OFFICIAL Pathways - KOE General Discussion

  • Thread starter Thread starter Cobarcats
  • Start date Start date
The Knock On Effect NSW Cup - Round 15 vs. Sea Eagles

Sunday, June 11 - 3:00 p.m. AEST
HE Laybutt Field, Sydney

WESTERN SUBURBS MAGPIES
1. Daine Laurie
2. Liam Scolari
3. Brent Naden
4. Triston Reilly
5. Israel Ogden
6. Zane Camroux
7. Will Smith
8. Aitasi James
9. Rua Ngatikaura (c)
10. Tukimihia Simpkins
11. Brandon Mansfield
12. Jack Boyling
13. Justin Matamua

14. Manaia Cherrington
15. James Roumanos
16. Sione Fainu
17. John Tuivaiti

18. Tony Pellow
Coach: Wayne Lambkin
 
KingRobbie said:
The Knock On Effect NSW Cup - Round 15 vs. Sea Eagles

Sunday, June 11 - 3:00 p.m. AEST
HE Laybutt Field, Sydney

WESTERN SUBURBS MAGPIES
1. Daine Laurie
2. Liam Scolari
3. Brent Naden
4. Triston Reilly
5. Israel Ogden
6. Zane Camroux
7. Will Smith
8. Aitasi James
9. Rua Ngatikaura (c)
10. Tukimihia Simpkins
11. Brandon Mansfield
12. Jack Boyling
13. Justin Matamua

14. Manaia Cherrington
15. James Roumanos
16. Sione Fainu
17. John Tuivaiti

18. Tony Pellow
Coach: Wayne Lambkin
Click to expand...
Solid looking team. I think a run or 2 in Reggie’s will be good for Naden, plus Talau playing ok.
No TDS so the plot thickens eh !
 
What is everyone's thoughts on Jack Boyling if you've seen him play quite a bit?

I've heard he's a good trainer & clubman, and from games I've seen on Fox & NSWRLTV, he is a solid workmanlike back-rower in both attack & defence and has proven to be able to fill in at hooker if absolutely required.

Could this versatility put him in the mix for a base-contract spot in the top 30 if Blore & Jake Simpkin move on?
 
BlackWhiteGold said:
What is everyone's thoughts on Jack Boyling if you've seen him play quite a bit?

I've heard he's a good trainer & clubman, and from games I've seen on Fox & NSWRLTV, he is a solid workmanlike back-rower in both attack & defence and has proven to be able to fill in at hooker if absolutely required.

Could this versatility put him in the mix for a base-contract spot in the top 30 if Blore & Jake Simpkin move on?
Click to expand...
I don't think so.
He'd be a career nsw cup player, train and trial type. may at some point get a run in first if a club has a crisis and he fills in.
He's just too small to play in the forwards in nrl. He's like a smaller version of Tumeth. While he competes well and works hard in Cup he's not really dynamic enough to play hooker, has limited ball playing and doesn't' run good lines like some other second rowers like BWM.
 
Has anyone seen much of Rua this year? Sounds like he has been injured a couple of times. I wonder where the rise of Da Silva leaves him?
 
Wearyfan22 said:
Has anyone seen much of Rua this year? Sounds like he has been injured a couple of times. I wonder where the rise of Da Silva leaves him?
Click to expand...
He's a good reserve-grade hooker, but don't think he'll ever be anything more.

Da Silva is five years younger than him and looks to have already jumped him in the pecking order.

People also forget that he's older than Simpkin.
 
Wearyfan22 said:
Has anyone seen much of Rua this year? Sounds like he has been injured a couple of times. I wonder where the rise of Da Silva leaves him?
Click to expand...
Hasn't appeared to be the player he was before his serious injury last year. His strength is his strong running game (particularly finding the try line from close range), but he has pretty much put that away apart from 1 try 2 weeks ago. I think he would have fallen quite a bit down the pecking order and wouldnt be surprised if he were to move on.
 
balmain boy said:
I don't think so.
He'd be a career nsw cup player, train and trial type. may at some point get a run in first if a club has a crisis and he fills in.
He's just too small to play in the forwards in nrl. He's like a smaller version of Tumeth. While he competes well and works hard in Cup he's not really dynamic enough to play hooker, has limited ball playing and doesn't' run good lines like some other second rowers like BWM.
Click to expand...
I think Boyling is better than some think.
I don’t know why everyone is fascinated by size, the best performed back rowers in the game at the moment t are players such as Reuben Cotter MOM in State of Origin 1, he’s about 93kgs at best.
Hudson Young at the Raiders around 97kgs.
Cameron Murray 97kgs at best.
 
Vicious said:
I think Boyling is better than some think.
I don’t know why everyone is fascinated by size, the best performed back rowers in the game at the moment t are players such as Reuben Cotter MOM in State of Origin 1, he’s about 93kgs at best.
Hudson Young at the Raiders around 97kgs.
Cameron Murray 97kgs at best.
Click to expand...
Cotter is 96kgs, but also has a stocky build. He's also the same age as Boyling, had 3 ACLs and yet still has played 50 first grade games, plus origins and internationals. He just has something special about him.
Boyling has maybe played 30-40 NSW cup games, you cannot compare the two...
Both Cotter and Young have huge impact on matches, at NRL level. Boyling is an honest toiler, good club man, he's playing fairly well. But doesnt come close to dominating matches.

Sure size isn't everything, but the smaller forwards that make it tend to stand out from the lack pack.
 
KingRobbie said:
He's a good reserve-grade hooker, but don't think he'll ever be anything more.

Da Silva is five years younger than him and looks to have already jumped him in the pecking order.

People also forget that he's older than Simpkin.
Click to expand...
Maybe we need to turn him back into a lock that can cover Hooker? He might be more useful to us that way.
 
Final team list for Cup tomorrow going to be intriguing.

Do you risk Daine, Tallyn, Nado etc? 6 day turnaround to Storm game so any failed HIAs rule them out, let alone risking other injury.

Pretty barebones now WITH them available.
 
Tigers_Wests said:
Hasn't appeared to be the player he was before his serious injury last year. His strength is his strong running game (particularly finding the try line from close range), but he has pretty much put that away apart from 1 try 2 weeks ago. I think he would have fallen quite a bit down the pecking order and wouldnt be surprised if he were to move on.
Click to expand...
I heard that the club have tried to move him on but there’s been no takers
 
The Knock On Effect NSW Cup - Round 15 vs. Sea Eagles

Sunday, June 11 - 3:00 p.m. AEST
HE Laybutt Field, Sydney

WESTERN SUBURBS MAGPIES
21. Daine Laurie
2. Israel Ogden
3. Brent Naden
4. Triston Reilly
5. Liam Scolari
6. Zane Camroux
7. Will Smith
8. Alex Seyfarth
9. Dean Blore
10. Tukimihia Simpkins
11. Brandon Mansfield
12. Jack Boyling
13. Justin Matamua

14. Tallyn Da Silva
15. James Roumanos
24. John Tuivaiti
17. Sione Fainu

18. Aden Perry
Coach: Wayne Lambkin
 
KingRobbie said:
The Knock On Effect NSW Cup - Round 15 vs. Sea Eagles

Sunday, June 11 - 3:00 p.m. AEST
HE Laybutt Field, Sydney

WESTERN SUBURBS MAGPIES
21. Daine Laurie
2. Israel Ogden
3. Brent Naden
4. Triston Reilly
5. Liam Scolari
6. Zane Camroux
7. Will Smith
8. Alex Seyfarth
9. Dean Blore
10. Tukimihia Simpkins
11. Brandon Mansfield
12. Jack Boyling
13. Justin Matamua

14. Tallyn Da Silva
15. James Roumanos
24. John Tuivaiti
17. Sione Fainu

18. Aden Perry
Coach: Wayne Lambkin
Click to expand...
Strange Cherrington and Rua are out
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Staff online

Members online

Total: 1,489 (members: 26, guests: 1,463)
Back
Top