LIVE GAME Round 14 vs. Dragons

Live Game Discussion
I been saying weve ZERO depth .Our NSW cup side are a pitiful joke stone motherless last and a for and against that's almost twice as bad as the 2nd worst team .
We then lose about 10 of 17 from our Ideal Nrl team and fill all those vacancies with our cup side . Our cup side are not reserve grade they are 3rd grade or Ron Massey cup or whatever .
Didn't Benji realise early in the year he's got no suitable replacements
The definition of Depth is you have a pool of players covering most positions and when you lose players from your NRL side due to injury or suspensions not a huge impact
The Storm and Penrith have exactly that .
Penrith have their own feeder stream and the Storm scour a number of the QLD cup and NSWcup top teams and have depth ! If we had Douehi and Toupu and kept Talau and kept joffa and kept leiluah and Garner and had Bateman and Papalii and were winning so Stephano was still motivated and had Klemmer and Twal to go with Bula ,Api ,Staines and Olam and a fit Toa and Galvin and Sezer
There's 18 but ATM as at yesterday weve got 6 of that 18
You know when business hold meetings they need a Quorum to function
I've listed 18 NRL quality players that we have or recently used to have that would make a functional Nrl club but with only 6 available you can't fill the 10-12 gaps with DUDS !
Please don't blame Api or Bula or Galvin or Twal for these terrible performances as they are on a hiding to nothing in such a Dud team .
Ps 2 Weeks ago I would have listed Stephano with the 6 Quality but not now he obviously
wants out and is not putting in .
We need really major recruitment to fix this that means about 7 or 8 minimum
Stop filling the holes with Duds .Stop releasing players except our NSW cup regulars
Its a mammoth job but the huge Chasm between our Ideal Nrl side and a 3rd grade reserves should have been identified before the season began
For gods sake Benji the fact that you've picked Kepoa and dropped him at least 6 times should have told you something .So far you have one thing in common with Madge that is poor judgement
 
Mate 100% like the video linked earlier In this thread and like I said yesterday, benji should have ripped those boys to ribbons. They have no steel and a disturbing lack of fire in the belly for nrl football. Nobody was actively trying to impact the result except for api who tackled himself into a standstill. IMHO api should go to another team, he doesnt deserve the apathetic rubbish these loosers dish up every week.

Maybe we need to hit rock bottom?

Well said mate. It's got me a bit sick in all honesty lol.

Everytime we hit rock bottom we manage to find
new depths. Really feel for the die hard fans if anything.
 
Not...yet. the part I don't understand is why anyone thought 2024 would be radically different to 2023 or 2022.
I’m not sure how people can’t see that when you remove experience from a side and replace it with rookies how you expect that team to improve and not go backwards.
 
There was one thing the benji said in the interview, that sent shivers throw my brain , he said we have juniors coming throw for next year ( I think that’s what I heard ) I screamed at the tv , benji have u see the nsw cup team play , or ur just bullshitting ur self .
 
There was one thing the benji said in the interview, that sent shivers throw my brain , he said we have juniors coming throw for next year ( I think that’s what I heard ) I screamed at the tv , benji have u see the nsw cup team play , or ur just bullshitting ur self .
The club has had a very inflated opinion of the juniors coming through for some time. Sheens was waxing lyrical when he came back. Still waiting to see what all the fuss is about.
 
Well said mate. It's got me a bit sick in all honesty lol.

Everytime we hit rock bottom we manage to find
new depths. Really feel for the die hard fans if anything.
I don't feel for them at all.
Magpies won a comp. in 1952 and then as the Tigers in 2005.
We're not due until 2058.
All this soft cock pissing and moaning is unbecoming.
 
I don't think I've ever seen a forward with a worse tackling style than Seyfarth. The way he just flails his arms and slaps at players as they run past him is ridiculously bad.
Yeah he's very very unco.... Typical Dundas Shamrocks style lol 🤣
But he goes all day and has a lot of ticker, and busts his hump for 80...getting a bit of grubbiness in his game too which has only emerged recently
I half expect him to burst into tears whenever there's been a bit of a push n shove... All. Emotion....not much smarts
 
Yeah he's very very unco.... Typical Dundas Shamrocks style lol 🤣
But he goes all day and has a lot of ticker, and busts his hump for 80...getting a bit of grubbiness in his game too which has only emerged recently
I half expect him to burst into tears whenever there's been a bit of a push n shove... All. Emotion....not much smarts
I thought it was just me noticing his grubbiness. Didn’t think it was there before haha. Good on him for developing his game 🤣 As long as we pay accordingly I like him in the squad.
 

Staff online

Back
Top