Melbourne are average

@innsaneink said:
@Flippedy said:
Love how everyone is jumping the gun and focussing on our match up in week 3 lol. We have to actually win in week 2 yet! We will most probably be playing the Warriors in week 2 and they will be hellbent on redeeming that super bad performance last night. One week at a time, please.

You could say youre jumping the gun and assuming Melb beat the Knights (half time now)….if Knights win we play Melb next week - yes I know unlikely but thats not the point.

Yes you could say that Ink, but I did say 'most probably' in my post, whereas others are just saying outright who and where we're gonna play in week 3!
 
@Adman said:
Melbourne are playing superbly. Saying Melbourne are average is rediculous. They are minor premieres and are a force again. They don't make mistakes, well not in today's game anyway.

Melb is in no way average, to finish 1st after so much player turnover is remarkable.

They are'nt the scary force they used to be but they play some good footy and make few mistakes.

My verdict is "They are very beatable" and they should be very worried if the tigers get through.
 
@Adman said:
Melbourne are playing superbly. Saying Melbourne are average is rediculous. They are minor premieres and are a force again. They don't make mistakes, well not in today's game anyway.

Melb is in no way average, to finish 1st after so much player turnover is remarkable.

They are'nt the scary force they used to be but they play some good footy and make few mistakes.

My verdict is "They are very beatable" and they should be very worried if the tigers get through.
 
@Spartan117 said:
@Adman said:
Melbourne are playing superbly. Saying Melbourne are average is rediculous. They are minor premieres and are a force again. They don't make mistakes, well not in today's game anyway.

Melb is in no way average, to finish 1st after so much player turnover is remarkable.

They are'nt the scary force they used to be but they play some good footy and make few mistakes.

My verdict is "They are very beatable" and they should be very worried if the tigers get through.

Every team left in the finals are scared of the Tigers Spartan
It would be very hard to play a team play well and still the oppositon only turned it on for thirty minutes and kicked your butt
Thats why the Tigers are scary And why we love them :sign:
 
if we cant beat warriors then we dont deserve melbourne. i say set your sights on winning the comp. that is the goal. new zealand is a speed hump.
 
They looked average today that's for sure. The Knights scored straight away as soon as they got their first tackle in the Storm's 20\. They didn't score one try in the second half and one of their tries was off a Knight's dropped ball. It could have easily been 12 - 12\. After watching this I feel much more confident in beating Melbourne in Melbourne, however I think the week off is going to do them a world of good unfortunately…
 
@AmericanHistoryX said:
@Flippedy said:
@alexaki said:
@rachtig25 said:
lets worry bout the warriors 1st before talking about melb

Touche!

Exactly what I said about 5,000 posts ago! :unamused:

oh please give me a break - 9 straight wins to lost to new zealand. i dont think so. new zealand should have been knocked out for being the second biggest loser.

In the end, it really doesn't matter what any of us think, AHX. Ask the coach and the team what they think. They would never dismiss a semi final opponent as readily as us fans do, and thank God, otherwise they wouldn't win anything. WT will only be focussed on the Warriors this week, not Melbourne.
 
In the end, it really doesn't matter what any of us think, AHX. Ask the coach and the team what they think. They would never dismiss a semi final opponent as readily as us fans do, and thank God, otherwise they wouldn't win anything. WT will only be focussed on the Warriors this week, not Melbourne.
\
\
\
x2 exactly my thoughts
 
thats true guys, i know what you mean, but i have to tell you the wests tigers spirit has rubbed off on me. i feel the need for speed.
 
I can't see Melbourne winning with only three great players. Very few teams can win a gf with such limited attacking ability. There defense is strong but attack predictable and boring. I hope the ref doesn't allow them to lie around the ruck. Finally the tigers have the wood on Melbourne. Can someone give me the statistics on the last ten head to head. That's also taking into consideration they cheated. Melbourne three years ago would make a mockery of this team and I believe the competition has got stronger.
 
Big game next Friday night hope we get plenty of our supporters out there I know friday nights can be a problem with work etc. I'll be there and hope many other WTs supporters will be too. Concentrate on winning this game firts, then take on Melbourne that will be a test.
 
Back
Top