Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

[JC99]

Well well that JAC info backs up what i was already thinking ie he is no chance to come here and all the talk has been his management trying to use us to bump up his price.

Mitchell all over again.

As a winger we barely even need him, start looking elsewhere and spend the cap more wisely.

Heres an idea, a half who can take ownership of our fortunes.

He won’t get fullback money anywhere. We are still a chance at getting him mainly because right now we are one of the few who can afford him



He would want at least 500k.

Id rather spend that elsewhere and run with our current outside backs and rookies.

We need origin level talent and at the moment there’s no other top level players on the market we should takr what we can get. He’ll improve our team

 

[avocadoontoast]

Well well that JAC info backs up what i was already thinking ie he is no chance to come here and all the talk has been his management trying to use us to bump up his price.

Mitchell all over again.

As a winger we barely even need him, start looking elsewhere and spend the cap more wisely.

Heres an idea, a half who can take ownership of our fortunes.

He won’t get fullback money anywhere. We are still a chance at getting him mainly because right now we are one of the few who can afford him

I would love Addo-Carr and I am sure we are doing everything we can to secure him, but I have feeling he won't be coming here..

Yeah even though we are ‘favourites’ id be surprised if we got him

Yep. Next year is going to be painful.

 

[WT2K]

Well well that JAC info backs up what i was already thinking ie he is no chance to come here and all the talk has been his management trying to use us to bump up his price.

Mitchell all over again.

As a winger we barely even need him, start looking elsewhere and spend the cap more wisely.

Heres an idea, a half who can take ownership of our fortunes.

He won’t get fullback money anywhere. We are still a chance at getting him mainly because right now we are one of the few who can afford him

I would love Addo-Carr and I am sure we are doing everything we can to secure him, but I have feeling he won't be coming here..

Even as a destination club, I can't see him coming here either

 

[avocadoontoast]

Well well that JAC info backs up what i was already thinking ie he is no chance to come here and all the talk has been his management trying to use us to bump up his price.

Mitchell all over again.

As a winger we barely even need him, start looking elsewhere and spend the cap more wisely.

Heres an idea, a half who can take ownership of our fortunes.

He won’t get fullback money anywhere. We are still a chance at getting him mainly because right now we are one of the few who can afford him

I would love Addo-Carr and I am sure we are doing everything we can to secure him, but I have feeling he won't be coming here..

Even as a destination club, I can't see him coming here either

The glitz and glamour of playing for WT isn't for everyone.

 

[twentyforty]

Well well that JAC info backs up what i was already thinking ie he is no chance to come here and all the talk has been his management trying to use us to bump up his price.

Mitchell all over again.

As a winger we barely even need him, start looking elsewhere and spend the cap more wisely.

Heres an idea, a half who can take ownership of our fortunes.

He won’t get fullback money anywhere. We are still a chance at getting him mainly because right now we are one of the few who can afford him

I would love Addo-Carr and I am sure we are doing everything we can to secure him, but I have feeling he won't be coming here..

Yeah even though we are ‘favourites’ id be surprised if we got him

Yep. Next year is going to be painful.

We were also favourites to land Mitchell who was also going through a positional transition. ?

 

[rihannafan1]

Nice to see Harry Grant back. Liddle is good but Grant is next level! Would honestly pay him anything to stay a WT. So tough, literally in everything in attack and D. Make him captain and the face of the ? for the next 10 years. Once in a generation dummy half! He will change this club forever if he stays ????

Yep! Completely different team with him.
Grant plays to win,puts his body on the line every game.he had us playing pretty good at one stage this year.
The thought of him at The Storm is scary ?

Maybe we could swap him for Simpkin?

Sure there's a risk involved but they risk losing B Smith if Grant goes back there. We know what Grant can do for us and will do. There won't be lots of players better than him. The odds of Simpkin ever reaching those heights is low.
Risky swap wouldn’t want to see simp play first b4 trading him?

I’d Like to give him a go First could be very special.

Fair enough. I have a feeling we'll find out soon.

Would love to see him this year but can respect club holding him for development, but next year want straight in

We'll see. I know Hartigan had mentioned hoping to get him a run at the end of the year. He's real young and won't have had any game time for a while.

 

[Viking Warrior]

Would people be happy with Gagai if we miss out on Jac? Usually if we miss out on a player we sign who the other club has to let go. That's if south's sign him

 

[the_third]

What other club has almost a million tied up Ipoh the wing? Bulldogs?

 

[The_Patriot]

Well well that JAC info backs up what i was already thinking ie he is no chance to come here and all the talk has been his management trying to use us to bump up his price.

Mitchell all over again.

As a winger we barely even need him, start looking elsewhere and spend the cap more wisely.

Heres an idea, a half who can take ownership of our fortunes.

He won’t get fullback money anywhere. We are still a chance at getting him mainly because right now we are one of the few who can afford him



He would want at least 500k.

Id rather spend that elsewhere and run with our current outside backs and rookies.

We need origin level talent and at the moment there’s no other top level players on the market we should takr what we can get. He’ll improve our team

No denying he is talented but a winger isnt going to fix us.

We need fixing and we need all the money we can find under the cap to address the problem areas.

Signing JAC is counter productive.

If we sign him we will run around with Brooks and Benji again in 2021.

Im out at that point.

 

[avocadoontoast]

Would people be happy with Gagai if we miss out on Jac? Usually if we miss out on a player we sign who the other club has to let go. That's if south's sign him

No.

 

[WT2K]

Would people be happy with Gagai if we miss out on Jac? Usually if we miss out on a player we sign who the other club has to let go. That's if south's sign him

No

 

[tigerap]

Would people be happy with Gagai if we miss out on Jac? Usually if we miss out on a player we sign who the other club has to let go. That's if south's sign him

pass

 

[tigerap]

Well well that JAC info backs up what i was already thinking ie he is no chance to come here and all the talk has been his management trying to use us to bump up his price.

Mitchell all over again.

As a winger we barely even need him, start looking elsewhere and spend the cap more wisely.

Heres an idea, a half who can take ownership of our fortunes.

He won’t get fullback money anywhere. We are still a chance at getting him mainly because right now we are one of the few who can afford him

I would love Addo-Carr and I am sure we are doing everything we can to secure him, but I have feeling he won't be coming here..

He is playing with us lust like LM did.....

 

[2005magic]

Would people be happy with Gagai if we miss out on Jac? Usually if we miss out on a player we sign who the other club has to let go. That's if south's sign him

Nope. I'd take Johnston but not Gagai.

 

[pawsandclaws1]

Well well that JAC info backs up what i was already thinking ie he is no chance to come here and all the talk has been his management trying to use us to bump up his price.

Mitchell all over again.

As a winger we barely even need him, start looking elsewhere and spend the cap more wisely.

Heres an idea, a half who can take ownership of our fortunes.

He won’t get fullback money anywhere. We are still a chance at getting him mainly because right now we are one of the few who can afford him



He would want at least 500k.

Id rather spend that elsewhere and run with our current outside backs and rookies.

We need origin level talent and at the moment there’s no other top level players on the market we should takr what we can get. He’ll improve our team


No denying he is talented but a winger isnt going to fix us.

We need fixing and we need all the money we can find under the cap to address the problem areas.

Signing JAC is counter productive.

If we sign him we will run around with Brooks and Benji again in 2021.

Im out at that point.

Signing a SOO and Aus winger counterproductive?

Lack of genuine pace is our issue. JAC turns half chances into tries.

 

[avocadoontoast]

Well well that JAC info backs up what i was already thinking ie he is no chance to come here and all the talk has been his management trying to use us to bump up his price.

Mitchell all over again.

As a winger we barely even need him, start looking elsewhere and spend the cap more wisely.

Heres an idea, a half who can take ownership of our fortunes.

He won’t get fullback money anywhere. We are still a chance at getting him mainly because right now we are one of the few who can afford him

I would love Addo-Carr and I am sure we are doing everything we can to secure him, but I have feeling he won't be coming here..

He is playing with us lust like LM did.....

I hope not, but I wouldn't be surprised.

 

[The_Patriot]

Well well that JAC info backs up what i was already thinking ie he is no chance to come here and all the talk has been his management trying to use us to bump up his price.

Mitchell all over again.

As a winger we barely even need him, start looking elsewhere and spend the cap more wisely.

Heres an idea, a half who can take ownership of our fortunes.

He won’t get fullback money anywhere. We are still a chance at getting him mainly because right now we are one of the few who can afford him



He would want at least 500k.

Id rather spend that elsewhere and run with our current outside backs and rookies.

We need origin level talent and at the moment there’s no other top level players on the market we should takr what we can get. He’ll improve our team


No denying he is talented but a winger isnt going to fix us.

We need fixing and we need all the money we can find under the cap to address the problem areas.

Signing JAC is counter productive.

If we sign him we will run around with Brooks and Benji again in 2021.

Im out at that point.

Signing a SOO and Aus winger counterproductive?

Lack of genuine pace is our issue. JAC turns half chances into tries.

Good halves create genuine chances not just half chances.

 

[JC99]

Well well that JAC info backs up what i was already thinking ie he is no chance to come here and all the talk has been his management trying to use us to bump up his price.

Mitchell all over again.

As a winger we barely even need him, start looking elsewhere and spend the cap more wisely.

Heres an idea, a half who can take ownership of our fortunes.

He won’t get fullback money anywhere. We are still a chance at getting him mainly because right now we are one of the few who can afford him



He would want at least 500k.

Id rather spend that elsewhere and run with our current outside backs and rookies.

We need origin level talent and at the moment there’s no other top level players on the market we should takr what we can get. He’ll improve our team


No denying he is talented but a winger isnt going to fix us.

We need fixing and we need all the money we can find under the cap to address the problem areas.

Signing JAC is counter productive.

If we sign him we will run around with Brooks and Benji again in 2021.

Im out at that point.

I agree that he won’t fix our problems but what halves are available? Not many good ones. Think the club wants Reynolds gone before spending on a half as well. May as well get the origin level winger while we can

 

[The_Patriot]

Well well that JAC info backs up what i was already thinking ie he is no chance to come here and all the talk has been his management trying to use us to bump up his price.

Mitchell all over again.

As a winger we barely even need him, start looking elsewhere and spend the cap more wisely.

Heres an idea, a half who can take ownership of our fortunes.

He won’t get fullback money anywhere. We are still a chance at getting him mainly because right now we are one of the few who can afford him



He would want at least 500k.

Id rather spend that elsewhere and run with our current outside backs and rookies.

We need origin level talent and at the moment there’s no other top level players on the market we should takr what we can get. He’ll improve our team


No denying he is talented but a winger isnt going to fix us.

We need fixing and we need all the money we can find under the cap to address the problem areas.

Signing JAC is counter productive.

If we sign him we will run around with Brooks and Benji again in 2021.

Im out at that point.

I agree that he won’t fix our problems but what halves are available? Not many good ones. Think the club wants Reynolds gone before spending on a half as well. May as well get the origin level winger while we can

Thatd be like buying ice cream with half of your weekly budget before buying the milk and bread.

 

[Newtown]

Well well that JAC info backs up what i was already thinking ie he is no chance to come here and all the talk has been his management trying to use us to bump up his price.

Mitchell all over again.

As a winger we barely even need him, start looking elsewhere and spend the cap more wisely.

Heres an idea, a half who can take ownership of our fortunes.

He won’t get fullback money anywhere. We are still a chance at getting him mainly because right now we are one of the few who can afford him

I would love Addo-Carr and I am sure we are doing everything we can to secure him, but I have feeling he won't be coming here..

I remember that until recently JAC was managing his own affairs but very recently signed a manager to look after his dealings. Could it be this manager who is pushing JAC to ask for fullback money even though JAC hasn't played fullback for years? His manager must think that Wests tigers are stupid.