Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

Betterdays22 said:
As a low cost back up half he is serviceable. I don't think anyone is claiming it to be a revolutionary signing.

Giving a top 30 and first drop halves spot to an unproven teenager would be a pretty poor recruitment move imo.
Click to expand...

We’ll agree to disagree ..the “unproven teenager” will be on a Top 30:deal somewhere next season … just like Makasini will be here …
 
Tom Shines said:
I would rather AD or the u/20 Origin guy to be the backup half
Click to expand...
Doueihi (if he re-signs) will play 13 by the looks of it, but can shift to 6 if needed.

We still need a 7 and 6 to play cup.each week and they need to be on low money and not expect to be first picked. Ideally they've had a few first grade games and not Wakeham standard in casebthey get a call up.

I think Jock fits that and if we get Javon Andrews, then we have him developing there too.

It's about as exciting as signing Kurt Falls, but necessary in relation to depth.
 
weststigers said:
Doueihi (if he re-signs) will play 13 by the looks of it, but can shift to 6 if needed.

We still need a 7 and 6 to play cup.each week and they need to be on low money and not expect to be first picked. Ideally they've had a few first grade games and not Wakeham standard in casebthey get a call up.

I think Jock fits that and if we get Javon Andrews, then we have him developing there too.

It's about as exciting as signing Kurt Falls, but necessary in relation to depth.
Click to expand...

I would suggest AD looks gone after this signing ….
 
Tom Shines said:
We’ll agree to disagree ..the “unproven teenager” will be on a Top 30:deal somewhere next season … just like Makasini will be here …
Click to expand...
I think its unlikely he will be top 30. Fair play to him of he does but our days of throwing kids into our top 30 bar out and out studs (Makasini) is over.

As pointed out many, many times we need to continue building out the depth across the park. Madden is a good step.
 
Betterdays22 said:
I think its unlikely he will be top 30. Fair play to him of he does but our days of throwing kids into our top 30 bar out and out studs (Makasini) is over.

As pointed out many, many times we need to continue building out the depth across the park. Madden is a good step.
Click to expand...

Mate… this guy next year will be just as good as Makasini… he will definitely have a Top 30 deal as there are maximums you can pay otherwise and he will be earning more than that
 
Tom Shines said:
He could have been retained at starting 13 and been still moved to halves if needed as dep5
Click to expand...
Oh got it. Yeah he probably is as the 6...maybe for 7, Madden is the replacement. Doueihi has a strong running game, so maybe they want an organising half around as well.

You still need 4 halves in the squad, so maybe you're right..Jarome, Latu, Adam and Madden...makes sense.
 
Tom Shines said:
He could have been retained at starting 13 and been still moved to halves if needed as deptn
Click to expand...
shifting your team around if one of your halves is out isn’t ideal, wouldn’t it be better to have a back up come straight in and keep Adam at 13 if that’s the plan for him
 
TIGERS said:
We have an option on Bula. Richo said on the ABC that his form leading up to his injury was worth the cost of his extension anyway. So I'd guess that's most likely what is going to happen at the end of the Season. His contract will go to 900k and he's off the market until 2028.

Moses gets no commision on Bula's current contract anyway, as it was established by his former agent. A few emails will pass between Moses and club recruiters, and that will get over reported by SMH grubs as 'gauging interest' or 'negotiations' with other clubs, but it's mostly a wind up.
Click to expand...
If the Isaac Moses playbook goes the same way it normally does, he will be asking us to upgrade Bula’s contract and pay him 900k from 2026 and not be happy to wait until 2027.
That way we would have to renegotiate his contract to allow Isaac to get his cut of the new deal and if we say no, he will threaten to request a release.
 
weststigers said:
Oh got it. Yeah he probably is as the 6...maybe for 7, Madden is the replacement. Doueihi has a strong running game, so maybe they want an organising half around as well.

You still need 4 halves in the squad, so maybe you're right..Jarome, Latu, Adam and Madden...makes sense.
Click to expand...

I think Douehi would be the replacement for both … JL can play either position…

Anyway moot point now is my prediction… I’ve thought even prior to this that they would have done the deal with AD by now if they really wanted him …
 
tigahhh said:
shifting your team around if one of your halves is out isn’t ideal, wouldn’t it be better to have a back up come straight in and keep Adam at 13 if that’s the plan for him
Click to expand...

No… you put the best team on the paddock each week … there are replacements for 13 in the team that have played there most of the season
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Staff online

Members online

Total: 557 (members: 35, guests: 522)
Back
Top