Madge Maguire - Mega Thread

[TrueTiger]

To tell the truth ,if Madge gets sacked I can guarantee this club will be in whole world of hurt for the next 3/5 years with no FINALS appearance...
coaches,players ,admin will all give the place a wide bearth...you reckon we cant attract marquee signings,see how we end up after sacking a premiership coach who has tried to cleanup a rabble that it has been for years...

Not sure how you can possibly think he’s done a good job. He’s taken a pretty ordinary team and made them
worse. He’s failed.

In your opinion,but he gave Simpkin his debut when everybody said he is far off NRL,he got Laurie here early,he moved AD to 5/8 and bought in Joe O and Stef to strenghthen the team and you say he failed because the results dont suit you...your hate for the man is overwhelming..yet you dont blame player incompetence at all...

 

[851]

The club has not asked why could we not keep quality? How many quality Penrith juniors leave the club?

Daine Laurie
Matt Burton
Kaide Ellis
Wayde Egan
Waqa Blake
RCG
Tyrone Peachey
Blake Austin
Luke Lewis
Wade Graham
Frank Pritchard
Paul Whatuira

Penrith leak lots of juniors, they have a very large catchment.

Also Marty Taupau isn't a Tigers junior, nor is JAC. Fifita technically also isn't a Tigers junior as he was picked up to join NYC from Griffith.

Penrith are leading the comp and undefeated, big difference, we are unco and defeated

 

[avocadoontoast]

To tell the truth ,if Madge gets sacked I can guarantee this club will be in whole world of hurt for the next 3/5 years with no FINALS appearance...
coaches,players ,admin will all give the place a wide bearth...you reckon we cant attract marquee signings,see how we end up after sacking a premiership coach who has tried to cleanup a rabble that it has been for years...

Not sure how you can possibly think he’s done a good job. He’s taken a pretty ordinary team and made them
worse. He’s failed.

In your opinion,but he gave Simpkin his debut when everybody said he is far off NRL,he got Laurie here early,he moved AD to 5/8 and bought in Joe O and Stef to strenghthen the team and you say he failed because the results dont suit you...your hate for the man is overwhelming..yet you dont blame player incompetence at all...

I don’t hate him at all, but he’s done a terrible job and he deserves to get the sack. We’re 1-6, you may be happy with that but I find it unacceptable.

 

[watersider]

I'm for giving Maguire another year. I don't think there are better coaches, I don't think it would be good for our clubs reputation to sack another coach, I think it will tarnish the development of our younger players if we start to make the direction look fragile and unreliable by breaking it.

We have a bad squad this year. Compare us to any side and we don't look good, not any other team. Madge has a say in our recruitment but he's very much hamstrung by signings of the past.

We're obviously not performing above our capacity, our defense is woeful and the players obviously aren't happy. But they need to develop more grit, and giving them another coach who they know they can push out if they don't like him just makes our club weaker.

Our problem is we don't tackle hard and our line speed in defense is poor. This has been a problem since the last years of Sheens. I would love for a coach to be able to fix this but Madge's defensive effort and tactics have never been a problem at other clubs. At other clubs he was seen to work the players too hard and play too conservatively in attack. But defense wasn't an issue for him. So he's suddenly forgotten how to do this?

Our players are bad, don't let them win! Don't give them an excuse! Stop listening to their opinions! Keep Madge!

 

[TrueTiger]

To tell the truth ,if Madge gets sacked I can guarantee this club will be in whole world of hurt for the next 3/5 years with no FINALS appearance...
coaches,players ,admin will all give the place a wide bearth...you reckon we cant attract marquee signings,see how we end up after sacking a premiership coach who has tried to cleanup a rabble that it has been for years...

Not sure how you can possibly think he’s done a good job. He’s taken a pretty ordinary team and made them
worse. He’s failed.

In your opinion,but he gave Simpkin his debut when everybody said he is far off NRL,he got Laurie here early,he moved AD to 5/8 and bought in Joe O and Stef to strenghthen the team and you say he failed because the results dont suit you...your hate for the man is overwhelming..yet you dont blame player incompetence at all...

I don’t hate him at all, but he’s done a terrible job and he deserves to get the sack. We’re 1-6, you may be happy with that but I find it unacceptable.

find another club like the roosters if it dont suit you here...when the club makes a desicion on Madges future then I will respond to that..not some fan venting because things didnt go his way...

 

[hobbo1]

Someone in the Club planted the story to the SMH about crisis meeting.....something is brewing.. and just as well!

Club still has leaks ....
Looking at you Go Go Gadget !

 

[gallagher]

The club has not asked why could we not keep quality? How many quality Penrith juniors leave the club?

Daine Laurie
Matt Burton
Kaide Ellis
Wayde Egan
Waqa Blake
RCG
Tyrone Peachey
Blake Austin
Luke Lewis
Wade Graham
Frank Pritchard
Paul Whatuira

Penrith leak lots of juniors, they have a very large catchment.

Also Marty Taupau isn't a Tigers junior, nor is JAC. Fifita technically also isn't a Tigers junior as he was picked up to join NYC from Griffith.

Penrith are leading the comp and undefeated, big difference, we are unco and defeated

Lol, someone comparing us to Penrith. Happy clappers

 

[851]

To tell the truth ,if Madge gets sacked I can guarantee this club will be in whole world of hurt for the next 3/5 years with no FINALS appearance...
coaches,players ,admin will all give the place a wide bearth...you reckon we cant attract marquee signings,see how we end up after sacking a premiership coach who has tried to cleanup a rabble that it has been for years...

Not sure how you can possibly think he’s done a good job. He’s taken a pretty ordinary team and made them
worse. He’s failed.

In your opinion,but he gave Simpkin his debut when everybody said he is far off NRL,he got Laurie here early,he moved AD to 5/8 and bought in Joe O and Stef to strenghthen the team and you say he failed because the results dont suit you...your hate for the man is overwhelming..yet you dont blame player incompetence at all...

I don’t hate him at all, but he’s done a terrible job and he deserves to get the sack. We’re 1-6, you may be happy with that but I find it unacceptable.

Exactly, he has made the squad less competitive each year, he has signed or re-signed all but MBye and Packer, he owns this mess, and should be punted

 

[hobbo1]

To tell the truth ,if Madge gets sacked I can guarantee this club will be in whole world of hurt for the next 3/5 years with no FINALS appearance...
coaches,players ,admin will all give the place a wide bearth...you reckon we cant attract marquee signings,see how we end up after sacking a premiership coach who has tried to cleanup a rabble that it has been for years...

Not sure how you can possibly think he’s done a good job. He’s taken a pretty ordinary team and made them
worse. He’s failed.

In your opinion,but he gave Simpkin his debut when everybody said he is far off NRL,he got Laurie here early,he moved AD to 5/8 and bought in Joe O and Stef to strenghthen the team and you say he failed because the results dont suit you...your hate for the man is overwhelming..yet you dont blame player incompetence at all...

I don’t hate him at all, but he’s done a terrible job and he deserves to get the sack. We’re 1-6, you may be happy with that but I find it unacceptable.

find another club like the roosters if it dont suit you here...when the club makes a desicion on Madges future then I will respond to that..not some fan venting because things didnt go his way...

It’s a low call to tell a fan to support another club mate ..
This is a public footy forum for everyone to vent or voice an opinion..

 

[Jedi_Tiger]

Was the sack coach thread this civil in the Potter and JT days?

Were either of those 2 really that bad in comparison?

I think potter and JT were not as bad as this year to be honest with you. We sacked both of them

 

[bigsiro]

Dead man walking

 

[avocadoontoast]

To tell the truth ,if Madge gets sacked I can guarantee this club will be in whole world of hurt for the next 3/5 years with no FINALS appearance...
coaches,players ,admin will all give the place a wide bearth...you reckon we cant attract marquee signings,see how we end up after sacking a premiership coach who has tried to cleanup a rabble that it has been for years...

Not sure how you can possibly think he’s done a good job. He’s taken a pretty ordinary team and made them
worse. He’s failed.

In your opinion,but he gave Simpkin his debut when everybody said he is far off NRL,he got Laurie here early,he moved AD to 5/8 and bought in Joe O and Stef to strenghthen the team and you say he failed because the results dont suit you...your hate for the man is overwhelming..yet you dont blame player incompetence at all...

I don’t hate him at all, but he’s done a terrible job and he deserves to get the sack. We’re 1-6, you may be happy with that but I find it unacceptable.

find another club like the roosters if it dont suit you here...when the club makes a desicion on Madges future then I will respond to that..not some fan venting because things didnt go his way...

It’s clear the writing is on the wall, and he’ll be gone soon. I had high hopes when we signed him but it hasn’t worked out.

 

[dazza65]

To tell the truth ,if Madge gets sacked I can guarantee this club will be in whole world of hurt for the next 3/5 years with no FINALS appearance...
coaches,players ,admin will all give the place a wide bearth...you reckon we cant attract marquee signings,see how we end up after sacking a premiership coach who has tried to cleanup a rabble that it has been for years...

Not sure how you can possibly think he’s done a good job. He’s taken a pretty ordinary team and made them
worse. He’s failed.

In your opinion,but he gave Simpkin his debut when everybody said he is far off NRL,he got Laurie here early,he moved AD to 5/8 and bought in Joe O and Stef to strenghthen the team and you say he failed because the results dont suit you...your hate for the man is overwhelming..yet you dont blame player incompetence at all...

I don’t hate him at all, but he’s done a terrible job and he deserves to get the sack. We’re 1-6, you may be happy with that but I find it unacceptable.

find another club like the roosters if it dont suit you here...when the club makes a desicion on Madges future then I will respond to that..not some fan venting because things didnt go his way...

It’s a low call to tell a fan to support another club mate ..
This is a public footy forum for everyone to vent or voice an opinion..

Especially the rooters.....FGS

 

[gallagher]

Dead man walking

He's gone. We killed another career

 

[cochise]

To tell the truth ,if Madge gets sacked I can guarantee this club will be in whole world of hurt for the next 3/5 years with no FINALS appearance...
coaches,players ,admin will all give the place a wide bearth...you reckon we cant attract marquee signings,see how we end up after sacking a premiership coach who has tried to cleanup a rabble that it has been for years...

Not sure how you can possibly think he’s done a good job. He’s taken a pretty ordinary team and made them
worse. He’s failed.

In your opinion,but he gave Simpkin his debut when everybody said he is far off NRL,he got Laurie here early,he moved AD to 5/8 and bought in Joe O and Stef to strenghthen the team and you say he failed because the results dont suit you...your hate for the man is overwhelming..yet you dont blame player incompetence at all...

I don’t hate him at all, but he’s done a terrible job and he deserves to get the sack. We’re 1-6, you may be happy with that but I find it unacceptable.

find another club like the roosters if it dont suit you here...when the club makes a desicion on Madges future then I will respond to that..not some fan venting because things didnt go his way...

That is poor form mate

 

[momo_amp_medo]

I’ve been a supporter of Madge and still am .... but .... There is definitely something to be said about the mental preparation of this team on game days.
They just fail to and loose focus for periods in the game.
And it’s nothing new and Madge just can’t seem to get on top of this. It is now embedded in our DNA and I’m not sure I can see a short term solution.
Whether it means we need a new coach with a new approach is hard one ..... you would have to be very careful that you “don’t throw the baby out with the water” .....

 

[TrueTiger]

To tell the truth ,if Madge gets sacked I can guarantee this club will be in whole world of hurt for the next 3/5 years with no FINALS appearance...
coaches,players ,admin will all give the place a wide bearth...you reckon we cant attract marquee signings,see how we end up after sacking a premiership coach who has tried to cleanup a rabble that it has been for years...

Not sure how you can possibly think he’s done a good job. He’s taken a pretty ordinary team and made them
worse. He’s failed.

In your opinion,but he gave Simpkin his debut when everybody said he is far off NRL,he got Laurie here early,he moved AD to 5/8 and bought in Joe O and Stef to strenghthen the team and you say he failed because the results dont suit you...your hate for the man is overwhelming..yet you dont blame player incompetence at all...

I don’t hate him at all, but he’s done a terrible job and he deserves to get the sack. We’re 1-6, you may be happy with that but I find it unacceptable.

find another club like the roosters if it dont suit you here...when the club makes a desicion on Madges future then I will respond to that..not some fan venting because things didnt go his way...

It’s a low call to tell a fan to support another club mate ..
This is a public footy forum for everyone to vent or voice an opinion..

but if it worries him that much ....you and others are freely giving advice and opinions why cant I ,,,,I gave him an alternative,,,what are you a phycologist now...giving the painting away ???

 

[bigsiro]

To tell the truth ,if Madge gets sacked I can guarantee this club will be in whole world of hurt for the next 3/5 years with no FINALS appearance...
coaches,players ,admin will all give the place a wide bearth...you reckon we cant attract marquee signings,see how we end up after sacking a premiership coach who has tried to cleanup a rabble that it has been for years...

Not sure how you can possibly think he’s done a good job. He’s taken a pretty ordinary team and made them
worse. He’s failed.

In your opinion,but he gave Simpkin his debut when everybody said he is far off NRL,he got Laurie here early,he moved AD to 5/8 and bought in Joe O and Stef to strenghthen the team and you say he failed because the results dont suit you...your hate for the man is overwhelming..yet you dont blame player incompetence at all...

I don’t hate him at all, but he’s done a terrible job and he deserves to get the sack. We’re 1-6, you may be happy with that but I find it unacceptable.

find another club like the roosters if it dont suit you here...when the club makes a desicion on Madges future then I will respond to that..not some fan venting because things didnt go his way...

Boooo!

 

[Jedi_Tiger]

To tell the truth ,if Madge gets sacked I can guarantee this club will be in whole world of hurt for the next 3/5 years with no FINALS appearance...
coaches,players ,admin will all give the place a wide bearth...you reckon we cant attract marquee signings,see how we end up after sacking a premiership coach who has tried to cleanup a rabble that it has been for years...

Not sure how you can possibly think he’s done a good job. He’s taken a pretty ordinary team and made them
worse. He’s failed.

1-6 I think madge is failling
Not a huge Flanagan fan but probably better option than Madge he has lost the group

 

[TrueTiger]

To tell the truth ,if Madge gets sacked I can guarantee this club will be in whole world of hurt for the next 3/5 years with no FINALS appearance...
coaches,players ,admin will all give the place a wide bearth...you reckon we cant attract marquee signings,see how we end up after sacking a premiership coach who has tried to cleanup a rabble that it has been for years...

Not sure how you can possibly think he’s done a good job. He’s taken a pretty ordinary team and made them
worse. He’s failed.

In your opinion,but he gave Simpkin his debut when everybody said he is far off NRL,he got Laurie here early,he moved AD to 5/8 and bought in Joe O and Stef to strenghthen the team and you say he failed because the results dont suit you...your hate for the man is overwhelming..yet you dont blame player incompetence at all...

I don’t hate him at all, but he’s done a terrible job and he deserves to get the sack. We’re 1-6, you may be happy with that but I find it unacceptable.

find another club like the roosters if it dont suit you here...when the club makes a desicion on Madges future then I will respond to that..not some fan venting because things didnt go his way...

That is poor form mate

why, I can give an opinion ,I merely gave him advice...what makes you judge and jury because your a mod....I didnt degrade him and whats more go through my thousands of posts and see where I was told to go on many occasions..didnt see anyone poking their nose in and crying for me...