel and are becoming a very serious threat up to finals positions,did any of you stop and think that Madge was hampered by previous signings that may not suit his coaching,did most of you stop and think that he recruited young inexperienced players with talent just learning NRL and he recruited experienced players to help them along the way to reach the top level of NRL,did most of you stop and think how much he has put into youth pathways for a better future...Hopefully most of you should stop and think that success doesnt happen overnight,but with hardwork and time this club will be a force in the not to distant future...
Yes Im disappointed, but Im not going to slit my wrists because the season has a long way to go and I will judge this coach and team at the end of THIS SEASON rather than cry sack the coach,,,overall its just a sport and game..Im going to support them even if Im down and out and I keep getting kicked in the guts by the opposition supporters...you know why...IM NOT A QUITTER,if you want to pull your membership and follow another club...go ahead and DONT LET THE DOOR HIT YOU ON THE ARSE ON THE WAY OUT....

It’s his team
We’re 1 from 7
Have let in more points than any other WT team over the first 7 rounds
The season is over
He needs to go now

 

[TrueTiger]

I laugh at most of you guys on here with your straight out "sack the coach"garbage because its suits your personal agenda and want to be in finals this year..

Did any of you stop and think that the effort by our young inexperienced players last week may have taken a toll on them,did you stop and think that the Manly side have 80% rep and nrl finals players in their team who also are starting to gel and are becoming a very serious threat up to finals positions,did any of you stop and think that Madge was hampered by previous signings that may not suit his coaching,did most of you stop and think that he recruited young inexperienced players with talent just learning NRL and he recruited experienced players to help them along the way to reach the top level of NRL,did most of you stop and think how much he has put into youth pathways for a better future...Hopefully most of you should stop and think that success doesnt happen overnight,but with hardwork and time this club will be a force in the not to distant future...
Yes Im disappointed, but Im not going to slit my wrists because the season has a long way to go and I will judge this coach and team at the end of THIS SEASON rather than cry sack the coach,,,overall its just a sport and game..Im going to support them even if Im down and out and I keep getting kicked in the guts by the opposition supporters...you know why...IM NOT A QUITTER,if you want to pull your membership and follow another club...go ahead and DONT LET THE DOOR HIT YOU ON THE ARSE ON THE WAY OUT....

It’s his team
We’re 1 from 7
Have let in more points than any other WT team over the first 7 rounds
The season is over
He needs to go now

Dont tell me and everybody else...man up and tell Pascoe and co...see what reply you get...it will be interesting..
Vent all you like on here,until the club makes the decision to sack him,then he is still the COACH....

 

[DarlingSt]

Our roster is bad but I can see Madge starting to lose his mind. I think he needs help and would bring in the Sheenius as a coaching director. We need players and time with pathways providing talent.

We are a bottom 4 roster but the lack of effort is troubling. We just fold like a deck chair.
I can handle losing but we must fight.

I personally think our roster isn't that bad...Maguire has just lost them

Our roster is worse than any team except the bulldogs. Some promising players but it’s 15/16 teams. Our roster is the problem it’s a bottom 4 team all day. Wayne Bennett or Trent Robinson may get us to 12th.

I don’t think our roster is that bad. Cleary did much better with less.

It's our tactics that are bad

One of the worst game plans or lack thereof in the comp

 

[Goldust]

It’s weird ,after Manly scored their first try I thought,we’re done for.i honestly didn’t even care lol
I’m so used to it.
What ever game plan Madge has in play we seem to only play to it until the other team scores.
I’m so sick of looking foward to watching us play all week,only to watch the most uninspiring footy I’ve ever watched.