Politics Super Thread - keep it all in here

Status
Not open for further replies.
The debt needs to be repaid. It's a simple choice - higher taxes or less spending. This needs to be ongoing as well. This is why I can't vote Liberal - they've screwed us. It might have been required and it has happened all over the world but it was on their watch. They don't have the right to run on good economic management.

You are 100% correct though in no one is brave enough. They probably need tax reform as well but no one will do that.
They don't have to raise taxes just get the big corporations/mines/etc. to pay their fair share like the rest of us. In fact, with the revenue raised by accurately taxing those corporations, you could conceivably lower taxes for small and medium-sized businesses plus all individuals and still be ahead. But somehow, some companies can make billions in profits and still pay zero tax. That's the real issue.
 
I have some questions:-

1. Did the government stuff up in the Solomon Islands ?
2. Can and should the government do anything about housing prices ?
 
I agree but on the flip side I think they made the right decision.
It is the correct decision now but imo attempting to convert a nuclear submarine design to non-nuclear submarine design was ambitious. A modified Collins Class design would have been a good outcome, although that would have required forward planning years in advance.
 
I have some questions:-

1. Did the government stuff up in the Solomon Islands ?
2. Can and should the government do anything about housing prices ?
Yes and yes. Tax advantages should never have been allowed for other than new housing that they were originally brought in to promote.
 
Name me one company that made billions in profit last year and paid zero tax.

This is an inaccurate, exaggerative trope and needs to die for the sake of accuracy and pragmatic policy formation moving forward.
They don't have to raise taxes just get the big corporations/mines/etc. to pay their fair share like the rest of us. In fact, with the revenue raised by accurately taxing those corporations, you could conceivably lower taxes for small and medium-sized businesses plus all individuals and still be ahead. But somehow, some companies can make billions in profits and still pay zero tax. That's the real issue.
 
No, the cost of living is an issue already without increasing a tax that makes virtually everything more expensive.

So what gives ?

This is what gets me. We have a massive debt. We have people wanting hand-outs and increased wages because cost of living is too high whatever that means.

Something has to give right ?

There is the stupid argument that debt doesn't matter but it does. You have to service that debt.
 
As I wrote above, only for new housing as it creates supply, whereas allowing it on existing dwellings narrows the market.

I don't get it. What needs to change ?

My take is that people get more money and they outbid each other so house prices increase. I don't see the governments job to fix this and I don't see how they can.
 
So what gives ?

This is what gets me. We have a massive debt. We have people wanting hand-outs and increased wages because cost of living is too high whatever that means.

Something has to give right ?

There is the stupid argument that debt doesn't matter but it does. You have to service that debt.

Correct. You do that by reducing spending or raising taxes.

I believe Australia should reclaim all mining and nationalise it, and put it in a future fund the way that Norway has.
 
I believe Australia should reclaim all mining and nationalise it, and put it in a future fund the way that Norway has.

I think you have a good idea in some ways. The flip side is that isn't the way you run capitalist economies but I don't really care about that. The real issue to me is companies like BHP would be devastated.

Interesting idea.
 
I think you have a good idea in some ways. The flip side is that isn't the way you run capitalist economies but I don't really care about that. The real issue to me is companies like BHP would be devastated.

Interesting idea.

I am sure that BHP and Rio Tinto have their nets cast far and wide.

I would like to see the value of Australian mined minerals used to benefit the Australian people.
 
Correct. You do that by reducing spending or raising taxes.

I believe Australia should reclaim all mining and nationalise it, and put it in a future fund the way that Norway has.
I cannot believe how short sided our policies in the last 30-40 years were, like we will never again be involved in a war! In our wisdom we sold out everything, and we don't control even our tactical reserves!😡
 
Tax compliance is an issue. How do you fix it - increase GST. Is that a good answer ?
There's as much non-compliance with GST as this is with most other federal taxes. Howard and Costello's promise that the GST would get rid of the black economy was a porkie and they were warned of it at the time.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Staff online

Back
Top