Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

Mate .. what question?

I made a statement that I am tired of having undersized players and evidenced it with last weeks debacle …

I don’t want another undersized forward ,.. just my opinion ,,..you are entitled to yours
Undersized players have to have that extra little something to their games just to be able to compete. There's room for one or two of them, but have too many at the same time and you get overrun by bigger teams eventually.
 
Not really worthy of this thread but Zane Camroux is back after a stint in the Dolphins system this seasion. He played half back for Ryde Eastwood in their Ron Massey Cup win today, scoring a try & kicking about 5 goals.

FYI Jimmy Ngutlik scored a try in Sydney Shield playing about 60 mins before subbed out.
 
Fisher harris isn't a big prop he's 6'2 and 105 kg which is large for a normal guy but at least 10kgs lighter then everyone else you listed.

For all people like to complain our up and comers are undersized they generally are around the same size as penrith the gold standard of the comp
The players being mentioned here though aren't 6'2, which would be in the top 3-4 largest players for us. These youngsters are all 5'10 to 5'11, which is a small frame for an NRL forward.

How many forwards (or even players) do Panthers have under 180cm?
 
So who actually posted it? Was it Buzz or someone else. If not true, why did they post it???
How are people falling for this crap? It had like 6 typos in it, including the name of our club. And yet some on here thought it was legit? Even after the poster admitted they made it as a gee up? It's all pure fantasy. The telegraph doesn't have high standards, but they are still higher than year 7 English...
 
How are people falling for this crap? It had like 6 typos in it, including the name of our club. And yet some on here thought it was legit? Even after the poster admitted they made it as a gee up? It's all pure fantasy. The telegraph doesn't have high standards, but they are still higher than year 7 English...
Desperation???.
 
Luai brilliant half for the Panthers. He appears to love to be the dominant half with Cleary out. Big signing for WTs.
He’s been unbelievable. From a Tigers perspective geez Cleary getting injured and Luai getting an extended run at 7 has been a blessing. That question mark has completely been removed. That 1.2m a season is starting to look like fair value.
 
He’s been unbelievable. From a Tigers perspective geez Cleary getting injured and Luai getting an extended run at 7 has been a blessing. That question mark has completely been removed. That 1.2m a season is starting to look like fair value.
In my view, there was never any doubt about Luai and his quality. The price we paid is what it took to get him away from the Panthers. I believe it will be one of the best signings in the NRL. There will be many clubs looking on at what has happened with a "we should have chased him" view.
 
In my view, there was never any doubt about Luai and his quality. The price we paid is what it took to get him away from the Panthers. I believe it will be one of the best signings in the NRL. There will be many clubs looking on at what has happened with a "we should have chased him" view.
I never had any doubts about his quality. I did have doubts if he could run a team from 7. He’s shown he can do that and keep his individual brilliance.
 
Back
Top