Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

[avocadoontoast]

Problem is in the last 2 seasons he’s created more nothings out of somethings…

Agree but he’s only 25 and does have some class. For the right price could be worth the risk.

 

[finnzo]

Drinkwater is the pick for me then Milford and Moylan last to many injuries he missed most of last year I’m not 100% sure but I think milf played every game

 

[pawsandclaws1]

Ok , we are really scrapping the bottom of the barrel now.

What do we find down there Moylan, Milford and other assorted over hyped plodders that are not delivering because their "Flash in the pan" days are over.
If we are not happy with Thommo at FB for 2020 then quickly throw the kitchen sink at Lomax or Munster.

At least go for someone decent and not buy someone that is going to take us backwards - we have enough of these players already - and are trying to get rid of them.

Don’t be so quick to write off Milford and Moylan. Both class players on their day who for the right price could be good pickups.

Milford may be okay if the Broncos are paying nearly all his freight. Moylan a huge no under any circumstances.

 

[HabboTiger]

Becoming the Samoan test team

 

[Nelson]

Ok , we are really scrapping the bottom of the barrel now.

What do we find down there Moylan, Milford and other assorted over hyped plodders that are not delivering because their "Flash in the pan" days are over.
If we are not happy with Thommo at FB for 2020 then quickly throw the kitchen sink at Lomax or Munster.

At least go for someone decent and not buy someone that is going to take us backwards - we have enough of these players already - and are trying to get rid of them.

Don’t be so quick to write off Milford and Moylan. Both class players on their day who for the right price could be good pickups.

Milford may be okay if the Broncos are paying nearly all his freight. Moylan a huge no under any circumstances.

Yeah when I looked at team lists this year and saw Moylan as an inclusion my feeling was generally that the Sharks would be worse off because of it. If we're going to make a big purchase I'd rather it be someone who is actually performing rather than someone that we just hope will re-find past form...

 

[NT_Tiger]

Ok , we are really scrapping the bottom of the barrel now.

What do we find down there Moylan, Milford and other assorted over hyped plodders that are not delivering because their "Flash in the pan" days are over.
If we are not happy with Thommo at FB for 2020 then quickly throw the kitchen sink at Lomax or Munster.

At least go for someone decent and not buy someone that is going to take us backwards - we have enough of these players already - and are trying to get rid of them.

Don’t be so quick to write off Milford and Moylan. Both class players on their day who for the right price could be good pickups.

Milford may be okay if the Broncos are paying nearly all his freight. Moylan a huge no under any circumstances.

Yeah when I looked at team lists this year and saw Moylan as an inclusion my feeling was generally that the Sharks would be worse off because of it. If we're going to make a big purchase I'd rather it be someone who is actually performing rather than someone that we just hope will re-find past form...

I wouldn't even look at him and I hope Maguire agrees.

 

[pawsandclaws1]

I am most disappointed we missed out on Scott. Yes I know he has his share of problems but he is significantly ahead of any centre option we have not including Talau who is staring is NRL career. With all this money to spend, we should have been all over him. We have to get Lomax this year or else our backline stocks are poor.

 

[Tiger_Steve]

Ok so we replace Matterson with Leilua. Not like for like but that’s ok. I’m happy we haven’t lost anything there. But we are still behind where we finished end of last year. Need a hard nosed prop (maybe Packer can be this role) and definitely need pace and impact in the backs - centre or fullback.
Talau, Garner, Twal, Mikaele will all improve I think. We get that prop and an elusive back, then we have an improved, and potentially very competitive, roster.

 

[Newtown]

Any chance of signing the young current Bulldogs winger who plays a good game at fullback. Is a very good goal kicker too.

 

[Fraze23]

Not sure why everyone hates Milf. He’s not the player you want at halfback, but as a runner and instinct ball player, there is not many better than him. Creates something out of nothing almost every game.

Milford is the kind of player who promises the world and delivers an atlas.

 

[OzLuke]

What are Wests Tigers doing regarding a reliable goal kicker?

apart from one glaring miss....I thought Momo did pretty well there.....

 

[Fraze23]

I am most disappointed we missed out on Scott. Yes I know he has his share of problems but he is significantly ahead of any centre option we have not including Talau who is staring is NRL career. With all this money to spend, we should have been all over him. We have to get Lomax this year or else our backline stocks are poor.

Scott is a trainwreck waiting to happen off the field. Talented footballer, but he'd be eaten alive by the Sydney media.

 

[pawsandclaws1]

I am most disappointed we missed out on Scott. Yes I know he has his share of problems but he is significantly ahead of any centre option we have not including Talau who is staring is NRL career. With all this money to spend, we should have been all over him. We have to get Lomax this year or else our backline stocks are poor.

Scott is a trainwreck waiting to happen off the field. Talented footballer, but he'd be eaten alive by the Sydney media.

That is true but our backline is poor.and lacks pace outside of Marshall, Brooks and young Talau. What happened to the young Souths centre/winger Hiroti?

 

[Spud_Murphy]

Any chance of signing the young current Bulldogs winger who plays a good game at fullback. Is a very good goal kicker too.

Meaney? Yes he is a very good player, wasted on the wing imo, though he goes alright there too. Can't see him leaving the Dogs though, he seems quite happy there. Still, money talks if we dangle a big enough carrot 😁

 

[tigerbenji]

Hiroti is a very handy player, no one has grabed him yet, worth a chance.

 

[WT2K]

Cowboys forum saying that Drinkwater will be playing 5/8 for them next season

 

[Viking Warrior]

Just my opinion but I reckon Mbye is an equal fullback as Moylan, it would be a side ways signing. They both had trouble catching this year and Mbye is faster.

 

[Jimmy]

Cowboys forum saying that Drinkwater will be playing 5/8 for them next season

Lol cowgilrs are so dumb, they will now have three support runners in there spine , they need a good game managing half, face is they do, he just needs time to develop in FG....Clifford

 

[Celticguy97]

yeah, what's going to happen to Clifford if Drinkwater is in the halves?

 

[teddy23]

Clifford is the much better half.....