Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

[teddy23]

A line up of the following would look ok.
1. Moylan
2. Nofo
3. Joey L
4. Momo / Mmbye / Talau
5. JAC
6. AD
7. Brooks

1. Joseph Suaalli
2. David Nofoaluma
3. Tommy Talau
4. BJ Leilua
5. Josh Addo-Carr
6. Adam Doueihi
7. Luke Brooks

Looks better to me idk.....

 

[mike]

Why in earth anyone would want injury prone Moylan here is beyond belief. He would add absolutely nothing to our squad and just drain more funds which can be better used to recruit actual useful players.

 

[Jedi_Tiger]

Sualli would be great for us to get

 

[ElleryHanley]

Any truth to the rumour swap Moylan to tigers and Josh reynolds to sharks ?


Is there any benefit in that for the players or clubs? I can’t see a benefit for WT after Moylan has already scrubbed us?

When we were rumoured to be signing him (last year?) I wasn't a huge fan. But if it's a straight swap for someone who never plays anyway, he could be a handy pick up.


Agreed. If a straight swap and for only one year I cant see a downside. Moylan isnt worth that kind of money but is a much better player than Reynolds.

Josh has ONE year left...

Moylan has TWO...so his deal is worth almost 900 000 more than Josh.

Any swap would have to be massively subsidized by Cronulla or else it would be a disaster for us.

 

[Jedi_Tiger]

a player swap for next year and a subsidised loan deal for the last year

 

[WeststigsRdaBest]

1.Suaalii
2.nofo
3.talau
4.Kei
5.graham/Jac
6.AD
7.Brooks

Care to dream anyone?

 

[Tiger5150]

Why in earth anyone would want injury prone Moylan here is beyond belief. He would add absolutely nothing to our squad and just drain more funds which can be better used to recruit actual useful players.

I think everyone agrees with you Mike, but not if its a swap for REynolds. If we cant offload Reynolds, replacing him with a better player would be next best.

 

[Tiger5150]

Any truth to the rumour swap Moylan to tigers and Josh reynolds to sharks ?


Is there any benefit in that for the players or clubs? I can’t see a benefit for WT after Moylan has already scrubbed us?

When we were rumoured to be signing him (last year?) I wasn't a huge fan. But if it's a straight swap for someone who never plays anyway, he could be a handy pick up.


Agreed. If a straight swap and for only one year I cant see a downside. Moylan isnt worth that kind of money but is a much better player than Reynolds.

Josh has ONE year left...

Moylan has TWO...so his deal is worth almost 900 000 more than Josh.

Any swap would have to be massively subsidized by Cronulla or else it would be a disaster for us.

Agreed, which is why my post included the ***if***

 

[hammertime]

I read somewhere we have released Momirovski - anyone aware?

Where did you read that?

 

[dazza65]

jeez didn't know we release Mommo wow

Could be wrong - cant remember where I read it, was seeking clarification from anyone as it hasn't been announced by WT as far as I know

 

[teddy23]

Sualli would be great for us to get

I think people underestimate how gettable he is for us rn

Practically guaranteed he won’t be at Souths as officials have confirmed, while South also refuse to release him too arch rivals the Roosters and us being the only other club interested so far with Madge having a strong relationship with him where he’ll be able to get his money and preferred position - don’t think ARU could even afford him knowing they’re collapsing by the day

The kids more hyped than Ponga was and look how good that turned out, while also getting GI and Tom Turbo comparisons can’t see why anyone would be against it, the natural talent he possess for anyone that’s watched him you’d understand there’s no ceiling for him he can be anything... I understand the whole he seems full of himself and not someone to build a team around attitude wise bc of contract negotiations rumours but he’s still a kid and I’m sure that’s more management than him from what I’ve been told there isn’t a harder trainer going around than Suallii himself hence probs why Madge rates him so highly

Just my two cents tho

 

[jadtiger]

So trade / swap an injury prone $800+K bench player for what ... another injury prone $800+K player ... great just great.


As much as Josh Reynolds has had a tough time at the Tigers at least he comes across as a decent bloke who is liked by his peers.

Moylan comes across as a gold-star douche who's managed to get most of his playing cohorts offside.

For the sake of team harmony I hope this isn't true.

Moylan is a massive downgrade on Reynolds not to mention the poor effect on team harmony he has caused at he 2 clubs he has played at

 

[happy_tiger]

Any person mentioning Moylan ...obviously hasn't either watched him the last 2 years or looked at his Wiki bio to see how many games he has played from actual possible games played

PASS PASS PASS PASS PASS PASS PASS PASS

 

[Tim Sheens]

People on this forum really don’t let stuff go.... not everyone is Adam Blair or Rob Jennings.

I’m not even sure who would he considered a good player lol you have to be in a crap team and perform good to count as good I think ?

It’s fairly simple

JAC is an elite player who will instantly improve any team he goes too

Graham is an average player who won’t improve a team like ours one tiny bit, I would honestly prefer Momirovski to him. He is the exact player we need to steer clear of

CG is light years ahead of Momirovski. I’d take him if he was available, he’d be our best centre since the early day of Chris Lawrence.

We need pace and that is a commodity Campbell Graham lacks. If you watch him on a chase he is so slow.

Yeah, though if there is pace around him that changes the dynamic.

 

[TigerWest]

Sualli would be great for us to get

I don't think he has played NRL, so not sure how you could think that?

 

[Jedi_Tiger]

seen him play for kings a few times he looks good. Souths and Bennett were very keen good enough for me to take a punt on. Look at Ponga and benji they had wraps before they started too

 

[mike]

Why in earth anyone would want injury prone Moylan here is beyond belief. He would add absolutely nothing to our squad and just drain more funds which can be better used to recruit actual useful players.


I think everyone agrees with you Mike, but not if its a swap for REynolds. If we cant offload Reynolds, replacing him with a better player would be next best.

Swapping one injury prone play for another is just insanity. We will gain nothing.

 

[TSupps05]

I will be very annoyed if we release momo i actually quite like him

 

[twentyforty]

So trade / swap an injury prone $800+K bench player for what ... another injury prone $800+K player ... great just great.


As much as Josh Reynolds has had a tough time at the Tigers at least he comes across as a decent bloke who is liked by his peers.

Moylan comes across as a gold-star douche who's managed to get most of his playing cohorts offside.

For the sake of team harmony I hope this isn't true.

Similar to my take. Not much difference in the on field performances, bit like kissing your sister. But because they spend most of their time off the field JRey wins by a nostril with his demeanour. Moylan eats too many lemons.

 

[pawsandclaws1]

I will be very annoyed if we release momo i actually quite like him

Is he enjoying the Sunshine Coast?