Manly Warringah Sea Dogs !

Ban all the worst perpetrators for the rest of the season, I say! The two Stewarts should be the first to go.
 
@Goose said:
The melbourne blokes coming in form the bench is interesting, they didn't throw any, but should not get involved, but it was 4 or 5 manly blokes on Adam Blair, what are they supposed to do

For me this is an issue, the Melbourne officials and Players came onto the playing field from the bench. If any of them touch any players espeicallt the officials there could be problems.

On the Manly players Brett only did some jump grap move nothing in it but he will be out injuried anyway. The 14 is the one who will be in trouble was involved in it in the first occurance and in the second.
 
My only concern is that someone didn't punch the crap out of Jamie Lyons - how come this little schoolgirl is continually allowed to whinge and whine to the refs, put forward his point of view of what they should do, tell them who he thinks they should penalise - and not once is he told to get lost - a few good uppercuts would have done - just enough to damage his voice box for the next 5 weeks.
 
@derailed said:
@Goose said:
The melbourne blokes coming in form the bench is interesting, they didn't throw any, but should not get involved, but it was 4 or 5 manly blokes on Adam Blair, what are they supposed to do

For me this is an issue, the Melbourne officials and Players came onto the playing field from the bench. If any of them touch any players espeicallt the officials there could be problems.

i have to disagree with this.. the melbourne guys that ran in were only pulling players away from the fight.. given they had one of their team mates being almost gang bashed by 5 guys i think it is fair enough.. if they got involved and threw punches etc, i'd agree with you… but from my perspective they were trying to stop it... not entice it further..
 
G. Stewart & Blair will get 4 or 5 weeks, B.Stewart will get a holiday & the 14 from Manly will have a holiday as well, also Ray Hadlee on radio last night said the league were looking at calling in another 6 or 7 players for a chat. This was a showcase game last night 1 v 2 a big crowd a large t.v audience watching & the boss of the league wont be happy, heads will roll.
 
The only blokes that threw punches were blair and g. stewart, 1 on 1, so not too bad, but on the side line after they have been binned is not great.
And Lussick, his was a disgraceful act, whacking Blair while on the ground, the other manly players only came in and pulled them apart, which is fair enough, I d be disapointed if they were my team and they didn't go to help out, none of them threw punches.
Seeing Lussick again this morning it was terrible
 
Side note but Slater did the right thing last night stabilising Williams on the ground. Turns out Wolfman has a broken neck
 
@pacey said:
If you missed it
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5p17GBlzxDk

Haha thanks man. Did you hear someone in the background yell out in excitement before they started punching on? lol you could certainly sense it was gonna happen which is surprising as they usually ignore one another and run off.

Got to admit I was on my feet when Stewart threw that punch.
 
While I don't particularly like slater as IMO he is a grug (great player but grub none the less), I grew a LOT of respect for him last night. Not only did he not move and help to stabilize wolfman, the look of concern on his face was genuine. Was refreshing to see this from an opposition player!!!

Well done Billy!

Edit: fick speelink mestaks, damn spell cheque! Hehe
 
its been confirmed Brett Stewart did his medial as a result of running into the fight. Hope it was worth it you gutless coward.
 
The SeaEagles= Dogs…..5-1 players bashing Adam Blair....what cats! and cowards...that Dog B.Stewart must be suspended...but watch them get 1 week max!
 
@stryker said:
@Golden said:
Does this mean we will cover some of mr 500k suspension next year?

How long are you expecting him to get Golden???

Any more than 2 weeks will be a disgrace.

I agree but Gallop hates the storm and Manly and they could get about 4 to 6 weeks to set an example who knows
 
well they are already saying the last lot of people got 11 weeks between them for the same incident. I reckon they will both get at least 4 weeks each
 
Back
Top