Robbie cracked tibia

I can see this being a repeat of grubs final game for the Dogs. Grub played the last game of the season at probably 40% fitness just so he could wear the jersey one last time. Robbie will try and do the same, especially with it being at LO. Lets say for the sake of argument we need to win to qualify. Do we play him at 40-50% fitness just so he can run out onto Leichhardt one last time? Pretty topical given the outcry over Mbye atm.
 
@tig_prmz Very disappointing from the club administration. Maybe not enough enough money to spend on sufficient number of staff.
 
@Newtown said in [Robbie cracked tibia](/post/1046860) said:
@tig_prmz Very disappointing from the club administration. Maybe not enough enough money to spend on sufficient number of staff.

why disappointing? what could the club have done?
 
@GNR4LIFE said in [Robbie cracked tibia](/post/1046854) said:
I can see this being a repeat of grubs final game for the Dogs. Grub played the last game of the season at probably 40% fitness just so he could wear the jersey one last time. Robbie will try and do the same, especially with it being at LO. Lets say for the sake of argument we need to win to qualify. Do we play him at 40-50% fitness just so he can run out onto Leichhardt one last time? Pretty topical given the outcry over Mbye atm.

i'd say this is different to any other injury. either the fracture heals or not. playing with a fracture shouldn't be considered tough, just stupid.
 
Tigers have probably seen back of Farah after broken tibia: top doctor
By Christian Nicolussi

August 12, 2019 — 4.43pm

In a massive blow to Wests Tigers' finals hopes, one of Australia's top sports doctors admits Robbie Farah has likely played his last NRL game.

And his teammates also don't expect to see the veteran No.9 in a Tigers jersey again.

Having already announced his retirement at the end of the year, Farah is sweating on any positive news from specialists after initial scans confirmed he had a crack at the top of his right tibia.

Farah bravely played on for 10 minutes against Canterbury on Saturday night, where he put in a kick and even tried to score from dummy half before he succumbed to the pain.
The Tigers favourite is known for his huge pain threshhold but Nathan Gibbs, who worked with Farah when he played for NSW – and is currently overseeing the Wallabies – says he should walk away now and not risk suffering further complications with his leg.

The latest crack also sits near the same ACL Farah ruptured in 2004, then had issues with again in the opening month of the 2016 season.

"Bone fractures needs a minimum four to six weeks to heal, and bigger bones take long, and the tibia is a bigger bone,'' Gibbs told the Herald.

"It's also the main load-bearing bone and where the main body-weight pressure goes through.



"If Robbie did try to play on with a crack in his tibia, he then runs the risk of completely fracturing the bone.''

Farah was given a rock-star reception at Leichhardt Oval last Thursday week as part of his 300-game celebrations, and the stars were already aligning for him to spearhead the Tigers' charge against Cronulla at the same ground in the final round for a potential finals berth.

Few at the club are prepared to write off Farah because of his tremendous healing powers and the fact he has enough respect to make the right call himself. He also has a classy entourage who know his body well, including Tigers physio Peter Moussa and South Sydney counterpart Eddie Farah, Robbie's brother.

Jacob Liddle, his long-term No.9 understudy, will get an early chance to give Tigers fans a glimpse of the post-Farah era when he starts against the Sea Eagles at Brookvale Oval.



Josh Reynolds appears unlikely to be brought into the team for the all-important clash, but the Herald understands Tommy Talau, the son of former Canterbury and New Zealand centre Willie Talau, will debut in the centres for injured captain Moses Mbye.

The Tigers can realistically drop one of their remaining four games if they are to return to the finals for the first time since 2011.

Farah was spotted on crutches at Concord Oval on Monday morning as his teammates did their best to discuss the coming weeks without the heart and soul of the club.

"It's disappointing because he's been in some great form and he's a real leader of this team,'' said Elijah Taylor, who filled in at dummy half once Farah went off during the 18-16 loss to the Bulldogs.



Michael Chee Kam added: "Everyone who knows 'Faf' knows he's a massive competitor. What he did on the field [to play on for 10 minutes with a broken leg], it would be horrible if that's the end of his career and to go out like that, so for his sake and us, we hope he's all right.

"Jacob Liddle will come in and bring a lot of energy and I'm excited to play with him.''

Liddle last week re-signed for a further two seasons and along with Queenslander Jake Simpkins will have the job of succeeding the 302-game premiership winner.
 
@GNR4LIFE said in [Robbie cracked tibia](/post/1046854) said:
I can see this being a repeat of grubs final game for the Dogs. Grub played the last game of the season at probably 40% fitness just so he could wear the jersey one last time. Robbie will try and do the same, especially with it being at LO. Lets say for the sake of argument we need to win to qualify. Do we play him at 40-50% fitness just so he can run out onto Leichhardt one last time? Pretty topical given the outcry over Mbye atm.


Under those circumstances, unless fit we don’t play him. If the game has no bearing on our position on the ladder then play him.
 
Robbie Farah says doctors have told him not to play again ... but he says he wants to play through the pain of a broken leg. Full story tonight @9NewsSyd
https://twitter.com/Danny_Weidler/status/1163303922129227776?s=19
 
@WT2K said in [Robbie cracked tibia](/post/1050657) said:
Robbie Farah says doctors have told him not to play again ... but he says he wants to play through the pain of a broken leg. Full story tonight @9NewsSyd
https://twitter.com/Danny_Weidler/status/1163303922129227776?s=19

Don't play, at this stage of career, don't endanger your long term health. You've done enough Robbie.
 
There's toughness, then there's stupidity. Playing on a broken leg when there's nothing on the line would fall into the latter category.
 
Well we will be a laughing stock if the club doctor advises Farah not to play and he ends up playing anyway.

1. He won’t be fully fit
2. He runs a high risk of further injury
3. Coaching team will look ridiculous
4. Last game of the season and more than likely a dead rubber.

Please don’t quote me Cronk here.
 
@TheDaBoss said in [Robbie cracked tibia](/post/1050664) said:
i feel bad for robbie, i really do he doesnt deserve to go out like this

He doesn't need to play and sustain a larger injury which will hamper his ability to live a quality life to prove a point.
 
What happens if he sustains another injury in the first few minutes. We are short of a player for the full match. Unfair for the other players?
 
Would be stupid to potentially cripple himself for the sake of one last hurrah. He can walk out onto the field and give everyone a wave, That's enough. The boys can lift him up and chair him off the field.

He already has a crook back, you don't want to add a screwed up leg to that for the rest of your life Robbie.
 
https://www.weststigers.com.au/news/2019/08/19/press-conference-robbie-farah/

You get the sense that he will play no matter what. It’s instilled in his character and sometimes may get the better of him.
 
If we let him play, then that is stupidity beyond belief laid solely at the people in charge of this club, like seriously, Robbie should have zero say in any of this.

the club will probably let him play though so we can get another fluff piece of media coverage in the papers. Bore off.
 
@TheDaBoss said in [Robbie cracked tibia](/post/1050664) said:
i feel bad for robbie, i really do he doesnt deserve to go out like this

Yeah, he probably doesn't, but very few great players go out the way they deserve - like holding the premiership trophy in the air or whatever.

At the end of the day it's footy and it is just that way sometimes. And the game is bigger than every player....even Robbie.
 

Latest posts

Members online

Back
Top