Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

[SwervinMervin]

Probably.
As you say our wage bill for halves is already looking extremely high.
I don’t mind Jock Madden as depth, but 350k seems like fairly expensive depth.

Bud at $500k? I would suggest $350k for a backup half with first grade experience is about par score.

 

[weststigers]

Why do you guys get all twisted up on guessing salaries? It gets you nowhere because you'll never find out for sure what players are really being paid.

Woods reckons he was in 68k in his final year at Manly and people were speculating loads more. You just never know unless they are a top line player where there is more info around.

 

[Tim Sheens]

Our Fullback is yet to be extended on in my opinion not worth the dollars being discussed. Was wondering what an alternate option would cost.

Probably losing the better fullback.

 

[gregjm87]

Probably losing the better fullback.

Don't know about better, but certainly different qualities.

 

[Vicious]

NBWT on Twitter tipping Peter Taateo will be upgraded to Top 30:..money must be a bit tight after the latest splurge of Madden

I like the look of Taateo and hope we do keep him for at least another season as he looks like a middle with a bit of aggression and hits top speed quickly when running the ball.
However IF he takes a top 30 spot it would mean we are virtually full in our forwards without making any improvements other than KPP.
Similarly we would only really have a couple of spots left for depth outside backs in which 2 spots will likely go to Izaak Tu’itupou and Krystian Mapapalangi.
Again not bad players, we will know much more about Tu’itupou’s value to us after this weekend, but aside from Taylan May and the hopeful progression of Makasini and Luke Laulilli, we will not have made much improvement to our backs either.
It seems the only way we can potentially make 1 or 2 more bigger name signings would be if we offload a combination of Bud Sullivan, Royce Hunt and Jack Bird without having to contribute much towards their contract.

 

[gregjm87]

Woods reckons he was in 68k in his final year at Manly and people were speculating loads more. You just never know unless they are a top line player where there is more info around.

Don't know about loads more. Was reported as an 80k development contract.

 

[88]

Wonder how May would go as a Fullback after some time back in the game??

 

[The Chad]

I'm surprised half the board has the motivation to get up in the morning.

3 pages of...

Madden signing for $750k
Costing us Doueihi
Sullivan on somewhere between $550k & $700k
Souths chipping in only $20 for bus fare
Some unknown kid from Qld not coming to the Tigers shows we can't sign anyone
Upgrades for Taatteo, Tu'itupou & Mapapalangi locked in showing we can't sign anyone
Bula gone
Should sign Jaiden Campbell to replace Bula now
Madden to start at 7
Luai gone
Api close to being as agile as the Queen Mary

I've probably missed some

 

[balmain boy]

Javon supposedly making his senior debut in the Qld Cup this weekend.
I agree, he will get a top 30 deal with someone for 2026, whether that be us or with someone else.

Very slim chance that anyone offers the kid an NRL contract. There have been many kids who've done well at u19 origin, but it still takes time to get ready for playing men. He won't play first grade next year for anyone. So he shouldn't be in any top 30. A development player makes sense as he'll likely start next year in Flegg whenever he goes. All signs point to us currently

 

[balmain boy]

Probably.
As you say our wage bill for halves is already looking extremely high.
I don’t mind Jock Madden as depth, but 350k seems like fairly expensive depth.

That's why the Broncos chipped in 100k. 250k for a backup half is good, and absolutely necessary. We have 3 halves with us currently for next season, hardly overkill..

 

[balmain boy]

Woods reckons he was in 68k in his final year at Manly and people were speculating loads more. You just never know unless they are a top line player where there is more info around.

That's about half the minimum wage, so no, he wasn't on that

 

[Joelcainenumber1fan]

awesome i never wanted madden to leave in the first place handy backup half

 

[Vicious]

That's why the Broncos chipped in 100k. 250k for a backup half is good, and absolutely necessary. We have 3 halves with us currently for next season, hardly overkill..

If we are paying him 250k that is more like a decent deal in our favour for a change.

 

[TIGERS]

Our Fullback is yet to be extended on in my opinion not worth the dollars being discussed. Was wondering what an alternate option would cost.

It's easy to say he's not worth '900'k. I can understand why, he's looked a bit languid at times this season, but he's a legit talent that's for sure.

I think framing the argument of "Is bula worth 900k' is a bit misleading. I think most decent NRL fullbacks will be on anywhere from 750 upwards... (As usual, probably more for us). I think we should be really thinking is Bula worth the extra couple of hundred grand a season beyond what we are going to need to stump up for a fullback anyway. I say yes.

 

[TIGERS]

I'm surprised half the board has the motivation to get up in the morning.

3 pages of...

Madden signing for $750k
Costing us Doueihi
Sullivan on somewhere between $550k & $700k
Souths chipping in only $20 for bus fare
Some unknown kid from Qld not coming to the Tigers shows we can't sign anyone
Upgrades for Taatteo, Tu'itupou & Mapapalangi locked in showing we can't sign anyone
Bula gone
Should sign Jaiden Campbell to replace Bula now
Madden to start at 7
Luai gone
Api close to being as agile as the Queen Mary

I've probably missed some

Don't worry we have a game tomorrow that'll bring back some common sense.

 

[The Chad]

Invincible belief: Incredible story of the ‘05 Tigers, the unlikeliest premiers of all

How the ‘05 Tigers shocked them all

www.foxsports.com.au

Just because it's a good read.

But also because there are some similarities in the build up. Good group of kids coming into the squad, a big signing spree one year, with a couple of astute additions the following year...

If the Tigers finish 2025 winning close to half the remaining games....

 

[SwervinMervin]

Probably losing the better fullback.

Not sure if he’s a better fullback or has the same upside potential as Bula, but Will Kennedy may end up being squeezed out of Cronulla. He’s a good player. Not in the same class as Teddy, Edwards, Walsh, Ponga, etc. but more than a solid first grade fullback.

 

[twentyforty]

Not sure if he’s a better fullback or has the same upside potential as Bula, but Will Kennedy may end up being squeezed out of Cronulla. He’s a good player. Not in the same class as Teddy, Edwards, Walsh, Ponga, etc. but more than a solid first grade fullback.

Agree, Kennedy would be a suitable replacement for Bula.
Also, an unpopular idea, but I’d love to see Staines get a handful of games at Fullback.

 

[weststigers]

That's about half the minimum wage, so no, he wasn't on that

Listen from 48:50

It was a supplementary contract. The point was, people don't actually know the details of a players deal.

 

[weststigers]

I'm surprised half the board has the motivation to get up in the morning.

3 pages of...

Madden signing for $750k
Costing us Doueihi
Sullivan on somewhere between $550k & $700k
Souths chipping in only $20 for bus fare
Some unknown kid from Qld not coming to the Tigers shows we can't sign anyone
Upgrades for Taatteo, Tu'itupou & Mapapalangi locked in showing we can't sign anyone
Bula gone
Should sign Jaiden Campbell to replace Bula now
Madden to start at 7
Luai gone
Api close to being as agile as the Queen Mary

I've probably missed some

Nicely summed up...the bed wetters come out in force if we haven't signed an origin rep every 3 weeks.