Round 22 discussion *Spoilers

[mike]

What a rubbish penalty.

correct penalty.

Kelly beat Radley there and Radley came almost from the side and attacked the legs. Desperation or not, you can't put a man under a risk of injury like this.

Fair and correct call.

I don't approve of the "he was trying to do his best" arguement. Same with fullbacks rushing in and hitting a player trying to score a try. That player has beaten you and now you're trying your best but you can't put the person under stress.

100% Correct call.

So was the last Penalty for a whack across the face. Suck it Broncos

 

[nrlsurvivor]

If you listen to the audio Perenara didn’t even notice the high tackle. He had to be promoted by the ref to take another look.

 

[hsvjones]

What a rubbish penalty.

correct penalty.

Kelly beat Radley there and Radley came almost from the side and attacked the legs. Desperation or not, you can't put a man under a risk of injury like this.

Fair and correct call.

I don't approve of the "he was trying to do his best" arguement. Same with fullbacks rushing in and hitting a player trying to score a try. That player has beaten you and now you're trying your best but you can't put the person under stress.

100% Correct call.

So was the last Penalty for a whack across the face. Suck it Broncos

Yes both correct calls to me...

 

[Yossarian]

That’s totally how we’d lose a game. Broncos are stealing our material.

 

[voice_of_reason]

Shows how important the captain's challenge can be.

 

[Shooter Mcgavin]

Cronk unbearable commentary

 

[JC99]

What an odd game of rugby league

 

[TheDaBoss]

What an odd game of rugby league

entertaining match tho lol

 

[voice_of_reason]

Cronk unbearable commentary

What about SBW on nine? Clueless.

 

[Tiger-ferret]

Paid attention to the million dollar man tonight…typical game from what I think of manu. Didn’t play bad. Possibly could have been injured. I still have to watch last weeks roosters game.

 

[Telltails]

Great captain's game by Teddy

 

[since 57]

Teddys now a ball hog..wouldnt pass wind

 

[innsaneink]

Insane game

 

[TigerVinnie]

Cronk unbearable commentary

You would think he was a Rooster 1 club man....hes become such a fan boy of that club now.

 

[cktiger]

Paid attention to the million dollar man tonight…typical game from what I think of manu. Didn’t play bad. Possibly could have been injured. I still have to watch last weeks roosters game.

Manu did bugger all .
Not worth anywhere near the likes of Teddy, Latrell or Turbo.

 

[Chicken_Faced_Killa]

Will Trent Robinson complain in the presser? Or does that only apply when the rules are applied against his team like that.

Clearly barely a high tackle and also incorrect use of the captains challenge. You can challenge a decision but not a non decision. That’s twice this weekend they got it wrong. In the Melbourne game they got an extra challenge because they infringed before what the challenges happened (and they were wrong anyway).

They have just shown everyone what to do. Minor head contact, knock on before playing the ball and you will get the penalty.

 

[Tiger-ferret]

Paid attention to the million dollar man tonight…typical game from what I think of manu. Didn’t play bad. Possibly could have been injured. I still have to watch last weeks roosters game.

Manu did bugger all .
Not worth anywhere near the likes of Teddy, Latrell or Turbo.

Game in tha balance. Attacking in the 30 and he’s out on the wing

 

[cktiger]

Will Trent Robinson complain in the presser? Or does that only apply when the rules are applied against his team like that.

Clearly barely a high tackle and also incorrect use of the captains challenge. You can challenge a decision but not a non decision. That’s twice this weekend they got it wrong. In the Melbourne game they got an extra challenge because they infringed before what the challenges happened (and they were wrong anyway).

They have just shown everyone what to do. Minor head contact, knock on before playing the ball and you will get the penalty.

Maybe they were challenging the decision of not making a decision.

 

[BAGNF05]

Will Trent Robinson complain in the presser? Or does that only apply when the rules are applied against his team like that.

Clearly barely a high tackle and also incorrect use of the captains challenge. You can challenge a decision but not a non decision. That’s twice this weekend they got it wrong. In the Melbourne game they got an extra challenge because they infringed before what the challenges happened (and they were wrong anyway).

They have just shown everyone what to do. Minor head contact, knock on before playing the ball and you will get the penalty.

Typical roosters favouritism.

 

[JC99]

Will Trent Robinson complain in the presser? Or does that only apply when the rules are applied against his team like that.

Clearly barely a high tackle and also incorrect use of the captains challenge. You can challenge a decision but not a non decision. That’s twice this weekend they got it wrong. In the Melbourne game they got an extra challenge because they infringed before what the challenges happened (and they were wrong anyway).

They have just shown everyone what to do. Minor head contact, knock on before playing the ball and you will get the penalty.

Typical roosters favouritism.

Roosters had some pretty bad calls against them too. Was a wobbly night from the referees on both sides