Mbye the worst player to ever play for Wests?

[The_Patriot]

Mbye is far from our worst player. A few seasons ago he was one of our best. He joined to play under Cleary which he went ok. Madge doesn’t know how to use him. As to his contract $$ that’s not on him the club put him on a monster deal just like Packer, Reynolds and Mats. Those 3 would be worse than Mbye by a mile for us regarding signings. Our big name recruits have a history of being diabolical with us because we just don’t play them how they played at the previous club - we have a habit of trying to work round pegs into square hole syndrome.

Seems like Madge doesn't know how to use a lot of players.

**> Corey Thompson, ring a bell?**

Guy doesn't coach to the roster, no person centred approach and tries to bring in players he likes that aren't the necessarily the best.

@The_Patriot knows what's up.

Momirovski, Kane Bradley, Josh Reynolds not players that fit Maguire's square peg approach.

Over and over the recruiting has been based on the style of player he wants rather than recruiting and retaining players with quality work ethics and game day mentality.

What he sees in Mybe does my head in.

 

[TigerWest]

Mbye is far from our worst player. A few seasons ago he was one of our best. He joined to play under Cleary which he went ok. **Madge doesn’t know how to use him**. As to his contract $$ that’s not on him the club put him on a monster deal just like Packer, Reynolds and Mats. Those 3 would be worse than Mbye by a mile for us regarding signings. Our big name recruits have a history of being diabolical with us because we just don’t play them how they played at the previous club - we have a habit of trying to work round pegs into square hole syndrome.

So where should we use him?

 

[Demps]

Mbye is far from our worst player. A few seasons ago he was one of our best. He joined to play under Cleary which he went ok. **Madge doesn’t know how to use him**. As to his contract $$ that’s not on him the club put him on a monster deal just like Packer, Reynolds and Mats. Those 3 would be worse than Mbye by a mile for us regarding signings. Our big name recruits have a history of being diabolical with us because we just don’t play them how they played at the previous club - we have a habit of trying to work round pegs into square hole syndrome.

So where should we use him?

There's like 4 games left...
Hopefully that is some one else's problem soon enough.

He's always been a #6
And he's always been a Bulldog.

Keen to see if he has a dig at his next club as he never did for us.

 

[TigerWest]

Mbye is far from our worst player. A few seasons ago he was one of our best. He joined to play under Cleary which he went ok. Madge doesn’t know how to use him. As to his contract $$ that’s not on him the club put him on a monster deal just like Packer, Reynolds and Mats. Those 3 would be worse than Mbye by a mile for us regarding signings. Our big name recruits have a history of being diabolical with us because we just don’t play them how they played at the previous club - we have a habit of trying to work round pegs into square hole syndrome.

Seems like Madge doesn't know how to use a lot of players.

Corey Thompson, ring a bell?

Guy doesn't coach to the roster, no person centred approach and tries to bring in players he likes that aren't the necessarily the best.

@The_Patriot knows what's up.

Surely Madge is entitled to change the roster to suit the style of game he wants the team to play?
Every other coach does.

 

[TigerWest]

Mbye is far from our worst player. A few seasons ago he was one of our best. He joined to play under Cleary which he went ok. **Madge doesn’t know how to use him**. As to his contract $$ that’s not on him the club put him on a monster deal just like Packer, Reynolds and Mats. Those 3 would be worse than Mbye by a mile for us regarding signings. Our big name recruits have a history of being diabolical with us because we just don’t play them how they played at the previous club - we have a habit of trying to work round pegs into square hole syndrome.

So where should we use him?

There's like 4 games left...
Hopefully that is some one else's problem soon enough.

He's always been a #6
And he's always been a Bulldog.

Keen to see if he has a dig at his next club as he never did for us.

He is probably one of the best 14 in the comp now.

 

[Demps]

Mbye is far from our worst player. A few seasons ago he was one of our best. He joined to play under Cleary which he went ok. Madge doesn’t know how to use him. As to his contract $$ that’s not on him the club put him on a monster deal just like Packer, Reynolds and Mats. Those 3 would be worse than Mbye by a mile for us regarding signings. Our big name recruits have a history of being diabolical with us because we just don’t play them how they played at the previous club - we have a habit of trying to work round pegs into square hole syndrome.

Seems like Madge doesn't know how to use a lot of players.

Corey Thompson, ring a bell?

Guy doesn't coach to the roster, no person centred approach and tries to bring in players he likes that aren't the necessarily the best.

@The_Patriot knows what's up.

Surely Madge is entitled to change the roster to suit the style of game he wants the team to play?
Every other coach does.

Yeah, he is... but what's his style of game?.
It's out of date and no longer works...?

We went into 2021 with BJ and Jet as our centres.
Surely I wasn't the only one underwhelmed by this.

He let Corey go and opted for Talau?
With the exception of Laurie, the backline has no strike.

 

[craigtob]

I think any player that gets the chance to play in the NRL must be pretty good in my eyes.How tough must they be physically and mentally,some are just better than others like it or not.My hat goes off to them all.

 

[Demps]

Mbye is far from our worst player. A few seasons ago he was one of our best. He joined to play under Cleary which he went ok. **Madge doesn’t know how to use him**. As to his contract $$ that’s not on him the club put him on a monster deal just like Packer, Reynolds and Mats. Those 3 would be worse than Mbye by a mile for us regarding signings. Our big name recruits have a history of being diabolical with us because we just don’t play them how they played at the previous club - we have a habit of trying to work round pegs into square hole syndrome.

So where should we use him?

There's like 4 games left...
Hopefully that is some one else's problem soon enough.

He's always been a #6
And he's always been a Bulldog.

Keen to see if he has a dig at his next club as he never did for us.

He is probably one of the best 14 in the comp now.

I don't think so.

800k for a 14.
Bad business.

 

[hobbo1]

Mbye / Anasta/ Ballin ..same

 

[Depressed]

I think Mbye has had plenty of good games.

Would he be coping this flak if he was on half the coin ? Who do we bring in ?

 

[TigerWest]

Mbye is far from our worst player. A few seasons ago he was one of our best. He joined to play under Cleary which he went ok. **Madge doesn’t know how to use him**. As to his contract $$ that’s not on him the club put him on a monster deal just like Packer, Reynolds and Mats. Those 3 would be worse than Mbye by a mile for us regarding signings. Our big name recruits have a history of being diabolical with us because we just don’t play them how they played at the previous club - we have a habit of trying to work round pegs into square hole syndrome.

So where should we use him?

There's like 4 games left...
Hopefully that is some one else's problem soon enough.

He's always been a #6
And he's always been a Bulldog.

Keen to see if he has a dig at his next club as he never did for us.

He is probably one of the best 14 in the comp now.

I don't think so.

800k for a 14.
Bad business.

I agree re: the $’s, but he covers more positions than most.

 

[Demps]

Mbye is far from our worst player. A few seasons ago he was one of our best. He joined to play under Cleary which he went ok. **Madge doesn’t know how to use him**. As to his contract $$ that’s not on him the club put him on a monster deal just like Packer, Reynolds and Mats. Those 3 would be worse than Mbye by a mile for us regarding signings. Our big name recruits have a history of being diabolical with us because we just don’t play them how they played at the previous club - we have a habit of trying to work round pegs into square hole syndrome.

So where should we use him?

There's like 4 games left...
Hopefully that is some one else's problem soon enough.

He's always been a #6
And he's always been a Bulldog.

Keen to see if he has a dig at his next club as he never did for us.

He is probably one of the best 14 in the comp now.

I don't think so.

800k for a 14.
Bad business.

I agree re: the $’s, but he covers more positions than most.

Mbye is far from our worst player. A few seasons ago he was one of our best. He joined to play under Cleary which he went ok. **Madge doesn’t know how to use him**. As to his contract $$ that’s not on him the club put him on a monster deal just like Packer, Reynolds and Mats. Those 3 would be worse than Mbye by a mile for us regarding signings. Our big name recruits have a history of being diabolical with us because we just don’t play them how they played at the previous club - we have a habit of trying to work round pegs into square hole syndrome.

So where should we use him?

There's like 4 games left...
Hopefully that is some one else's problem soon enough.

He's always been a #6
And he's always been a Bulldog.

Keen to see if he has a dig at his next club as he never did for us.

He is probably one of the best 14 in the comp now.

I don't think so.

800k for a 14.
Bad business.

I agree re: the $’s, but he covers more positions than most.

Isn't great at any.

I would claim Peachy is a better 14
Or Nicholas Hynes.

Players who actually turn up.

 

[TigerWest]

Mbye is far from our worst player. A few seasons ago he was one of our best. He joined to play under Cleary which he went ok. **Madge doesn’t know how to use him**. As to his contract $$ that’s not on him the club put him on a monster deal just like Packer, Reynolds and Mats. Those 3 would be worse than Mbye by a mile for us regarding signings. Our big name recruits have a history of being diabolical with us because we just don’t play them how they played at the previous club - we have a habit of trying to work round pegs into square hole syndrome.

So where should we use him?

There's like 4 games left...
Hopefully that is some one else's problem soon enough.

He's always been a #6
And he's always been a Bulldog.

Keen to see if he has a dig at his next club as he never did for us.

He is probably one of the best 14 in the comp now.

I don't think so.

800k for a 14.
Bad business.

I agree re: the $’s, but he covers more positions than most.

Mbye is far from our worst player. A few seasons ago he was one of our best. He joined to play under Cleary which he went ok. **Madge doesn’t know how to use him**. As to his contract $$ that’s not on him the club put him on a monster deal just like Packer, Reynolds and Mats. Those 3 would be worse than Mbye by a mile for us regarding signings. Our big name recruits have a history of being diabolical with us because we just don’t play them how they played at the previous club - we have a habit of trying to work round pegs into square hole syndrome.

So where should we use him?

There's like 4 games left...
Hopefully that is some one else's problem soon enough.

He's always been a #6
And he's always been a Bulldog.

Keen to see if he has a dig at his next club as he never did for us.

He is probably one of the best 14 in the comp now.

I don't think so.

800k for a 14.
Bad business.

I agree re: the $’s, but he covers more positions than most.

Isn't great at any.

I would claim Peachy is a better 14
Or Nicholas Hynes.

Players who actually turn up.

It’s all arguable, but I never stated he was the best.

 

[Demps]

Mbye is far from our worst player. A few seasons ago he was one of our best. He joined to play under Cleary which he went ok. **Madge doesn’t know how to use him**. As to his contract $$ that’s not on him the club put him on a monster deal just like Packer, Reynolds and Mats. Those 3 would be worse than Mbye by a mile for us regarding signings. Our big name recruits have a history of being diabolical with us because we just don’t play them how they played at the previous club - we have a habit of trying to work round pegs into square hole syndrome.

So where should we use him?

There's like 4 games left...
Hopefully that is some one else's problem soon enough.

He's always been a #6
And he's always been a Bulldog.

Keen to see if he has a dig at his next club as he never did for us.

He is probably one of the best 14 in the comp now.

I don't think so.

800k for a 14.
Bad business.

I agree re: the $’s, but he covers more positions than most.

Mbye is far from our worst player. A few seasons ago he was one of our best. He joined to play under Cleary which he went ok. **Madge doesn’t know how to use him**. As to his contract $$ that’s not on him the club put him on a monster deal just like Packer, Reynolds and Mats. Those 3 would be worse than Mbye by a mile for us regarding signings. Our big name recruits have a history of being diabolical with us because we just don’t play them how they played at the previous club - we have a habit of trying to work round pegs into square hole syndrome.

So where should we use him?

There's like 4 games left...
Hopefully that is some one else's problem soon enough.

He's always been a #6
And he's always been a Bulldog.

Keen to see if he has a dig at his next club as he never did for us.

He is probably one of the best 14 in the comp now.

I don't think so.

800k for a 14.
Bad business.

I agree re: the $’s, but he covers more positions than most.

Isn't great at any.

I would claim Peachy is a better 14
Or Nicholas Hynes.

Players who actually turn up.

It’s all arguable, but I never stated he was the best.

You legit said...

"He is probably one of the best 14 in the comp now."

?

 

[TigerWest]

Mbye is far from our worst player. A few seasons ago he was one of our best. He joined to play under Cleary which he went ok. **Madge doesn’t know how to use him**. As to his contract $$ that’s not on him the club put him on a monster deal just like Packer, Reynolds and Mats. Those 3 would be worse than Mbye by a mile for us regarding signings. Our big name recruits have a history of being diabolical with us because we just don’t play them how they played at the previous club - we have a habit of trying to work round pegs into square hole syndrome.

So where should we use him?

There's like 4 games left...
Hopefully that is some one else's problem soon enough.

He's always been a #6
And he's always been a Bulldog.

Keen to see if he has a dig at his next club as he never did for us.

He is probably one of the best 14 in the comp now.

I don't think so.

800k for a 14.
Bad business.

I agree re: the $’s, but he covers more positions than most.

Mbye is far from our worst player. A few seasons ago he was one of our best. He joined to play under Cleary which he went ok. **Madge doesn’t know how to use him**. As to his contract $$ that’s not on him the club put him on a monster deal just like Packer, Reynolds and Mats. Those 3 would be worse than Mbye by a mile for us regarding signings. Our big name recruits have a history of being diabolical with us because we just don’t play them how they played at the previous club - we have a habit of trying to work round pegs into square hole syndrome.

So where should we use him?

There's like 4 games left...
Hopefully that is some one else's problem soon enough.

He's always been a #6
And he's always been a Bulldog.

Keen to see if he has a dig at his next club as he never did for us.

He is probably one of the best 14 in the comp now.

I don't think so.

800k for a 14.
Bad business.

I agree re: the $’s, but he covers more positions than most.

Isn't great at any.

I would claim Peachy is a better 14
Or Nicholas Hynes.

Players who actually turn up.

It’s all arguable, but I never stated he was the best.

You legit said...

"He is probably one of the best 14 in the comp now."

?

Correct and imo, he is.

There wouldn’t be many who can cover the whole backline and the 9?

 

[Demps]

Mbye is far from our worst player. A few seasons ago he was one of our best. He joined to play under Cleary which he went ok. **Madge doesn’t know how to use him**. As to his contract $$ that’s not on him the club put him on a monster deal just like Packer, Reynolds and Mats. Those 3 would be worse than Mbye by a mile for us regarding signings. Our big name recruits have a history of being diabolical with us because we just don’t play them how they played at the previous club - we have a habit of trying to work round pegs into square hole syndrome.

So where should we use him?

There's like 4 games left...
Hopefully that is some one else's problem soon enough.

He's always been a #6
And he's always been a Bulldog.

Keen to see if he has a dig at his next club as he never did for us.

He is probably one of the best 14 in the comp now.

I don't think so.

800k for a 14.
Bad business.

I agree re: the $’s, but he covers more positions than most.

Mbye is far from our worst player. A few seasons ago he was one of our best. He joined to play under Cleary which he went ok. **Madge doesn’t know how to use him**. As to his contract $$ that’s not on him the club put him on a monster deal just like Packer, Reynolds and Mats. Those 3 would be worse than Mbye by a mile for us regarding signings. Our big name recruits have a history of being diabolical with us because we just don’t play them how they played at the previous club - we have a habit of trying to work round pegs into square hole syndrome.

So where should we use him?

There's like 4 games left...
Hopefully that is some one else's problem soon enough.

He's always been a #6
And he's always been a Bulldog.

Keen to see if he has a dig at his next club as he never did for us.

He is probably one of the best 14 in the comp now.

I don't think so.

800k for a 14.
Bad business.

I agree re: the $’s, but he covers more positions than most.

Isn't great at any.

I would claim Peachy is a better 14
Or Nicholas Hynes.

Players who actually turn up.

It’s all arguable, but I never stated he was the best.

You legit said...

"He is probably one of the best 14 in the comp now."

?

Correct and imo, he is.

There wouldn’t be many who can cover the whole backline and the 9?

Nicho Hynes and Peachy had.

But yeah, he's among a select few that offer such versatility. He just isn't that good at any... at least, for us.

 

[batboy]

Mbye is far from our worst player. A few seasons ago he was one of our best. He joined to play under Cleary which he went ok. **Madge doesn’t know how to use him**. As to his contract $$ that’s not on him the club put him on a monster deal just like Packer, Reynolds and Mats. Those 3 would be worse than Mbye by a mile for us regarding signings. Our big name recruits have a history of being diabolical with us because we just don’t play them how they played at the previous club - we have a habit of trying to work round pegs into square hole syndrome.

So where should we use him?

There's like 4 games left...
Hopefully that is some one else's problem soon enough.

He's always been a #6
And he's always been a Bulldog.

Keen to see if he has a dig at his next club as he never did for us.

Pretty sure he played 9 in a GF...
Listening to the Bulldogs banter at the time we signed him, And it was clear then was the only Place Mbye works hard at is the Lips.
He's always talked the talk, Seems a nice enough guys - And probably a reasonably clever football brain...
But he's Lazy, Overpaid, And Does.Not.Give.A.Rats...

More than once I've seen on his socials him having fish and chips for lunch with his family at the beach (No Beaches around the inner west) when we're playing later in the day....
I don't begrudge a guy Lunch, Or his Family.... But surely that's not game day activity for a professional footballer / Club captain.

He's a magician the deals he's talked his way into...
We'll lose absolutely nothing from our team if we pay his full freight next year...

On the other side of the coin - How good is Corey Norman going when he's getting replaced with Moses Mbye?? And a side note to that - I don't watch the Dragons but i remember Corey Norman "Winning them Games" in his time there - I've barely seen Moses Mbye break out of a jog for us.... And maybe once scored a try that put a game beyond reach.

Bulldogs paid him to play against them.
We'll pay him to play against us
so will the next, so on and so forth....
He's Garbage.

 

[Cultured_Bogan]

We've had a lot of garbage players over the years, but in terms of value signings, Mbye would be up there with Packer and Blair as the worst value for money signings. I suppose I would classify Packer worse than Mbye and Blair because at least both Blair and Mbye were fit to make the field pretty much every week. Packer has been an abject failure aside from levelling Matterson and is just waiting it out on big dollars so he can go on and put his uni education to use.

 

[Deleted member 3518]

Mbye is far from our worst player. A few seasons ago he was one of our best. He joined to play under Cleary which he went ok. **Madge doesn’t know how to use him**. As to his contract $$ that’s not on him the club put him on a monster deal just like Packer, Reynolds and Mats. Those 3 would be worse than Mbye by a mile for us regarding signings. Our big name recruits have a history of being diabolical with us because we just don’t play them how they played at the previous club - we have a habit of trying to work round pegs into square hole syndrome.

So where should we use him?

There's like 4 games left...
Hopefully that is some one else's problem soon enough.

He's always been a #6
And he's always been a Bulldog.

Keen to see if he has a dig at his next club as he never did for us.

Pretty sure he played 9 in a GF...
Listening to the Bulldogs banter at the time we signed him, And it was clear then was the only Place Mbye works hard at is the Lips.
He's always talked the talk, Seems a nice enough guys - And probably a reasonably clever football brain...
But he's Lazy, Overpaid, And Does.Not.Give.A.Rats...

More than once I've seen on his socials him having fish and chips for lunch with his family at the beach (No Beaches around the inner west) when we're playing later in the day....
I don't begrudge a guy Lunch, Or his Family.... But surely that's not game day activity for a professional footballer / Club captain.

He's a magician the deals he's talked his way into...
We'll lose absolutely nothing from our team if we pay his full freight next year...

On the other side of the coin - How good is Corey Norman going when he's getting replaced with Moses Mbye?? And a side note to that - I don't watch the Dragons but i remember Corey Norman "Winning them Games" in his time there - I've barely seen Moses Mbye break out of a jog for us.... And maybe once scored a try that put a game beyond reach.

Bulldogs paid him to play against them.
We'll pay him to play against us
so will the next, so on and so forth....
He's Garbage.

Pretty sure carbo loading before and after a game is a thing . Especially during the warmer months , and getting as many fats as you can get . Due to the extreme workload a guy can get through during an nrl game .
How do you know what the dietician has approved and not approved ?
Imagine stalking a dudes Instagram and criticising him for have a couple of calamari rings and a few chips for lunch when he plays at 730 that night .
The lack of walking the walk , for sure , that’s a thing , but the rest really shows your lack of knowledge not his lack of commitment .

 

[hobbo1]

Mbye is far from our worst player. A few seasons ago he was one of our best. He joined to play under Cleary which he went ok. **Madge doesn’t know how to use him**. As to his contract $$ that’s not on him the club put him on a monster deal just like Packer, Reynolds and Mats. Those 3 would be worse than Mbye by a mile for us regarding signings. Our big name recruits have a history of being diabolical with us because we just don’t play them how they played at the previous club - we have a habit of trying to work round pegs into square hole syndrome.

So where should we use him?

There's like 4 games left...
Hopefully that is some one else's problem soon enough.

He's always been a #6
And he's always been a Bulldog.

Keen to see if he has a dig at his next club as he never did for us.

He is probably one of the best 14 in the comp now.

I don't think so.

800k for a 14.
Bad business.

I agree re: the $’s, but he covers more positions than most.

Mbye is far from our worst player. A few seasons ago he was one of our best. He joined to play under Cleary which he went ok. **Madge doesn’t know how to use him**. As to his contract $$ that’s not on him the club put him on a monster deal just like Packer, Reynolds and Mats. Those 3 would be worse than Mbye by a mile for us regarding signings. Our big name recruits have a history of being diabolical with us because we just don’t play them how they played at the previous club - we have a habit of trying to work round pegs into square hole syndrome.

So where should we use him?

There's like 4 games left...
Hopefully that is some one else's problem soon enough.

He's always been a #6
And he's always been a Bulldog.

Keen to see if he has a dig at his next club as he never did for us.

He is probably one of the best 14 in the comp now.

I don't think so.

800k for a 14.
Bad business.

I agree re: the $’s, but he covers more positions than most.

Isn't great at any.

I would claim Peachy is a better 14
Or Nicholas Hynes.

Players who actually turn up.

It’s all arguable, but I never stated he was the best.

You legit said...

"He is probably one of the best 14 in the comp now."

?

Correct and imo, he is.

There wouldn’t be many who can cover the whole backline and the 9?

But he doesn’t .. he sucks wherever he plays lol